Bank of England 'gambling with cut and quantitative easing'

Thursday, 5 March 2009

The Bank of England has made a leap in the dark and is gambling its latest interest rate cut and the injection of £75 billion in new money into the economy will kick-start lending and spending, a senior economist said today.

Philip McDonagh, of business advisors PricewaterhouseCoopers said the bank had made a leap of faith.

The reduction of interest rates to an historic low of just 0.5% was about as far as they can go in using interest rates to try to regenerate the economy, according to PwC.

The Monetary Policy Committee's new weapon in the battle against the credit crunch - quantitative easing - will see the Bank of England buy up to £75 billion of securities over the next three months.

Frequently, but wrongly described as printing new money, quantitative easing does not boost the amount of money in circulation by freshly minting and printing new coins and notes, said PwC.

Instead, said the businesses advisors, the Bank will buy assets like government securities - gilts - and high quality corporate bonds.

In theory the money it pays for the assets is then available to commercial banks to lend to businesses and consumers.

Mr McDonagh said low base rates, plus quantitative easing, equalled more money in circulation and a real reduction in both short term and long term borrowing.

"Hopefully that will re-inflate bank reserves, increase the flow of lending and instil investment confidence. This is new territory for the Bank of England, but there are some experiences they can draw on," he said.

Japan used quantitative easing in 1990s as a last resort to regenerate its economy and the US was currently pursuing a similar policy of buying back Treasury and corporate debt, he added.

But Mr McDonagh said: "Explaining quantitative easing is difficult enough; making it work will be a real challenge.

"For the Bank of England, this is a real leap of faith - and also a leap in the dark."

PwC said the bank's decision on bank rates would not be welcomed by savers who would now earn virtually nothing and by mortgage lenders who relied on savers' deposits to fund new mortgages.

Meanwhile the Federation of Small Business welcomed the interest rate cut, but said access to finance rather than the cost of it was the main concern for small businesses.

FSB policy chairman Wilfred Mitchell said polls of members suggested recent interest rate cuts - six in almost as many months - were not having the desired effect and other means of economic stimulus were required.

"Small businesses are clearly worried that this monetary policy has been used extensively over the last few months yet they are still struggling to access cheaper finance.

"The concern now is that if rates are cut any further there may not be too much more room for manoeuvre in the economy.

"The onus is really on the banks to start promoting these lower rates to fire up the economy," he said.

The Northern Ireland Independent Retail Trade Association said interest rate cuts were more or less at the end of the road and it was to be hoped quantitative easing would have the right impact on the economy.

Chief executive Glyn Roberts said: "While the repeated interest rate cuts have been helpful to consumers and businesses, we are still not seeing any real recovery in consumer spending."

He said the 2.5% VAT reduction before Christmas had little or no success in encouraging consumer spending.

"We would urge the Chancellor to end the VAT cut and use the intended funds for reducing front line taxes for hard-pressed families and for businesses struggling to survive in this recession."

It is generally thought that there is wealth in the older populations pockets. Cutting savings intrest to this section of the community means they stop spending in shops, travel agents etc and cease to put further funds in the hands of banks and mortgage lenders. How can this help the economy?

Posted by D Morton | 05.03.09, 18:09 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

In Pictures: CIPR PRide Awards

In Pictures: CIPR PRide Awards

Pub of the Year Awards

Digital Advertising Awards Gala

Digital Advertising Awards Gala

Digital Advertising Awards Gala

Carbon Rankings - UK's Top 100 Firms

Click here for rankings and video

TeleBest: World's most powerful logos

eleBest: World's most powerful logos

Click here to launch gallery

NI's Top 100 Companies 2011

Top 100 Companies

Who's up and who's down in 2011

In pictures: Doing the business

  • PMST Apprentice of the Year 2011
  • Graham Dillon of Tandragee, Co Armagh (centre), accepts the Adult Apprentice Award: Best Attendance at the PMST Apprentice of the Year 2011 ceremony held this week in Belfast City Hall. Also pictured are Keith Poole (left) of CHC Group, Craigavon, who employ Graham, and Nick Hayward of category sponser ATL
  • Ciara Walls of Whitehead, Co Antrim (centre), accepts the Adult Apprentice Award: Most Consistently High Exam Results, at the PMST Apprentice of the Year 2011 ceremony held this week in Belfast City Hall. Also pictured is Professor Jackie McCoy (right) of the University of Ulster, the category sponsor, and Nicola Cherry of Fusion Heating of Killyleagh, Co Down, who employ Ciara

Cream of the crop in the business world

BT Business TV


Business Digest by Email


Sign up for your free weekly business newsletter

Latest Comments