CLICK HERE TO GET YOUR BELFAST TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR EVERY DAY

Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

Northern Rock shareholders stage protests outside branches

Monday, 12 January 2009

Angry Northern Rock shareholders took part in demonstrations today ahead of a court hearing into levels of Government compensation.

A bus load of small shareholders protested outside three branches of the nationalised bank in central London before moving on to the Treasury and the House of Commons.

They accused the Government of "sacrificing" ordinary people, saying investors - many of them pensioners - will receive little or no money back for their shares.

At a judicial review in the High Court, which starts tomorrow, the shareholders will argue a Government-commissioned valuation of shares is in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights.

They will argue the Treasury's criteria for valuing the shares falsely assume the bank was in administration, was no longer a going concern and was no longer receiving financial assistance.

And they will contrast the Government's conduct in the Northern Rock rescue with its later acquisition of stakes in other banks, such as Bradford & Bingley, whose shareholders were not wiped out.

The case is based on the principle, enshrined in human rights law, that the taking of property by the State without payment of an amount reasonably related to its value will normally constitute a disproportionate interference with property rights.

It is being brought by three shareholder groups - hedge funds SRM Global and RAB Capital, as well as a representative group of private shareholders supported by the UK Shareholder Action Group (UKSA), which organised today's activities.

More than 30 demonstrators, including former Northern Rock employees, took part in the demonstrations.

They waved placards and queued outside branches - a reminder of the scenes in September 2007 when long lines of savers queued to withdraw their money.

Dennis Grainger, 62, from Cramlington in Northumberland, the lead claimant for the small shareholders, said it was the "small people" who would lose the most.

"They are not speculators and they are not playing the markets, but they are older people who are using their dividend income to supplement their meagre pensions.

"In some cases the shares were a nest egg for sons and daughters, families and grandchildren."

Mr Grainger, who worked as an assistant in finance at Northern Rock for 10 years, estimates he will lose a total of £114,000 in shares.

"Now it looks as though the shares are worth nothing. I'm not fighting the compensation because I lost the money myself, it's because I don't like the idea that the small people, the salt of the earth people, have been rubbished by the Government.

"A lot of people feel they've been sacrificed on the cross of other financial mismanagement in the City.

"All we're looking for is to be treated fairly, but the Government are refusing to back down and admit they've made a mistake."

A valuation expert appointed by the shareholders has valued Northern Rock shares, at the time of nationalisation, at no lower than £3 each and probably much more.

The same expert concluded that applying the false assumption that Northern Rock was in administration would almost inevitably result in a nil valuation.

Chair of the UKSA Roger Lawson, 63, from Chislehurst in south-east London, said: "Clearly the Government wants to pay nothing. The company was not bust, it was not in administration and yet the Government chooses to nationalise it. They should pay compensation."

Doreen Shannon, 53, from Fulwell in Sunderland, whose husband worked for Northern Rock for 20 years as an analyst, said their retirement plans, which included a trip to Australia to visit family, were "up the spout".

The former IT lecturer at South Tyneside College said: "We think the Government is acting totally unfairly and treating Northern Rock totally differently from the way it's treating the other banks. Is that because it's a northern bank?

"We planned our retirement specifically with our savings in mind. The Government is taking our property and is dictating to us how much we will get for that property."

The hearing is scheduled to last three-and-a-half-days.

If the Government loses, it will be forced to reconsider the terms of reference given to valuers so as to reflect what the shareholders say is the true value.

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

The Government should be thoroughly ashamed of itself stealing from share holders in such a disgraceful manner.

The people that they are really hurting are those who have worked hard and have tried to save something from what little they may have left after already being taxed to the hilt by an administration that has lost its way completely in economic and fiscal policy.

They should back down now and pay proper compensation. If they do not how will anyone trust them in the future and who on earth will vote Labour at the next election?

Posted by mrnachos | 13.01.09, 18:54 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

What a digcrace. The government have acted in a rediculous manner over this whole issue. How can it be fair to steal property from individuals and then, after the fact tell them how much (or how little) they will get?

What next - will alistair darling be buying up houses, evicting the residents and giving them 50p for their trouble?

Admit the mistake and pay fair compensation before this government gets more of an Arthur Daley reputation please!

Posted by Christian Balmer | 13.01.09, 09:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

the goverment are no better bank robbers stealing peoples shares

Posted by mr rothery | 12.01.09, 18:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

NI Travel and Tourism Awards

  • Sean Crummey entertains guests at the Northern Ireland Travel and Tourism Awards 2009
  • Sean Crummey, Maureen Ledwith and Nan Short with Craig Doyle at the Slieve Donard Resort and Spa at the Northern Ireland Travel and Tourism Awards 2009
  • Rowan Devereux and Ciaran Mulligan of Blue Insurances with Craig Doyle at the Slieve Donard Resort and Spa at the Northern Ireland Travel and Tourism Awards 2009

NI Travel and Tourism Awards

Deloitte Technology Fast 50 Awards

  • From left to right, Daniel McRitchie (Andor Technology, placed 48 in this year?s Fast 50 ranking); Mark McCusker (Texthelp Systems Ltd, placed 40th in this year?s Fast 50 ranking); Trevor Jordan (Andor Technology); and Seamus Scullion (Texthelp Systems Ltd).
  • James Greer, proprietor of Greer Publications, presents the ?Rising Star? award to Mary McKenna and Paul McElvaney of Learning Pool Ltd.
  • From left to right: Daniel McRitchie and Trevor Jordan of Andor Technology.

Deloitte Technology Fast 50 Awards

CEF Construction Awards 2009

  • CEF Construction Awards 2009
  • CEF Construction Awards 2009
  • CEF Construction Awards 2009

CEF Construction Awards 2009

Newry Chamber of Commerce Banquet

  • Newry Chamber of Commerce Banquet. Thursday 8 October 09
  • Newry Chamber of Commerce Banquet. Thursday 8 October 09
  • Newry Chamber of Commerce Banquet. Thursday 8 October 09

Newry Chamber of Commerce Banquet

Connecting Employers to Communities

  • The Connecting Employers to Communities event hosted at Hillsborough Castle by Business in the Community on 23 September 2009.
  • The Connecting Employers to Communities event hosted at Hillsborough Castle by Business in the Community on 23 September 2009.
  • The Connecting Employers to Communities event hosted at Hillsborough Castle by Business in the Community on 23 September 2009.

Connecting Employers to Communities

Ulster Tatler Awards 2009

tatler awards.

In pictures: Doing the business

  • Christmas appeal for children launched
Business in the Community?s Cares programme has launched its Cares At Christmas appeal with charity Action for Children to help companies and individuals make a difference to vulnerable youngsters. From left to right are Sam Davidson, human resources director at sponsors Henderson Group, Maureen Taggart, chair of Cares Leadership Team and Louise Ward-Hunter, strategic director of Action for Children. To register interest in the appeal, email caresni@bitcni.org.uk
  • The outstanding global performance of Northern Ireland accountancy students has been recognised at the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants (ACCA) Awards in Belfast. Not only did three local students take top place in Ireland but there were also three performances in ACCA?s global top ten and a further five in the top 20. Hazel Bradbury joined Keith McManus, president of the ACCA?s Ulster Branch to celebrate coming 8th out of 24,000 global participants and first in Ireland in the audit assurance exam.
  • Revamped Stena vessel ship-shape for Scotland voyage
Former Miss Northern Ireland Judith Wilson puts the finishing touches to the Stena Navigator to ensure it?s in ship-shape condition for its first voyage since its return. The upgraded Stena Line ship sets sail from Belfast to Stranraer tomorrow. The vessel, which caters for both passenger and freight traffic and has a capacity of up to 1,500 passengers and up to 280 cars or 50 lorries, means the ferry company now offers up to 14 crossings on the route each day. The addition of the Navigator and a £2m upgrade programme, which has been carried out in Belfast Port over the past month, represents a total investment in the route of over £6m

Cream of the crop in the business world

NI's Top 100 Companies

Top 100 Companies

Who's up and who's down in 2009


Business Digest by Email

Sign up for your free weekly business newsletter