Belfast Telegraph

Thursday 18 December 2014

DebateNI home of Northern Ireland politics

Political unionism and Orangeism's 'graduated response' to Ardoyne parade determination will be tactically short sighted

PSNI officers stand firm as trouble flared in the Ardoyne area on the Twelfth of July in 2013. Pic Charles McQuillan/Pacemaker
PSNI officers stand firm as trouble flared in the Ardoyne area on the Twelfth of July in 2013. Pic Charles McQuillan/Pacemaker

The nature of political unionism and Orangeism's "graduated response" to the Ardoyne determination will be tactically short sighted – albeit involving tactics which may have repercussions for the political situation and potentially events on the ground.

The position adopted to date, (including the stage managed walk out from party leader talks, asserting that the institutions are under threat, the avoidance of the North South Ministerial Council, combined with the Orange declaration that governance in the north will be impacted), throws up real strategic questions for unionism, and what it expects to achieve.

Whenever pan-unionism has mobilised around rejectionist goals, the most extremist elements have always set the agenda, and political instability, unrest and violence occur.

That’s exactly what happened during the unionist strikes in 1974/77, against the Anglo Irish Agreement in 1985, during the Drumcree crisis in 1996/97, throughout the last two years, and specifically arising from the organised protest at Twaddell last July.

Unless proper leadership is provided within political unionism, and the extremists within the orange order are shunned, this society can have no confidence that anything different will happen this time.

Political unionism is not committed to power sharing and partnership government, and is opposed to managing the ongoing process of change in the north. Blaming the Parades Commission for putting the political institutions under threat is a smoke screen for a significant crisis of leadership within political unionism.

In turn the default position for the unionist parties and paramilitaries becomes a retreat into another (temporary) pan unionist front, and the formation of an explicit anti-Agreement axis.

Contested parades are a vexed issue and must be resolved. Political unionism’s “graduated response” is a sham.  It has nothing to do with unresolved parades, and everything to do with opposition to the Good Friday Agreement framework and principles, power sharing, and partnership government.

However, for political unionism to move away from that template will be like setting off on a journey into the wilderness without the satellite navigation switched on.

The Good Friday and other agreements, and existing power sharing arrangements are the only show in town.

A pro-Agreement axis is required. The Irish and British governments, supported by the US administration must now take the lead.

There is only one direction for the political process - that’s forward - towards a new phase of the Peace Process. 

Political unionism should accept that reality, and get back to the talks table. Much better 'Plan A'. So, let’s make it work, properly.

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk