Belfast Telegraph

Monday 26 January 2015

Great British Bake Off 'bin-cident': Ofcom may investigate row over Iain Watters' Baked Alaska

The baked Alaska incident which ultimately led to the Belfast-born baker Iain Watters walking away from the competition
The baked Alaska incident which ultimately led to the Belfast-born baker Iain Watters walking away from the competition

Justice could be served for Belfast baker Iain Watters after Great British Bake Off viewers complained to Ofcom about the "bin-cident" that saw him cruelly booted off the BBC show.

The communications watchdog could launch an investigation into the row as a baker's dozen - 13 - viewers have complained, with 12 of them concerned at the apparent sabotage of Mr Watters' Baked Alaska.

Another 811 have complained directly to the BBC.

The 31-year-old bearded baker lost his cool when his pudding melted after rival contestant Diana Beard took it out of the freezer - leading Mr Watters to throw it in the bin.

The controversy whipped up anger among viewers who accused Mrs Beard, 69, of sabotaging the pudding, and she quit the show due to ill health just after the episode was filmed.

Their complaints are being assessed while Ofcom decides whether to investigate.

#JusticeforIain: Sign our petition here

Diana Bird removes Iain's pudding from the freezer
Diana Bird removes Iain's pudding from the freezer

Mr Watters was voted off the show after presenting judges Mary Berry and Paul Hollywood with a bin when they asked to see his dessert, and his departure sparked a Twitter campaign with the hashtags BringIainBack and justiceforiain, calling for him to make a return.

Speaking on BBC's Newsnight programme, when asked if he would be making a comeback, he teased viewers by saying: "You will have to watch next week."

He added that he had spoken to Mrs Beard since and had no hard feelings.

He said: "I knew it was going to be quite a big thing as it was a big thing that happened on the show. The reaction has been crazy, there were a lot of comments on Twitter. It's been really nice support and really built up overnight.

"I was more frustrated and it was just the heat of the moment. In the last half-hour of the show it got very tense.

"I've spoken to (Diana) and she's fine."

Yesterday judge Hollywood responded to the Twitter storm by saying: "Ice cream being left out of fridge last night for 40 seconds did not destroy Iain's chances in the bake off, what did was his decision BIN."He added that he had spoken to Mrs Beard since and had no hard feelings.

Read more:

Mrs Beard revealed she left the show just before filming began on episode five after a freak fall severed her olfactory nerve, robbing her of her sense of smell.

After she complained that the show had been edited to make it look as though she sabotaged her rival's chances, the BBC then announced that Mrs Beard would not be appearing in episode five, explaining that she "fell ill" ahead of filming.

But she has since clarified that she "fainted" and banged her head during supper with the other contestants just before production of the episode was due to start.

Mrs Beard, who lives near Whitchurch, Shropshire, said: "I fainted - which I have never done - and bashed my head, severing my olfactory nerve.

"So I have now lost my sense of smell and most of my taste."

She added that she has some sensation of foods which are very salty or vinegary, but has been told by a specialist that nothing medically can be done to repair the damage and she may never fully recover her senses.

"It could have been worse, and I am counting my blessings," said Mrs Beard, who used to run an upholstery business.

She said the announcement that she would not be returning for episode five had been brought forward by the BBC following the furore in which some members of the public branded her "evil".

"At least people will know I haven't wimped out," she said.

"It's a relief, as people now know the truth."

The programme was filmed in the spring.

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Nightlife Galleries


Latest Entertainment News

Latest Music News

Latest Film & TV News

Latest Eating Out News


Your Horoscopes by Russell Grant


You exude grace and charm. Don't be surprised when everybody wants to be seen with you. You create an aura of glamour wherever you go. If you're looking for love, you could find it with someone who has recently moved to the area. Offer to show this newcomer all the hotspots. Are you already in a relationship? You and your amour will benefit from a mini-break. Visit a nearby city or village that appeals to you both. You'll enjoy spending quality time together.More