Enniskillen: 20 years on
On November 8, Enniskillen marks the 20th anniversary of the remembrance day bombing. a total of 11 people died and 63 were injured when an IRA explosion went off during the commemoration ceremony for the dead of the two World Wars. The Belfast Telegraph looks at how the atrocity affected the Republican movement - and the difficulties with efforts to bring the perpetrators to justice two decades later
Friday, 2 November 2007
Twenty years on and the police investigation into the Enniskillen bomb has just entered a new phase with officers from the Historical Enquiries Team meeting the families of the 11 people murdered that day.
The team was set up by PSNI Chief Constable Sir Hugh Orde specifically to
provide the relatives of the 3,268 people killed during the Troubles with
answers about how their loved ones died and to seek out opportunities to
gather additional evidence against those responsible.
In looking at
Enniskillen now the team is treating the atrocity as an exceptional case.
Its 100 officers have been dealing with the murders in chronological order.
Starting with 1969 they are believed to have reached the early '70s. Had
Enniskillen not been "exempted" from this rule and taken out of
sequence the team's investigation of the events of November 8, 1987, would
still be a long way down the line.
A source stressed: "There
have been some meetings with families but this process is at the very
earliest stage of review."
The team will be reviewing a case
in which there is precious little evidence. Much of what is known about the
attack is based on intelligence and the word of informers.
A former
RUC officer with detailed knowledge of the investigation believes the
bombing of Enniskillen was not the work of an individual unit but was
carried out by a team made up of personnel drawn from IRA units in
Enniskillen, Kinawley/Derrylin, Donegal and Monaghan.
"That
indicates that it would probably have been organised at a higher level,"
he explains.
This was to be a major co-ordinated attack on the
Remembrance Day services in Enniskillen and at Tullyhommon, on the
Fermanagh/Donegal Border, where a landmine planted where children were
assembling for a church parade failed to detonate.
For such a
specialised operation the IRA would have drawn together its most trusted
personnel.
According to the former RUC man components for the
Enniskillen bomb were supplied by a senior figure from the South East
Fermanagh and Monaghan Border area and it was assembled by an explosives
expert in Donegal. It was planted in the former Reading Rooms beside the
Cenotaph by members of the Enniskillen and Derrylin/Kinawley unit.
The former RUC man believes the location of the bomb points to at least one
of those involved in the attack. He says that in 1972 an IRA unit was using
the Reading Rooms as a base. One night while the terrorists were assembling
an incendiary bomb it exploded prematurely and a number of people were
injured. They went on the run and fled to Donegal where one of them became a
central figure in the local IRA unit, bringing with him detailed information
about the lay-out of the Reading Rooms where the bomb was placed and
exploded to such deadly effect.
When the dead and injured had been
pulled from the rubble and the dust finally settled police were left with
very little physical evidence in terms of fingerprints, fibres and the
signature marks of the bomb maker.
Detective Chief Superintendent
Norman Baxter, who was involved in a major review of the case in 2004, says:
"There were limited forensic opportunities due to the scale of the
devastation."
Officers took statements from numerous witnesses.
"There was very, very good co-operation from the public," states DCS
Baxter.
"But through stealth and good planning they (the IRA)
were able to plant it with minimal opportunities for people to see them
doing it," he explains.
He is convinced that there are people
out there who know who was involved and have not come forward with that
information, and he called on them to do so, even at this late stage.
Having examined the evidence in the case DCS Baxter is in no doubt about the
bombers' aim.
"Their intention was to inflict casualties. The
only mistake in the operation was that the bomb went off before the parade
arrived. If they had killed 11 soldiers and 11 civilians it would have been
a success. They would have said the 11 civilians were 'unfortunate
casualties,' 'collaterral damage.' The victims were of no consideration,"
he states.
"Before the Historical Enquiries Team was set up we
had carried out a full review of the investigation here in Enniskillen and a
number of new lines of enquiry were identified and a number of new potential
suspects identified," he adds.
All of that information was
passed to the Historical Enquiries Team at the beginning of this year.
DCS Baxter says that in the immediate aftermath of the bombing the republican
leaderships' only consideration was how to extricate themselves from what
was a public relations disaster and minimise the damage to the organisation
and the flow of money from America.
"My assessment, having
reviewed the material, is that the leadership put in place a strategy to
support the individuals within the units that carried out the atrocity.
There was no exodus from the IRA in Fermanagh and Donegal over the incident
and indeed some believe the death and destruction at the cenotaph was a
success," he says.
However, the fallout from the bombing left
the terrorists looking nervously over their shoulders.
"The
public mood within republican and nationalist areas across Northern Ireland
was one of revulsion and there was an erosion of financial and public
co-operation in the weeks following Enniskillen which undermined confidence
in IRA military operations where they had major concerns that they couldn't
depend on being able to hide within communities for fear of the revulsion
caused by Enniskillen leading people to pass information to police. There
was a complete decline in violence over a period of months," recalls
DCS Baxter.
In his view: "The bombing was an attack on
everything decent in society; on unarmed civilians at prayer. If you see
them(the IRA) as an army, it was a war crime. This was murder without
remorse."
He believes the atrocity led to a rethinking of its
strategy by the Sinn Fein leadership and eventually to the talks between
party president Gerry Adams and John Hume of the SDLP and the beginning of
the Peace Process.
Jim Dixon, one of the survivors of the bombing,
has been highly critical of the police investigation, and Aileen Quinton,
whose mother Alberta was killed in the explosion, has also asked questions
about why police have failed to bring the perpetrators justice.
A
PSNI spokesman said: "The police are as frustrated as all the families
and all the victims that no-one has been made amenable. Obviously the police
haven't suffered the same pain. There are a number of officers who have put
a large part of their careers and lives into trying to get somewhere with
this. Frustration and regret are the two continuing emotions."
DCS Baxter adds: "I can understand how they feel that the criminal
justice system has failed them. It is not only the police that have failed
them but society has failed them; people in their own community whose family
members were involved in scouting the bomb in. The wider republican movement
knows (who carried out the bombing)."
Even if the Historical
Enquiries Team makes a breakthrough in the investigation and brings the
perpetrators to justice, under the terms of the Good Friday Agreement anyone
convicted of committing a terrorist offence prior to the IRA ceasefire of
1994 can be sentenced to no more than two years in prison.
A black time for republicanism
If the Enniskillen Bomb had been a deliberate attempt to murder civilians
then it would have been political suicide for Sinn Fein, according to party
spokesman Brian McCaffrey.
It undermined electoral support and set
back republican political ambitions by 10 years, and 20 years later is
something republicans are still "very uncomfortable" with.
"In all of the years of the republican struggle it's probably the
blackest period there was, with the possible exception of the '81 Hunger
Strike, and I think the period that most threatened the existence of that
struggle," states Mr McCaffrey.
"It's still something
that makes republicans very uncomfortable; maybe for some, even difficult to
talk about, because they just find it very, very hard to deal with in terms
of its scale and effect and maybe also from the point of view that there's a
certain amount of collective guilt."
Mr McCaffrey was one of
eight Sinn Fein members of Fermanagh District Council in 1987 and recalls
his reaction to the scale of the carnage.
"I think it was
basically the same reaction by all republicans: How could this happen? I
can't actually recall anyone complaining directly to me about it but
republicans and their supporters would have been absolutely shocked by it,"
Mr McCaffrey remembers.
"In the days following there seemed to
be a push by politicians, media and some church people to portray it as a
deliberate act against civilians. I think probably republicans at that stage
would have been thinking 'this wasn't intentional'.
"I believe
that most republicans felt it was unacceptable. It had put republicans under
serious pressure and obviously this whole spin that this was a deliberate
attack on the civilian population was, at the very least, undermining the
struggle. The purpose of the spin was to finish off the republican struggle.
To me this was a cynical exploitation of the tragedy. That was how I saw it
at the time," he adds.
Mr McCaffrey recalls the pressure put
on his party colleague and then council chairman, Paul Corrigan.
Mr
McCaffrey believes the bombing set back Sinn Fein's political progress by 10
years.
He accepts: "A certain amount of our support base did
walk away.
While support remained steadfast among those who
believed the bombing was not a deliberate attack on civilians, many
nationalists were not prepared to support Sinn Fein.
He says the
seeds of what became known as the Peace Process were sown before the bombing
but the explosion served to focus minds on the process.
Mr
McCaffrey says that over the past 20 years he has spoken to unionists who
would have accepted that republicans "were sorry and believed it
shouldn't have happened".
"I think there's that
collective guilt from all republicans in that they would feel it was totally
unacceptable to attack ordinary people at a Remembrance Ceremony."
He adds: "Had it been something deliberate it would also have been
political suicide. There will always be those who refuse to accept any kind
of apology from republicans. I can't change that but that doesn't make our
apologies any less genuine."
Post a comment
Limit: 500 characters
View all comments that have been posted about this article
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use
Also in this section
- She speaks! Moss comes clean in rare interview
- Nelson Mandela: a man of all the people
