Alternative Christmas
Thursday, December 21, 2006
As Christians prepare to celebrate one of their most important religious
dates, Chrissie Russell and Jane Hardy speak to people with a different take
on December 25
Buddhist
Gen Drolkar (57) is a Buddhist nun and teacher attached to the Potala
Buddhist Centre at Donegall Pass, Belfast
As Buddhists, we try to fit in and do whatever everybody else wants to do.
There are no particular routines at Christmas, but some people like to go on
retreat, and sometimes Buddhist centres put on a special meditation session.
A few years ago, I went to a Buddhist retreat over Christmas, held in York.
On the day itself, we had a big party and they put on a play about the life
of Buddha, but that was a bit unusual.
In terms of food, we had a vegetarian meal with a large nut roast, and there
was present-giving. We gave each other books, cards and things you could buy
at the Dharma shop.
People often say the real spirit of Christmas has been lost and we try to
reinstate it; part of my job is doing workshops on giving and generosity,
which is relevant at this time of year.
All Buddha means is 'enlightened being', which could be Jesus or you or
anyone else. We're pretty tolerant and say that if the Christian teaching
works for you, good.
We'd probably recommend giving Christmas presents unconditionally, without
attachment and without working out what you're going to get in return. All
we wish is for people to practise some form of spirituality and to enjoy
Christmas.
Humanist
Humanists Les and Heather Reed, from Belfast, are members of the Belfast
Humanist Group
I don't think it's just humanists, I think most people now do Christmas
without the religion. As humanists, we prefer to celebrate Darwin Day on
Charles Darwin's birthday, February 12. That's when the Belfast Humanist
Society sets out a stall in town with leaflets on evolution, and we conduct
opinion polls to survey people's views on the subject. We normally get a
surprisingly positive reaction.
At Christmas, I send charity Christmas cards, without a religious message,
as a way of keeping in touch with people. I do it because it's a tradition,
but there's no reference to it in the Bible and the religious component is
tiny.
I won't be going to a carol service, although I like some of the tunes and
don't denounce anybody who enjoys carols.
On the 25th, I will be sitting down to a turkey dinner, but regard it as a
mid-winter feast. The whole Christmas thing goes back way beyond
Christianity, which as the dominant culture appropriated the pagan festival
and Roman saturnalia.
That's ok, I'm quite happy that Christians should enjoy the holiday as much
as I do.
My two children, who are now grown up and humanists like me, went to
ordinary schools and encountered a lot of religious thinking. I encouraged
them to treat these ancient traditions as just traditions rather than
something that required unthinking reverence.
We did give the children Christmas presents when they were young and told
them the Santa Claus story. In fact, with his beard and ubiquity, he's a bit
of a god-figure, yet nobody believes in Santa when they grow up. From a
humanist standpoint, Christmas is just a secular holiday.
Pagan
Esther (she wants to keep her identity secret) is regional co-ordinator
of the Pagan Federation in Northern Ireland
We don't celebrate Christmas ... it's nothing to do with me (she laughs).
People often make the mistake that a non-Christian celebration means a
non-spiritual celebration, but all the nature festivals have a deep
spiritual basis.
We like to mark the winter solstice, the shortest day of the year, which
occurs today. That's when you'd bring a yule log and evergreen tree into the
house, to encourage spring to come.
I don't want to criticise Christianity - one of the special things about
paganism is it's not a proselytising belief. In fact, it's a far older
religion, and many of the Christmas customs are borrowed from us.
We give presents, sure, and people send each other Yule cards. Hanging
mistletoe in the house is important to druids, but I'm not a druid.
On the 25th itself, we'll have what my kids, who are young men now, like to
eat - and that'll probably be turkey with all the trimmings. We believe in
buying what's in season, so I won't have strawberries from America or
wherever for pudding.
We dress the table with candles, even for breakfast. But, for me, the
ceremony at the solstice is the most important thing.
I've planned a visit to Newgrange in the Boyne valley for after Christmas.
The site dates from 3200BC and is far older than Stonehenge.
I was brought up in a strongly Protestant family and, as a woman, I felt God
the Father, God the Son and God the Holy Ghost left out half the human race.
Now, I'm much happier with a religion that worships the goddess and the god.
My introduction to paganism came via a book I was given 20 years ago on
anthropology and witchcraft in Africa.
I thought the author hadn't a clue and went on to read about the 'burning
times', the persecution of witches in different cultures, and that set me
off on a quest.
I met people who were witches, but not the kind that are into Titania's love
potions. You have to be careful, there is dangerous stuff out there too - I
could make you a love spell today and you could meet a man who might turn
out to be violent or alcoholic.
The most important pagan tenet is to harm no one.
We don't watch carol services or anything like that on television, but
there's one pagan movie I am hoping to catch on TV, the Wizard of Oz.
It opens with a line from the good witch to Dorothy: "What sort of
witch are you, a good or a bad witch?" then goes on "We can all
decide which sort of witch we want to be ... " It's the first time the
old gods are mentioned in a Hollywood movie.
Jehovah's Witness
Jehovah's Witness Trish Keery (42), a full time carer, lives in Belfast
with her three children Christina (16), Gary (20) and Alan (23), who is not
a Jehovah's Witness)
Sometimes we go and stay with friends in Donegal or with my mum in England,
as it is the one time of the year that everyone is off work and school.
But we absolutely do not celebrate Christmas day at all. It's just a normal
day for us when we can sit and enjoy some chill-out time.
As Jehovah's Witnesses, we don't celebrate Christmas day because of its
origins. There's no mention of the date in the Bible and the only two
birthdays celebrated in the Bible are not part of worship.
We believe that it is the death of Jesus that is meant to be remembered, but
we don't 'celebrate' Easter either. We don't give each other chocolate eggs,
but we would get together for a remembrance service.
I don't feel left out at all at Christmas. Before I became a Witness 15
years ago I used to be really into Christmas and make my own decorations,
but I don't miss it.
At my daughter's school everyone knows she is a Jehovah's Witness.
Initially, she had some people who would have given her cards at Christmas
and she would explain to them that she didn't want to hurt their feelings,
but that she didn't celebrate Christmas.
It's never been a problem for any of my children that we don't celebrate
Christmas. At school people are sometimes curious, but they've never been
bullied about it or felt left out at all.
They always got toys, though - I would have bought them bikes in summer,
because that time of year makes better sense. They thought it was great that
they didn't have to wait until Christmas to get presents.
I just hate this time of year because of what it stands for. Everybody goes
mad, buying the shops out of everything, there are huge crowds and the same
Christmas tunes - I just don't see the point of it.
Muslim
Muslim Sheikh Anwar Mady (33) is an Imam at the Belfast Islamic Centre.
He lives in Belfast with his wife Einaf Amin and children Mazen (4), Tareq
(2) and six-month-old Yousuf
For Muslims, Christmas Day is not a special day, but we live in a
multi-cultural society and so we respect that for many people it is and we
congratulate them. We would, of course, accept Christmas gifts or cards out
of respect for Christian beliefs. In this country, Christmas is a big part
of people's lives.
Our special day is Eid ul-Adha, which will be on December 31 or January 1
this year. It is our celebration to commemorate the actions of the prophet
Ibrahim and the pilgrimage to Mecca.
As Muslims, all we ask for is equal treatment in our beliefs. I think all
different religions have their own special day and they should all be
recognised.
As Muslims, we recognise all prophets of God, and see Jesus as one of the
most respected. We believe in his miraculous birth and Mary is given
elevated status among women.
But in the Koran, Jesus said there would be another prophet to come after
him - Mohammed - so our beliefs about Jesus are not the same as for
Christians.
My oldest child goes to a mixed school where he is not the only Muslim. He
is not involved in Christmas celebrations, because he knows that we have
another story different to the Nativity.
Jew
Jew Leon Litvak (46) is a reader in Victorian Studies at Queen's
University, Belfast
Christmas is a completely meaningless day for Jews, so Christmas day is just
an ordinary day for me. However, at the moment we have Chanukah going on -
it is a major festival for us.
It starts on Friday, December 15, and goes on for eight days. It's based on
a historical event, when the temple in Jerusalem was rededicated after being
desecrated.
Every night a candle is lit until there are eight candles lit on the
candelabra. We sing songs and eat food associated with Chanukah, like donuts
and potato pancakes.
We don't give presents, but the children play specific games like spinning a
dradle. Depending on what side the top falls on, the kids get nuts and coins.
The giving of coins has really been picked up commercially in America, with
gold-wrapped chocolate money being handed out at this time of year.
I'm from Canada originally, and I think much more is made of Chanukah there
than here in Northern Ireland. It's also much more common in Canada and
North America for someone to wish you 'Happy Holidays' rather than 'Merry
Christmas'.
I prefer that, because it shows a recognition that there are different
faiths, but I do think political correctness can be taken to extremes.
I think the meaning of Christmas has become very commercial and it's
impossible to avoid. Members of the Jewish (and Islamic) faiths are not able
to engage in the same outward displays of faith that one can in somewhere
like North America, where people are more sensitive to different religions.
I think in Northern Ireland people are just not very aware of different
faiths, because they are not part of their lives.