Belfast Telegraph

Friday 9 October 2015

Mr Chartwell, By Rebecca Hunt

Reviewed by Peter Carty

Published 22/10/2010

Dogged: Winston Churchill in 1943
Dogged: Winston Churchill in 1943

The Sixties aren't swinging for Esther Hammerhans.

In Rebecca Hunt's first novel, it is 1964 and Esther is living alone in Battersea, working as a lowly librarian in the Houses of Parliament. Her monotonous existence is disrupted when she advertises for a lodger and an enormous black dog takes the room. The dog is the eponymous Mr Chartwell. He has the power of speech and a penetrating intelligence, as well as being six foot seven on his hind legs (he stands on them quite often).

Winston Churchill labelled his depressions his "Black Dog" and we learn that Mr Chartwell is this self-same metaphorical canine made flesh, busy lurking around his illustrious client in between rooming with Esther. By now Churchill is 89 and about to retire from the Commons after more than six decades of glorious service to the nation. The prospect fills him with gloom and so Mr Chartwell has descended upon him once more.

While Esther tries to cope with her tenant's grotesque habits - he has disgusting table manners, he stinks and he destroys her furnishings - we are left to wonder why Mr Chartwell has attached himself to her. Could it be related to the absence of her husband Michael? A fresh ordeal looms when she is deputised by her irascible head librarian to fill in as a relief secretary to Churchill. She is to help him draft his farewell speech to the Commons, over at his country retreat in the Weald of Kent (the Chartwell from which the Black Dog has purloined his name).

Hunt nimbly avoids the whimsy invited by her magical realist conceit. Instead she brings to bear a fine artist's lateral sensibility (she's a painter as well as a writer) to deliver a quirkily inspired hypostatisation of Churchill's inner demon. And the later Churchill himself, in his hammy grandeur and Lear-like plight, is a gift for a novelist. By now history had rolled on past this most potent of all 20th-century political beasts, an Edwardian colossus who had so long outlived his era that it is astonishing to realise, as Hunt deftly shows, that he overlapped with the Rolling Stones.

There are niggles. Near the novel's start, excessive name-checking intrudes into her descriptions, though her depictions of Parliament and Chartwell, in particular, are finely crafted and engagingly evocative. Inevitably, there must be a feeling that she could have made more of Churchill; she delivers a series of adroit sketches where perhaps she might have gambled upon a portrait of more depth. Towards the end, too, its intersecting tales of depression begin to over-strain her central narrative device, despite his super-canine powers of agency.

Nevertheless, the big black dog is always full of entertaining surprises. If Mr Chartwell loves chewing on a sheep's pelvis, he's happiest when verbally jousting with humans who do not want him to be there at all, despite his inimitably seductive traits. Hunt's debut is charming, funny and moving.

From the web

Sponsored Videos

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph