Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Life Health

Is IVF really the best option for you?

Published 21/09/2015

Alternative treatment: one in seven couples in the UK struggle to conceive through natural means
Alternative treatment: one in seven couples in the UK struggle to conceive through natural means

Professor Robert Winston discusses his new fertility guide with Lisa Salmon and explains why there is so much more to fertility treatment than just IVF.

Having a baby for many is a fundamental part of life, yet one in every seven couples in the UK struggle to conceive.

There are many different reasons for this, and numerous treatments to improve their chances of having a baby. However, many people assume the best way of overcoming fertility problems is through IVF (in-vitro fertilisation) - but that's often not the case, insists fertility expert Professor Robert Winston.

Although one of the founding fathers of IVF himself, Prof Winston believes the technique - where an egg and sperm are mixed in a dish, creating an embryo which is then implanted in a woman's uterus - is used far too often before other, usually cheaper and less stressful options, are fully explored.

DON'T RUSH IN

In his new book, The Essential Fertility Guide, Prof Winston outlines fertility treatment options and suggests that more than half of those referred to IVF clinics may be treated by alternatives. He says some doctors in the NHS don't take infertility seriously enough, too swiftly shunting patients into the private sector where expensive IVF, which only has a 25% success rate, is a highly profitable industry.

He says: "There are numerous causes of infertility, and the best treatment may be different in each circumstance. Unfortunately, the massive publicity given to IVF has led to most people believing that it is almost the only treatment and the most successful. This is utterly wrong.

"Couples rush into IVF far too frequently."

OTHER OPTIONS

So what are the alternatives to IVF? Depending on the cause, these include:

  • Drug treatments to encourage ovulation
  • Artificial insemination (AI)
  • Microsurgery
  • Laparoscopic (minimally invasive) surgery
  • Treatment for endometriosis

PROFIT OVER PATIENT

Prof Winston points out that many of the 47,000 women treated with IVF every year are referred to clinics "without the competence or interest in offering anything other than IVF".

The National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), recommends three treatment cycles for those needing IVF, but the NHS frequently limits each patient to just one. Prof Winston adds: "Regrettably, in the commercial sector, where most IVF is done because NHS provision is so inadequate, the pressure for the clinic to offer profitable IVF rather than another treatment is strong."

He says that while there are of course ethical private practitioners, it's often easier to immediately put couples on the IVF treadmill rather than spend sufficient time investigating the underlying cause of infertility.

WHOSE PROBLEM IS IT?

Failure to conceive is caused by a female problem in just over a third of cases, says Prof Winston.

The most common cause of female infertility is failure to ovulate (around 30%), damage to the fallopian tubes causes around 25% of female infertility cases, while endometriosis is found in about 20% of infertile women. In another third of infertility cases, the problem is that the man is sub-fertile and may have a low sperm count, for example, and in the remainder, both partners are responsible.

In addition, a substantial number of couples have what is referred to as 'unexplained infertility' - although more detailed testing sometimes reveals a possible cause.

Many couples have two, or occasionally more, infertility causes.

"Do not go for IVF without a clear idea about why you need it," says the book's author.

"Most infertile couples do not require this complex treatment," added Prof Winston, who stresses that couples need to ask the right questions and make sure they are properly tested to identify the cause of their infertility and the best treatment to suit them.

INVESTIGATE IVF

Only after investigations - ranging from testing women for ovulation, other hormone levels and chromosomal abnormalities, plus using imaging techniques and assessing the number and quality of the man's sperm, hormones and chromosomes - should treatment options be considered.

Prof Winston says IVF is appropriate when fallopian tubes are so badly damaged that tubal surgery has failed or can't be done, if a women isn't ovulating and ovulation-stimulating drugs have repeatedly failed, or if a man has an abnormal or low sperm count, but the sperm are still potentially capable of fertilising an egg.

It may also be useful in some cases of endometriosis and unexplained infertility, where there are problems with the cervix, where couples have multiple fertility problems, and when there's a high risk of couples having genetically abnormal babies so preimplantation genetic screening (PGS) is needed.

EXPLOITATION

Prof Winston adds: "IVF is not the only treatment for infertility, and it's often not the best or the most successful. There are many treatments depending on the cause, and the cause should be established first.

"The desperation to get pregnant makes people vulnerable and capable of being exploited, and one of the issues is to understand very often expectant treatment, ie. waiting to get pregnant, is likely to be more effective.

"The reason for writing this book is to try to get couples to ask the right questions and to understand that if they've got a condition that would prevent IVF working, for example, they have to get that treated first.

"People need to make sure they have the most accurate information and that they see responsible doctors who are prepared to listen to their concerns rather than just shoving them into a mechanical treatment because they're not thinking about what the various alternatives are."

The Essential Fertility Guide by Prof Robert Winston is published by Quadrille, £10 and is available now

Belfast Telegraph

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph