Fury at Ruane for ‘failing the kids’

Thursday, 8 October 2009

Sinn Fein has told the Belfast Telegraph it will not comment further on our Sit Down, Sort It Out campaign. However, those living in party leader Gerry Adams’ constituency still have a great deal to say ... as Kathryn Torney discovered

The people of west Belfast have sent a strong message to Sinn Fein today that they want them to sit down with other politicians and sort out the school transfer issue.

On the same day that a Sinn Fein spokesman said they had “no further comment to make” on the Belfast Telegraph’s petition, our campaign garnered strong support in the republican heartland of west Belfast.

Hundreds of parents, trainee teachers, grandparents and other members of the public added their name to the petition which is calling for focused all-party Executive talks on the issue.

It demands that the politicians sit down together to agree on a new form of transfer in time for this year’s P6 pupils moving to secondary-level schools in 2011.

Our campaign does not call for academic selection to be maintained or scrapped — this will be up to the politicians to decide upon. The Ulster Unionists, DUP, SDLP and Alliance Party have all backed the campaign. Education Minister Caitriona Ruane has scrapped the 11-plus and has issued admissions guidance to schools. But this has been dismissed by 68 schools which are running their own entrance tests instead. Almost a year ago Caitriona Ruane came under fire from angry parents and teachers during a public debate on future school transfer arrangements held at St Mary’s University College on the Falls Road.

She was strongly criticised by parents of P6 pupils — whose children are now in P7 and will be the first to transfer under the new unregulated system. One P6 mother walked out of the hall during the discussion, shouting at the minister: “You are failing our kids by the way. Just so you know.” Earlier this week people walking past the teacher training college were among those adding their names to our petition.

The SDLP’s Alex Attwood is an Assembly member for west Belfast and is backing our campaign.

He said that parents and teachers in the area feel angry and confused about the unregulated transfer system.

“Leading up to the European election the issue at the doors was very much school transfer, not Europe. While Sinn Fein are saying they are opting out of the Telegraph’s campaign, I hope they do not opt out of sitting down with the other parties next week to try and find a way forward,” he said.

“This is not the time to walk off the pitch.

“It is the time to sit down and get things sorted.

“We need to get something in place for next autumn and then work on getting something in place for the longer term.”

>> Transfer chaos - sign up to the Belfast Telegraph Online Petition

WHAT THE PEOPLE OF WEST BELFAST SAID. . .

By Kathryn Torney, Rachel Quigley and Conor O’Neill

PARK CENTRE

Anne Kane (41), a housewife from Belfast, said: “My child is in P4 and I'm anxious that something won't be up and in running in time.”

David Thompson (31), an area manager, said: “It's a bit ridiculous that kids are having to go for private tuition. If anything, the new tests set by schools are more discriminating than the old 11-plus.”

Muriel Cafferty (63), a retiree from Belfast, said: “I think Caitriona Ruane has made things worse. Every child deserves the best opportunity to get the best education. I think teachers and parents should know a child's capabilities, and selection should be made on that basis.”

THE KENNEDY CENTRE

Katherine Johnson said: “The education system in this country is second to none, or at least it was until Caitriona Ruane got her hands on it. It’s obvious she has not thought this through.”

Brenda Irwin’s 10-year-old son Tiarnan will be taking the transfer test next month.

She said: “The kids this year are being treated like guinea pigs. Tiarnan’s school aren’t allowed to prepare them for it, it’s ridiculous. No one is telling us anything to be honest and it’s just not fair on the kids.”

Another concerned parent, David Irving, said his son Connor is trying hard to do his best but is under additional pressure.

He said: “The kids are so young to be put under so much pressure.

“Connor always does his best, but things are just extra hard for all the kids now. I really hope they get something sorted soon for the sake of the kids.”

And it wasn’t just parents who stopped to voice their concern. Bronagh Mervyn said: “I don’t have any kids doing the test but I can only imagine what it would be like. Caitriona Ruane has a lot to answer for. It’s not just the parents she is hurting, but the working- class. It’s a disgrace.”

FALLS ROAD

Mother-of-two Gillian Keenan said: “I’m not sure if tests are the right way to do things, but the situation does need to be sorted out.

“I worry that schools could end up going private and a lot of people living on this road could not afford that.”

Housewife Marie McVeagh said: “My grandson is in P7 and sitting the entrance tests this year. These children don’t know where they stand or what is going to happen.

“My grand-daughter is in P6 and the family are really concerned about what is going to happen next year. I would like the Education Minister to get it all sorted out.”

Mother-of-one Jennifer Douglas said: “It is worrying that everything is still very much up in the air.

“What was the point in scrapping the 11-plus when schools are able to set their own tests anyway? It is all very confusing for parents.

“My son is only in nursery school so I really hope that it will all be sorted out in time for him.”

ruanes visit to radio ulster when stephen said he would put a couple of calls through to her she was of quicker than a greyhound you who voted for her take note this person has no respect for anyone bar herself

Posted by w. gould | 14.10.09, 13:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I have written to the Minister, I have written to all local MLA's and I have also written to Bishop Donal McKeown - what a waste of time it all was, I had replies from Sinn Fein MLA's, the Minister and Bishop McKeown which were nothing short of condescending. The other MLA's replied but it would appear their hands are tied. I think it is very important that everyone punishes Sinn Fein at the polls for this behaviour. I have voted Sinn Fein for 18 years and will never ever vote for them again. I will also have no problems sending my children to non-catholic grammar schools if there are no catholic grammar schools.

Posted by deirdre | 10.10.09, 17:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

seanid i totally agree with you i wish people like yourself and like minded people on unionist side could get together we could soon sort out any disagreements we might have, its pig headed people like ruane and same on unionist side who hold the rest of the island back from peace and harmony i hope a resolve will come on the childrens educational needs they have a bad enough start as it is amid this pigheadedness

Posted by w. gould | 09.10.09, 12:44 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I totally agree with you glasrock I have aimed my campaigning at Ms Ruane, I have written to her I have went to meetings that she held and believe me I had no problem in expressing my disgust at her I even shouted at her when a group of parents and I walked out of the meeting in st marys because she would not stop avoiding our questions. This woman has no conscience and she has no problem with sitting back and watching while 3 years of p7 children face the chaos of an unregulated transfer. she probably thinks if there is chaos the other parties will have no other choice but to accapt her terms. I am a catholic but I have no love for sinn fein infact I have no trouble in telling you I have never voted sinn fein and after this I never will. The reason I feeling we should protest to all the politicians is so that Ms Ruane can see she has no support, and if the other MLAS are in favour of ending the chaos they will see they have the backing of the parents.

Posted by sineadmccabe | 09.10.09, 10:23 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Sinead, you and the BT are calling on all politicians to end this chaos but it seems to me that our efforts need to be aimed at one party and one Minister in particular. The other MLAs have been unable to sort this out as the Minister for Education will not listen to them unless it is to confirm their agreement with her. No debate, no middle ground, no other solution. I do however agree with protesting, but against Sinn Fein's handling of education.

Posted by Glasrock | 08.10.09, 16:45 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I was the mother that shouted at the minster at the meeting in St Marys. I knew she would fail this years p7 pupils, I knew there would be an unregulated transfer and I knew it would bring chaos. My only advise for this years p6 parents is not to sit and wait for this to be sorted out it will be chaos next year and the year after that and for many years to come if we don't do something now. It is too late for my daughter she will have to face what ever lays ahead, I just hope that I have managed to prepare her the best I could. I think we should all get together and protest against this deadlock and make the politicians sort this out. The minster has no conscience and she doesn't care if these children suffer they are just political pawns. Let's arrange a protest to show the politicians we won't accept they way they are dealing with this, if they have no time they better find the time these are 10 and 11 year old children.

Posted by sineadmccabe | 08.10.09, 10:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I have been writing letters to the minster I have went to meetings with the grammar schools and I even went to a meeting in St Marys to meet the minster and to make my concerns heard to her it has been a long year and im sorry to say it has been a total waste of time. I am not the only parent that has done this many other parents I know have also campaigned to try and get and end to the chaos. I feel that the only way for parents to be heard is to hold a protest march demand an end to this and make the minster listen she has to compromise these grammar schools can't change over night they need time. If you would be interested in having a peaceful protest to help the children leave a comment maybe the telegraph could take a poll to see if there is enough interest. Its too late for my daughter who is in p7 but we need to make sure this does not go on next year. I have a boy in p4 and I couldn't go through another year like this. Let's arrange a protest.

Posted by sineadm | 08.10.09, 10:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

What is the Belfast Telegraph position? Being neither for nor against academic selection is not possible. Every child must transfer at the end of P7. If not by academic selection then the BT should outline their proposals.
What do the BT expect politicians to do? Perhaps the MLAs should also declare that they are neither for nor against academic selection so that the BT campaign could run ad infinitum.

Posted by Parental Alliance for Choice in Education | 08.10.09, 08:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

sinn fein look to the childrens welfare you wont lose anything by talking, and dont forget when your in a hole stop digging

Posted by w. gould | 08.10.09, 08:16 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Most viewed in Education

BT Woman.

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

To send Us Your Baby snaps just Click here

Just Wed: Readers' Wedding Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Wedding Pictures

To send Us Your Wedding snaps just Click here

Latest Comments

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery