Parties dither over talks to end transfer logjam

By Kathryn Torney
Thursday, 1 October 2009

Alliance leader David Ford

Alliance leader David Ford

The SDLP and the Ulster Unionists have failed to respond to an Alliance party invitation to take part in all-party talks on the school transfer fiasco despite publicly backing the Belfast Telegraph's Sit Down and Sort It Out campaign.

The two parties have not yet replied to a letter sent by Alliance leader David Ford last week which called on each party to nominate representatives for talks in a bid to resolve the logjam over what should replace the 11-plus.

However, the DUP has said it is happy to take part in the talks.

Sinn Fein, which also has yet to reply to the invitation, has not backed the campaign and instead insists that a decision has already been taken and that the department’s Transfer 2010 policy should be followed by all schools.

However, 68 schools have already dismissed Caitriona Ruane’s guidance that academic selection should be abandoned, and instead have introduced their own entrance tests for P7 pupils.

Over 13,700 registrations have been received for the two sets of entrance exams which will be held across the province this autumn.

Mr Ford wrote to DUP leader Peter Robinson, Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness, SDLP leader Mark Durkan and UUP leader Sir Reg Empey.

He said: “I am sure the public will be astounded that three of the parties I wrote to last Thursday have not responded on this vitally important issue. We have only heard from the DUP on this, and they have indicated they will take part in talks.

“The fact that we have heard nothing from the others may serve as an indication of the complacency that haunts this failing Executive.”

Alliance education spokesman Trevor Lunn said: “I am disappointed that the Ulster Unionists, SDLP and Sinn Fein have not been in contact to make arrangements for talks. Alliance took the initiative last Thursday and we will continue to keep the pressure on all parties to build a consensus to end the current transfer chaos.

“Some might say this illustrates the attitude that these three parties have about our future generation.

“Are they happy to maintain entrenched positions or will they come to the table in the spirit of co-operation?

“I applaud the Belfast Telegraph’s ongoing campaign and I hope the continued pressure can force these parties into action.

“The public will tolerate no more excuses on the issue of post-primary transfer as it potentially affects every child across Northern Ireland.”

Mr Lunn added that he planned to place an amendment to an Assembly motion to call for talks.

He said: “We are placing an amendment to a motion in the Assembly next week on grammar school entrance tests, which will reflect our thinking and the views expressed by the Belfast Telegraph campaign.”

As predicted by PACE the political parties are now trying to sell social selection in the Assembly as their answer to 11-plus testing of numeracy and literacy attainment. The Pupil Profile has been resuscitated in an effort to avoid the Public Accounts Committee investigation of yet another extravagant waste of public money on CCEA software that tells parents nothing.
Mr Lunn's amendment was another pathetic attempt by Alliance to end academic selection. It failed again. Why are politicians such slow learners?

Posted by Parental Alliance for Choice in Education | 06.10.09, 10:41 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

ruane you have ruaned the childrens education feel proud ,now the kids are more important than your inflated ego get talking

Posted by william | 03.10.09, 07:34 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

“Are they happy to maintain entrenched positions or will they come to the table in the spirit of co-operation?

David Ford are you listening to and reading what Mrs Ruane has repeatedly been saying. She is totally determined not to move from her position and no amount of talking to Unionists and fussing from the Alliance party is going to change that.

Posted by T J McClean | 01.10.09, 08:08 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

The Alliance Party and Mr Ford are anti-academic selection. What new suggestions does he have to make talks worthwhile so that parents and pupils have their rights restored in a regulated system? More jawing will not solve the education chaos unless those parties, including the Alliance Party, back the right of parents to a pluralist system that includes academic selection not social selection. A return to the 11-plus is the simple answer. This announcement of a motion amendment is simple grandstanding absent a reversal of the Alliance position.
Backdoor efforts to change the law on academic selection will not fool parents.

Posted by Parental Alliance for Choice in Education | 01.10.09, 07:56 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Most Read in Education

BT Petition: Sort Out Transfer Chaos

Transfer chaos petition

Click here to join our campaign

BT Woman.

Schooldayz

  • Rivers has fun during play time
  • Will gets in touch with his artistic side
  • Dylan gets caught with his hand in the cookie jar

Greenway Creche

Schooldayz

  • The Year 10 hurling team
  • Traditional music lessons are very popular at the school
  • Staff members dressed up earlier in the year as part of a Halloween fitness day

Coláiste Feirste

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

To send Us Your Baby snaps just Click here

Just Wed: Readers' Wedding Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Wedding Pictures

To send Us Your Wedding snaps just Click here

Latest Comments

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery