Scramble grows for private tuition

By Kathryn Torney
Monday, 6 July 2009

Demand for private tutoring for primary school pupils is likely to grow as parents attempt to prepare their children for the new grammar entrance tests.

Six exam preparation courses for children in September and October at Queen’s University and Stranmillis University College are already full.

Twenty children have signed up for the three-hour sessions on Saturday mornings with P7 teachers and the course’s primary tutors are also booked up in some areas of the province for private one-to-one tuition costing £28 an hour.

Education Minister Caitriona Ruane said that private tutoring further disadvantages children from lower income families and Professor Tony Gallagher, head of the School of Education at Queen’s University, urged parents to trust primary teachers and principals rather than turn to paid coaching.

Simon McKee, from Helping Hand tutors, said: “A lot of our primary tutors are fully booked now in certain areas,” he added.

“Tuition can work as long as the tutor, the parent and the child are all working together. Much of the benefit comes from the reinforcement work given home for children to do. Children typically have tutoring for one hour a week after school.”

Frances Hamill is a mother of two from Larne and a member of Schools Transfer Options for Pupils (Stop) parents group. Her son is due to sit the new grammar tests in the autumn.

She said: “At this minute in time my son is not being coached. I have another son who went through the 11-plus a few years ago and he wasn’t coached either. However, given the current chaos with the system, I can understand why other families would turn to coaching to try and get back some sort of control of the situation.

“In Larne we have one grammar school so there will be a lot of competition for the places.

“You may want a tutor if your child’s school is doing just the bare minimum while other schools are holding summer classes and sessions after school. There is such a wide variation in the preparation by primary schools.”

Professor Gallagher said: “The best evidence we have is that between a third and a half of pupils received paid for out-of-school coaching for the old 11-plus exams. Most primary school principals thought this added to the pressure on children and exacerbated the social inequities that already existed in the 11-plus system.

“Now that grammar schools have decided to run their own selection tests, primary schools no longer have any formal role to play in the process and many |have decided not to provide |additional coaching.

“The uncertainties facing parents is likely to encourage more to seek out-of-school coaching and, no doubt, some budding entrepreneurs will seek to exploit these concerns by printing ‘practice tests’. Whether these will be of any real value is in doubt, as they are entirely new tests, with no past papers and few exemplars on which to base preparation.

“Primary teachers are entirely committed to their pupils and will deliver the revised curriculum to the best of their ability — it is hard to think of any better preparation the children could receive in the transition from primary to post-primary school.

“My best advice is to trust the primary teachers and principals.”

Ms Ruane said: “Testing children at the age of 10 or 11 for the purpose of determining admission to post primary school is |totally wrong.

“The old system clearly created inequality as the facts show children living in well off areas are much more likely to gain admission to a grammar school than those living in more disadvantaged areas.

“Private tutoring further disadvantages children from lower income families and only serves the needs of those who can afford to support the industry that has grown up around tutoring. Children should be able to access the education they are fully entitled to, rather than just the education they can afford.

“It is important for children to have free time to play and build friendships rather than endure the pressure tutoring imposes.”

If Caitriona Ruane and Professor Tony Gallagher, head of the School of Education at Queen’s University, urge parents to trust primary teachers and principals rather than turn to paid coaching a simple question arises. Since the coaches are also teachers and principals perhaps these eminent experts will tell parents, by name, which teachers to trust.

Posted by Parental Alliance for Choice in Education | 07.07.09, 08:18 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Totally agree with Transfer Parent - same situation! ! Got a letter re free school meals - our joint income is below that stipulated but because we work more than 16 hours a week my son is not entitled to "free" entrance to a Grammar School! At least with 11+ he would have had a chance! Thankfully he is bright so hopefully with AQE (which we paid for to give him a chance!)he will get there on his own merit but I can't afford to have him tutored. One size schooling DOES NOT fit all!

Posted by Frustrated P6 Parent | 06.07.09, 16:49 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

The advice I give to my children is trust no-one other than yourself. Children know what they are capable of and need a variety of ways to be able to demonstrate this. The egalitarian revised curriculum provides no opportunity to demonstrate academic ability or apptitude. The 'prizes for all' mentality is suffocating and retards development. 'Failure' in terms of education has shifted from 'failing a test' to 'failing all pupils'. Educationalists have succeeded in applying failure equally!

Posted by L Saunders | 06.07.09, 09:05 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

EVERY CHILD IN NI HAD THE CHANCE FOR A GRAMMAR SCHOOL PLACE AND PARENTS DIDN'T PAY A PENNY. Ms Ruane you have taken this away and are ruining EDUCATION for all NI Children. I am working class and my daughter goes to Grammar School, I am Protestant and have never claimed for school dinners, I work and put my kids first. You are now going to discriminate my Son when he transfares next year - Shame on you. Look at the mess of the English system and that's what you want for our kids - Waken up!

Posted by Transfare Parent | 06.07.09, 09:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Thanks to you, Mrs Ruane!!!

Posted by TJ McClean | 06.07.09, 08:27 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

BT Woman.

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

To send Us Your Baby snaps just Click here

Just Wed: Readers' Wedding Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Wedding Pictures

To send Us Your Wedding snaps just Click here

Latest Comments

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery