Drunk man stabbed 'nagging' wife 177 times, court told

Wednesday, 25 February 2009

A drunken man left a breadknife buried in his partner's neck after stabbing her 177 times because she was a nag, a jury heard today.

Arthur Pitt-Plaiddy, 36, of Saundersfoot, West Wales, then called the police and confessed to murdering 44-year-old partner Kim Butler.

The "prolonged and brutal attack" happened at the couple's Saundersfoot flat, in Pennant Avenue, in August last year, a Swansea Crown Court jury heard.

Paul Thomas QC, prosecuting, said Pitt-Plaiddy left the flat and called the police from a local phone box nearby.

He told the operator "I have just committed murder" and described the victim when asked as "my missus".

When police arrived at the phone box he told an officer: "I have done her in mate."

Mr Thomas said he then added: "I stabbed her in the leg, then the stomach and to shut her up I stabbed her in the face. I left the knife sticking in her neck."

He said Pitt-Plaiddy would later tell the police his partner had been "mouthy" and had hit and nagged him and he had stabbed her twice.

Subsequently he would see a psychiatrist and would go on to claim he had almost no memory of the incident, the court heard

Pitt-Plaiddy also described himself as an alcoholic with a heroin dependency, using the drug twice a day.

He later told police he had an alcohol dependency syndrome representing an abnormality which impaired his mind and diminished his responsibilities for the violent actions he carried out.

The trial began today with Pitt-Plaiddy admitting a charge of manslaughter but denying murder.

Mr Thomas told the jury their role would be to decide whether it was a case of "diminished responsibility as he says or whether it is a case of murder, pure and simple".

He said Pitt-Plaiddy was originally from London and had moved to Saundersfoot after his release from prison several months before and had soon moved in with his partner.

On the night before the killing he had been drinking in the Captain's Table pub in the seaside resort before going home drunk.

Mr Thomas said a neighbour in the flat above heard an argument after his arrival in the early hours of the morning and heard the couple's Labrador barking.

She heard what she believed was Kim Butler saying: "Sorry" three times and heard eight to 10 thumps.

Mr Thomas told the jury the prosecution believed that was the "sustained and fatal attack by the defendant on Kim Butler."

He added: "The defendant seems to have stabbed Kim Butler, on the pathologist's best estimate, at least 177 times.

"You can imagine how long it would have taken to inflict all of those stab wounds and slash wounds," he said.

The jury today was shown photographs of the victim after being warned about the images they would see.

They also listened to a recording of the emergency call made by Pitt-Plaiddy which Mr Thomas reflected his state of mind at the time.

He argued the defendant's "insistence" on hyphenating his surname when he told it to the emergency operator showed he was in control of his faculties.

The case continues.

NiteLife: White's Tavern

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Old School Pictures: Ian Paisley

Old School Pics: Girls Aloud Nadine Coyle

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

In Pictures: The Troubles

Titanic Gallery: First class bedroom

Titanic Gallery: exclusive collection

Out & About: Pizza Night

Out & About: Pizza Night

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Gritty, moving and heroic...Billy plays captured life here

It was the best of times, it was the worst of times ... Sunday's 30th anniversary screening of the seminal Too Late to Talk to Billy was riveting viewing. But it wasn't nostalgic viewing.
ed_curran

Parties need better defence in Stormont's game of two halves

Surprise, surprise. Peter Robinson has been to his first gaelic match, Martin McGuinness is heading for Windsor Park and the Ulster Unionists have scored another own goal.
nuala_mckeever

Why trying to go on a diet is never really a piece of cake

Some people make New Year’s resolutions, I make lists. Every new year I determine to keep track of everything I spend and everything I eat and drink.

frances_burscough

Scary movie? Their jaws were sore from laughing

Teenage boys love horror films and I have two who are in charge of the remote control in our house, so naturally there’s gore-a-plenty on the box most weekends. However, until recently one film was banned.

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

To send Us Your Baby snaps just Click here

Just Wed: Readers' Wedding Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Wedding Pictures

To send Us Your Wedding snaps just Click here

Latest Comments

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery