Belfast Telegraph

Saturday 27 December 2014

Facebook status updates and Twitter posts intercepted by UK Government

A legal loophole means Facebook status updates and Twitter posts are being monitored by the UK Government
A legal loophole means Facebook status updates and Twitter posts are being monitored by the UK Government

Facebook status updates and Twitter posts are being intercepted by the UK Government because they are regarded as external communications from countries based overseas, it has been revealed.

A legal battle with campaign group Privacy International over the level of surveillance by intelligence agencies has led to the disclosure of the legal loophole by Charles Farr, director general of the Office of Security and Counter-Terrorism.

The continuing legal battle was brought by a collection of civil liberties groups as a result of the Edward Snowden revelations last year.

The former National Security Agency (NSA) employee exposed a wide-ranging network of surveillance by government agencies.

In leaked documents, Mr Snowden revealed extensive snooping was being carried out by the US-based NSA, and GCHQ in the UK, including the interception of email and other communications.

The Government's interpretation means intercepting data can be carried out without a warrant under British law, which identifies an "external communication" as "those communications which are both sent and received outside the British Islands, whether or not they pass through the British Islands in the course of their transit."

In a statement, Mr Farr used the example of someone in the UK carrying out a Google search to demonstrate what would constitute an "external communication".

"Google's data centres, containing its servers, are located around the world, but its largest centres are in the United States.

"So a Google search by an individual in the UK may well involve a communication from the searcher's computer to a Google web server, which is received outside the British Islands, and a communication from Google to the searcher's computer, which is sent outside the British Islands. In such a case, the search would correspondingly involve two 'external communications'."

Privacy International says the interpretation "patronises the British people".

Eric King, deputy director of Privacy International, said: "Intelligence agencies cannot be considered accountable to Parliament and to the public they serve when their actions are obfuscated through secret interpretations of byzantine laws."

Earlier this year, the founder of the world wide web Sir Tim Berners-Lee called for a "bill of rights" to protect web users.

The British physicist also criticised the NSA and GCHQ for the level of surveillance.

In a statement, GCHQ said its work is "carried out in accordance with a strict legal and policy framework which ensures that our activities are authorised, necessary and proportionate".

Mr Berners-Lee set up the World Wide Web Foundation to help protect internet users. Foundation chief executive Anne Jellema said: "Based upon the documents published today, it seems the UK's spy agencies are using flimsy legal justification to sidestep the need for individual warrants and feel able to indiscriminately collect and monitor the private social media and web communications of anyone.

"The toxic cocktail of an opaque system and antiquated laws means that we have no idea how many times this has been done, how many people it has affected, or whether the technology companies involved are aware.

"Intelligence agencies need powers to keep people safe, but these powers must be subject to tough checks and balances or they will erode the very fabric of democracy. Bulk data collection by default, with laws made and enforced in secret, can never be acceptable."

The news follows confirmation from mobile network provider Vodafone that secret wires exist within their network that allow for surveillance by the state. The Heartbleed Bug as well as viruses GoZeus and CryptoLocker have also recently made headlines because of their threat to online privacy.

Emma Carr, acting director of privacy campaign group Big Brother Watch, said: "There has clearly been significant damage done to people's expectations that their communications will remain private from the gaze of companies, the Government or law enforcement agencies.

"There is little wonder that people are increasingly worried about their privacy, which will only have been made worse by the Government's unwillingness to have a proper debate about its surveillance capabilities.

"Our surveillance law needs reviewing, oversight needs to be much stronger and greater transparency about how powers are being used would all improve accountability and trust.

"Addressing this would not require legislation and should be addressed by the Home Secretary without delay."

Related video

Applebaum: To Protect And Infect

Further reading

Vodafone: governments use secret wires to listen to all conversations on mobile network 

Snooping tools GCHQ could use to hack your phone's microphone, camera and keypad

52% wary of expressing their views online, one in three do not feel free from government surveillance

GCHQ ‘using online viruses and honey traps to discredit targets’ 

GCHQ given access to US 'Dishfire' system

NSA can spy on computers not connected to internet using radio waves

BT 'refuses to deny data handover'

GCHQ 'harvested webcam images' 

GCHQ ‘using online viruses and honey traps to discredit targets’ 

Spymasters swoop on Angry Birds

US bid to stop spying on its spying 

Obama vows NSA phone data reform

GCHQ given access to US 'Dishfire' system that reads hundreds of millions of text messages

Internet founder hails Snowden 

Snowden gives TV Christmas message

NSA and GCHQ agents acted as elves and gnomes to spy on gamers

Wikipedia's Jimmy Wales: Edward Snowden is a hero 

NSA spied on pornography use and ‘online promiscuity’ to discredit those with radical views

GCHQ ran hotel surveillance ring to spy on diplomats and delegations

GCHQ set up fake LinkedIn pages to spy on mobile phone giants using using 'Quantum Insert' technique

Google engineers on NSA and GCHQ surveillance: "F*** these guys"

Germany demands explanation from British ambassador over GCHQ's 'secret listening post in the heart of Berlin'

Britain’s GCHQ has ‘secret listening post in the heart of Berlin to eavesdrop on the seat of German power'

Civil liberties groups claim British spy agency GCHQ broke European laws by hacking millions of citizens’ internet data

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Latest News

Latest Sport

Latest Showbiz