Ward walks free as £26m bank robbery trial collapses
Thursday, 9 October 2008
A man has been found not guilty of involvement in the £26.5m Northern Bank robbery after the trial collapsed in Belfast.
Christopher Ward, 26, from west Belfast, was accused of robbing the bank's Belfast headquarters and of holding a bank official colleague and his wife hostage in December 2004.
Mr Ward denied all charges.
Defence lawyer Niall Murphy claimed: "The mere fact he was a Catholic and charged with this offence was enough to seal his guilt in the eyes of some people."
He added: "This Kafka-esque farce started from the premise that Chris Ward was guilty and worked backwards, rather than commencing with the evidence and working forwards."
He said Mr Ward had been denied the presumption of innocence from the beginning.
"He should have appeared at this court today as a witness for the prosecution, instead he found himself in the dock for a crime he did not commit and of which he remains a victim," he said.
It was the prosecution case that the robbery was a highly organised crime by a gang which had good inside knowledge.
It was alleged at the start of the trial that Ward had made last minute changes to the rota of staff who had a key to the bank's vault so he would be on duty the day of the robbery, in December 2004.
Prosecution counsel Gordon Kerr QC said the prosecution contention was that the last-minute switch of Mr Ward’s shift was “deliberate to place him on the rota with colleague Kevin McMullan”, who lived in a detached house in the countryside that was easy to observe and to guard.
Today, however, the court heard that the change in rota had been "the result of a chance decision by management".
Mr Kerr said the case had been brought before the court based on circumstantial evidence.
"An essential strand related to the circumstances in which the defendant came to be on the rota of the late shift of the Northern Bank on the day of the robbery.
"Fundamental in the case to the prosecution inviting the court to draw inference from other parts of the case."
He added that differences had arisen during the trial around the rota which prompted the rethink.
"Having considered the remaining evidence and the advice of counsel... it has been concluded that it would not be proper to make further submissions."
Judge Mr Justice McLaughlin said: "I consider the decision of the Director for Public Prosecutions to be fully justified and proper.
"Given the decision to present no further evidence, I could not arrive at any other verdict and I conclude that Chris Ward is not guilty of the three counts in front of me."
The trial at Belfast Crown Court began on 9 September.
The raid was one of the biggest cash robberies in the world and within days Chief Constable Sir Hugh Orde and both the British and Irish governments blamed the Provisional IRA.
However, Sinn Fein denied republican involvement.
On December 19, 2004 armed men took over the homes of two Northern Bank employees, Chris Ward in Belfast and Kevin McMullen in Co Down.
Both men were told to go to work the following day as normal or their families would be killed.
The robbery, now nearly four years, caused a major political crisis when the PSNI declared it was the work of the IRA.
As part of the investigation, Gardai arrested Cork chef Don Bullman at Heuston Station in Dublin in early 2005. He was found in possession of a Daz washing power box containing more than €90,000.
He was jailed last year for IRA membership but never charged in connection with the Northern Bank robbery.
Police recovered £2m during raids in Cork and Dublin.
Around $100,000 in US banknotes was also recovered from a toilet of the police athletic association's Newforge Country Club.
The PSNI confirmed the money was taken during the Northern Bank heist but said the stash was likely to have been "planted to distract detectives".
The timetable of Britain's biggest bank raid
Sunday, 10pm: Armed and masked gangs take over the homes of two Northern Bank staff, one in Loughinisland and one in Poleglass. The families are taken to undisclosed locations.
Sunday, 10pm: Armed and masked gangs take over the homes of two Northern Bank staff, one in Loughinisland and one in Poleglass. The families are taken to undisclosed locations. Monday, 7am: The bank employees are told to go to work as usual at the Northern Bank HQ on Donegall Square West. Monday, 4:30pm: Belfast city centre is packed with Christmas shoppers. Monday, 6pm: After the bank closes only the two bank employees and security staff are left. Black bin bags are left outside to be cleared away by a 'refuse' lorry. The bank's vaults are believed to have contained up to £30m, much of the money has just arrived and is set to be consigned to the bank's 95 branches and high street dispensing units. Monday, 8.30pm: Two hours later and a truck has been filled, it leaves Donegall Square West and travels to an undisclosed location. Monday, 10pm: The two bank managers are left in the countryside outside Belfast. Their families are finally freed after a 24-hour ordeal. Monday, 11.45pm: Police and bank officials are alerted to the raid. The PSNI's Crime Operations department is immediately brought in to investigate. Midnight: Rumours of a £30m heist at Northern Bank's headquarters are already sweeping bars in Belfast. Tuesday, 8am: Despite a virtual media blackout, the Belfast Telegraph establishes the bank's vaults have been looted and the haul could run to tens of millions of pounds. By then, we were predicting the raid was the biggest in UK criminal history Tuesday, 12:30pm: Northern Bank spokesman insists it is business as usual at their banks and customers will not be affected. Tuesday, 3.30pm: Assistant Chief Constable Sam Kinkaid says he believes at least £20m was stolen but says it is too early to say if paramilitaries were involved. Tuesday, 11pm: Detectives reveal they are examining a burnt-out car found in Drumkeeragh Forest Park, Co Down, which is believed to be connected to the raid.
Historic heists
Jonathan McCambridge looks back at some of the most famous heists in UK - and Northern Ireland - history: 1963: The great train robbery - On August 8 a 15 strong armed gang stole £2.6m, mostly in used bank notes, from a Royal Mail train north of London. 1983: Britain's biggest cash robbery - almost £6m was stolen from the Security Express HQ in Shoreditch, east London. 1983: November 26: six robbers broke into the Brinks Mat warehouse at Heathrow Airport for what . was supposed to be a relatively easy job, stealing £3m in cash, but this all changed when, instead of the cash, they found gold bullion worth £26m. 1990: £292m City bonds robbery. A 58-year-old messenger with money broker Sheppards, was mugged at knifepoint on a quiet side street in the City of London; the total haul was £292m in bonds which became largely worthless. 2000: Police foiled the robbery when they caught a gang smashing their way into the Millennium Dome with a JCB earthmover to snatch £200m worth of diamonds. 2002: Thieves carried out a dramatic robbery at Heathrow airport, attacking the driver of a security van before escaping with an estimated £6.5m in cash. Amongst the biggest raids in Northern Ireland have been: A Provisional IRA raid on a postal sorting office in the early 90s that is believed to have netted £2m. A loyalist robbery at a bank in Portadown in the late 80s that netted around £700,000. An INLA raid on the Ulster Bank in Strabane in November last year may have cost the bank £400,000. An armed gang made off with £1m worth of goods in an articulated lorry from the Makro store in west Belfast in May 2003.
- Text Size

Photosales
niJobfinder
niCarfinder
Home Delivery
Propertynews


















If Mr. Ward was innocent, and he was found not giulty, he should sue the Authorities. Having appeared before the Crown Court on such a serious charge, despite the fact that he was found not guilty still means that no employer will wants to touch him with a bardge pole. So what if I've made a couple of speelling mistakes?
Posted by MARC | 11.10.08, 05:10 GMT
Sad reflection on the legal system whose philosophy here seemed to be Ready-Fire-Aim! Perhaps they felt that they had to do something, regardless of any sound proof.
Posted by Edward | 10.10.08, 20:12 GMT
Its not the first time THE PSNI / RUC have tried to send down catholics with circumstancial evidence.
Posted by raymond | 10.10.08, 20:02 GMT
Are the PSNI any closer to finding the real suspects.
Posted by raymond | 10.10.08, 20:01 GMT
Its easy to press charges when the PSNI dont have to foot the bill.
Posted by raymond | 10.10.08, 20:00 GMT
When was anybody sent down based purely on circumstancial evidence alone? It never happens, so on top of the £26 million stolen you can add another £20 million. Surely somebodys head must roll for this farce, don,t hold your breath.
Posted by Sonny Bradley | 09.10.08, 19:55 GMT
Chris Wards lawyer hit the nail perfectly on the head. This was nothing other than the fact that Chris Ward is a Catholic and that was good enough. Even a kangaroo-court system, such as in the North of Ireland, couldnt find any fault in this young man, and yet this is the so-called police force Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness would have young nationals join? What a joke. What a farce.
Posted by no longer fooled | 09.10.08, 13:57 GMT
Yet another court case getting thrown out of court, due to lack of evidence and experience. Never mind we seem to have a big pot for theses types of things!!
Posted by Ian | 09.10.08, 13:21 GMT
Why on earth does the PP keep on taking people to court without any evidence, don't they know beforehand they that it will fail and cost us the taxpayers money. My belief is the Police like to arrest anyone in response to any crime that is in the public eye, so that it looks as if they are actually doing something, how many times has this been the case? Does the PP not report to someone and if so why does this continue to happen again and again!
Posted by John | 09.10.08, 13:07 GMT
Excellent news for Chris. He has been used as a scapegoat for an inept police service from day one and today he can finally breath a sigh of relief. Well done Chris!
Posted by Liam | 09.10.08, 12:52 GMT