Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Christopher Meli murder: Dunmurry man Lee Smyth refused bail

Published 18/04/2016

Christopher Meli was beaten to death in west Belfast
Christopher Meli was beaten to death in west Belfast

One of the teenagers accused of beating a young father to death in west Belfast must remain in custody, a High Court judge ruled on Monday.

Madam Justice McBride refused bail to Lee Smyth after rejecting claims that he should be released due to delays in the investigation into the killing of Christopher Meli.

Smyth, 19, of Colinbrook Gardens in Dunmurry, is among three teenagers charged with murdering the 20-year-old on December 12 last year.

A witness has made a disputed claim that he whistled for others to join in the attack.

Detectives believe up to 20 people were involved in a number of violent confrontations that led to Mr Meli suffering fatal head injuries at Doc's Lane in the Twinbrook area of the city.

Prosecutors have alleged that he was set upon by a large group of both males and females, and subjected to "a sustained, savage attack."

One line of enquiry is that the murder victim and his friends were targeted in retaliation for a clash outside a kebab shop on the Stewartstown Road earlier the same night.

Another group of teenagers came together to "exact revenge" for that fight in which in one of their number sustaining a "busted nose", the court was told previously. 

Mr Meli was said to have been located, knocked to the ground and then repeatedly punched and kicked about the head.

Smyth, who denies the charge against him, went to police later that day to give an account of his alleged involvement in the wider incident.

Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's coffin leaves Requiem Mass in New Barnsley for burial. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's coffin leaves Requiem Mass in New Barnsley for burial. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Mother , Vanessa Burke during The funeral of west Belfast murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday, His remains left his Family home at Sliabh Dubh before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa, Christopher Snr and two brother lead his coffin as it leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
Tragic: Christopher Meli with friend Ryan Morris
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
Christoper Meli was murdered on grassland in the Twinbrook area (PSNI)
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
The funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli on Monday. His remains left his family home at Sliabh Dubh, Belfast, before Requiem Mass at the Church of the Annunciation in New Barnsley. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Photo Colm Lenaghan/Pacemaker Press
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa looks on as his coffin is taken from the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa(right) is comforted as his coffin leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa and father Christopher Snr follow his coffin as it leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa looks on as his coffin is taken from the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's brother, mother Vanessa and father Christopher Snr follow his coffin as it leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa(right) is comforted as his coffin leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's brother, mother Vanessa and father Christopher Snr follow his coffin as it leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Funeral of murder victim Christopher Meli from his family home in Sliabh Dubh View in west Belfast. The 20-year-old father of one died after he was attacked by a gang of youths in Glasvey Close in the Twinbrook estate on 12 December. Christopher Meli's mother Vanessa and father Christopher Snr follow his coffin as it leaves the family home. Picture by Jonathan Porter/PressEye
Flowers left at the scene of the murder of Christopher Meli at Glasvey Close in west Belfast. Pic: Matt Bohill/Pacemaker.
Flowers left at the scene of the murder of Christopher Meli at Glasvey Close in west Belfast. Pic: Matt Bohill/Pacemaker.
Flowers left at the scene of the murder of Christopher Meli at Glasvey Close in west Belfast. Pic: Matt Bohill/Pacemaker.

He claimed to have exchanged blows with Mr Meli in a "fair fight" where both were on the ground as others set upon them, a judge was told.

But according to the prosecution a witness alleged that Smyth whistled as a signal for others to join him.

It was claimed that he then started to assault Mr Meli on the ground, kicking him to the face and stomach, with another of those at the scene said to have remarked: "He's dying."

The murder victim's mother, Venessa Burke, was present in court with other family members as Smyth mounted a fresh application for bail.

Defence counsel Tom McCreanor argued that a date for submitting a preliminary investigation file to the Director of Public Prosecution has been missed.

Raising further concerns with progressing forensics in the case, he predicted any trial may not get underway until next year.

"It's a concern that whilst awaiting that this young man is going to be detained in custody for that period," Mr McCreanor said.

But prosecution counsel responded that police are expected to have the file ready by the middle of next month.

She revealed that a major investigation team handling the case are also in the process of interviewing four more potential witnesses.

Refusing bail, Madam Justice McBride ruled: "The delay is not significant enough to amount to a material change of circumstances.

"It may be at a later date if there's ongoing delay."

Online Editors

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph