Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Families hail finding of 'significant police collusion' in Loughinisland murders

Published 09/06/2016

Loughinisland families press conference takes place in the Ramada Hotel in Belfast
Loughinisland families press conference takes place in the Ramada Hotel in Belfast
Heights Bar at Loughinisland in Co Down where six men were gunned down as they watched a World Cup football match in 1994
A memorial plaque at the Heights Bar in Co Down marks Loughinisland killings.

Families of six Catholic men murdered by loyalist gunmen in a village pub have hailed a damning watchdog investigation that exposed significant police collusion with the killers.

Northern Ireland's Police Ombudsman Michael Maguire was scathing in his assessment of the police role in the 1994 Ulster Volunteer Force sectarian massacre in Loughinisland, Co Down.

Two UVF gunmen burst into the packed bar at around 10.10pm on June 18 1994 and fired at customers watching the Republic of Ireland play Italy in the World Cup in the US. Six were killed and five injured. No one has ever been brought to justice.

Dr Maguire found that one man suspected of carrying out the mass killing in the Heights Bar was a police informant

The ombudsman also said the murder squad had been involved in a number of other killings in the years beforehand, but had avoided arrest because the Royal Ulster Constabulary's Special Branch intelligence unit had withheld evidence from RUC detectives investigating the crimes.

He said some Special Branch officers had a "hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil" mind-set that placed the collection of information above the detection of crime.

The victims' families have long claimed police colluded with the killers and won a court battle to quash a previous Ombudsman's report that had rejected the collusion allegation.

Emma Rogan, whose father Adrian was killed, said: "Today we finally have a report by the Police Ombudsman that at last vindicates our long-held suspicions and belief that the truth about these murders was being covered up by the very people - the police - who were supposed to be protecting us, be on our side and investigate and bring to justice those responsible."

Paddy McCreanor, nephew of victim Daniel McCreanor, said: "Collusion is no illusion and collusion happened. The truth has come out and that's all we ever wanted."

The families' lawyer Niall Murphy said the scale of the collusion was "terrifying".

"This report is one of the most damning expositions of state collusion in mass murder that has ever been published," he said.

Mr Murphy said relatives retained hope that justice could be done, but he acknowledged prosecutions would be difficult, noting that evidence, including the getaway car, had been destroyed.

While the report was revealed in Belfast, former prime minister Sir John Major was elsewhere in Northern Ireland delivering a pro-European Union speech. Mr Murphy called on Sir John to apologise for the collusion that took place when he was in office.

The families also called on current Northern Ireland Secretary of State Theresa Villiers to say sorry for referencing Loughinisland in a speech earlier this year about what she claimed was a "pernicious counter-narrative" of the Troubles that was trying to place undue blame on the security forces.

"We call on her to retract and apologise to us today," said Ms Rogan.

In his report's conclusion, Dr Maguire said he had "no hesitation in saying collusion was a significant feature of the Loughinisland murders".

While acknowledging some officers worked tirelessly to catch the killers, the ombudsman described failures in the overall investigation as "catastrophic" and said in too many instances the probe was characterised by "incompetence, indifference and neglect".

The ombudsman also examined the role of police informants in efforts by loyalist paramilitaries to smuggle weapons into Northern Ireland from abroad during the mid to late 1980s.

He found that security forces were monitoring the importation bids and information provided by state agents in high positions within the paramilitary groupings helped lead to the recovery of a significant number of weapons.

But the watchdog questioned why many still ended up in the hands of loyalist killers.

He said unrecovered weapons from the shipments were used in 70 murders and attempted murders, including those at Loughinisland.

The ombudsman said there was no evidence the security forces had forewarning of the Loughinisland attack.

He said that after the murders, Special Branch did not appear to use sources in an effort to catch the killers.

"I have found no evidence that sources were tasked with gathering specific information that could have assisted the murder investigation," he said.

"This was a 'hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil' approach to the use of some informants, which potentially frustrated the police investigation."

Dr Maguire said many officers in the RUC and their successors in the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) worked tirelessly to catch the killers, but he also identified a series of major failures in the investigation.

A report by previous police ombudsman Al Hutchinson in 2011 found that the RUC failed to properly investigate what happened in Loughinisland but said there was insufficient evidence of collusion.

Those findings were quashed after a legal challenge by relatives of those killed and Dr Maguire undertook a fresh investigation.

Those murdered were Barney Green, 87, Adrian Rogan, 34, Malcolm Jenkinson, 53, Daniel McCreanor, 59, Patrick O'Hare, 35, and Eamon Byrne, 39.

PSNI Chief Constable George Hamilton accepted the report's findings and said officers involved in collusion should be held to account.

"This report makes uncomfortable reading, particularly in relation to the alleged actions of police officers at the time," he said.

"The ombudsman has stated that collusion was a feature of these murders in that there were both wilful and passive acts carried out by police officers. This is totally unacceptable and those responsible should be held accountable."

He added: "These were appalling murders carried out by those with evil intent and I am very aware of the hurt and anger felt by the families of those killed and those injured. The PSNI remains firmly committed to apprehending those responsible for these murders and appeal to the community for information to allow us to do so."

A UK Government spokesman described the events at Loughinisland as appalling and unjustifiable.

"The report makes clear that those responsible for the carnage at Loughinisland were the terrorists who planned and carried it out," said the spokesman.

"It also reaches some very grave conclusions about the conduct of the police.

"The Government takes allegations of wrongdoing by the police very seriously. Where there is evidence it should be pursued and those responsible held accountable. Everyone is subject to the rule of law."

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph