Belfast Telegraph

Thursday 3 September 2015

Scottish independence would not reopen Northern Ireland divisions: John Reid

Former NI Secretary says that after years of British and Irish 'rapprochement ' it would be paradoxical if Scotland separated

By Mark McLaughlin

Published 08/06/2014

John Reid says the Scottish referendum does not have a particular implication for Northern Ireland
John Reid says the Scottish referendum does not have a particular implication for Northern Ireland

Fears that Scottish independence could reopen divisions in Ireland have been dismissed by former Northern Ireland Secretary John Reid.

Mr Reid said the Scottish referendum does not have "a particular implication for Ireland", in response to concerns by Swedish foreign minister Carl Bilt, who said independence would lead to the "Balkanisation" of the UK.

He accused First Minister Alex Salmond of running a Monty Python-esque campaign by deliberately ignoring the benefits of the UK and the risks of independence.

Mr Reid, also a former Scottish Secretary, welcomed the fact that all political parties are now committed to improving devolution "if necessary".

"I think Scotland and Ireland are two separate issues," Mr Reid told the Press Association ahead of a Better Together speech in Stirling.

"Personally I welcome the fact that in recent years there has being a growing rapprochement between the governments of the UK and Ireland.

"I am very proud to have played a small part of that when I was Irish Secretary and in other cabinet posts.

"I think in doing that we are helping to make up for some of the mistakes of history.

"So, at a time when there is, in a sense, a coming together after so many years, indeed centuries, of the UK and Ireland, I think it would be paradoxical if Scotland was to separate from the rest of the UK at precisely that time.

"I don't think it has a particular implication for Northern Ireland.

"If the UK breaks up it will have wide repercussions outside the UK. When the President of the United States says that, it's an indication of the difficulties.

"When the prime minister of Spain, the president of the European Commission and the foreign ministers of the Scandinavian countries say that, it's an indication that they are concerned about the wider implications of it."

He added: "All the major parties are now committed to looking at the details of the constitutional settlement and improving it if necessary.

"Life is constantly changing. I constructed the devolution plan that is now in place with Gordon Brown and others.

"But if there is sense in looking again at this, as all the major parties now think, that is something that I would support.

"It may need to bring together some kind of convention or discussion amongst all the other parties to see what has the widest possible support."

During his speech, Mr Reid said: "We have been going through a sort of Monty Python period of exchange.

"Every time I hear the SNP respond to an argument it reminds me of the sketch: 'What have the Romans ever done for us?'.

"What has the UK done for us? Well, it gave us financial stability from the period after the Darien Scheme when Scotland was very badly affected by a catastrophic economic mistake through to a few years ago when RBS ended up with toxic debt greater than the GDP of Scotland.

"They, say: 'Well, I give you that - but what has the UK ever done for us?'."

He added: "It is possible to look at an elephant and swear that there is no such animal, but it doesn't make it a reality.

"The more the Scottish Nationalists say that ratings agencies don't know anything about ratings, that the governor of the Bank of England doesn't know anything about sterling, that the president of Europe doesn't know anything about Europe, that the Institute for Fiscal Studies doesn't know anything about fiscal studies, that economic experts don't know anything about economics, you begin to think that however sincere Alex Salmond's commitment is his pursuit of his own objectives are blinding him to reality.

"We got rid of the divine right of kings and we are not about to restore divine wisdom to Alex Salmond who can, by decree, suspend reality."

From the web

Sponsored Videos

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph