Peer wins first round in trespass legal battle
One of Northern Ireland's richest men has secured an order to stop trespassing on his land in a dispute over access to a stretch of Co Down beach.
Lord Ballyedmond, head of Norbrook Laboratories, was granted a High Court injunction against Newry and Mourne District Council restraining it from using a laneway on his estate.
The authority had sought an alternative direction for the removal of metal fences erected on the land close to the foreshore at Killowen.
But Mr Justice Deeny ruled yesterday that the status quo should remain with Lord Ballyedmond until the case is ultimately decided at full trial.
He said: “The onus is on the council to prove the public have a right of way, not on the owner of the land to disprove it.”
The judge resisted a bid to extend the injunction to include a prohibition on any form of encouragement to use the lane. He did so after lawyers for the council pledged to do nothing that would flout the terms of the order.
The court heard how the local authority had carried out an inquiry and formed the view that there was a public right of way.
But after coming to that opinion there were a number of “unfortunate confrontations” at the scene, said Mr Justice Deeny.
Lord Ballyedmond applied for an order restraining any trespassing on the land and to stop the council from claiming the public could use it.
The judge pointed to one of the arguments being about alleged trespassers being close to “sensitive research facilities” for Norbrook Laboratories, the Newry-based pharmaceutical
company. Applying a legal test, Mr Justice Deeny held that status quo rests with Lord Ballyedmond as owner of the land under dispute.
A senior barrister for the council argued there was no need to grant an injunction due to the physical obstruction put in place.
He described it as large, spiked fencing set in concrete.
The lawyer added: “My client will take no steps that will in any way impinge the order of the court and will respect the order of the court completely.”
As he granted the interim injunction to Lord Ballyedmond, Mr Justice Deeny also stressed how the case was still to be resolved.
He said: “In my view the outcome of this dispute at trial remains an open issue with both parties having an arguable case.”
A week-long hearing is expected to take place at the High Court later this year.