McGuinness: The once reviled gunman now a politician of note
Monday, 30 November 2009
Trust may still be a long way off, but are Protestants beginning — tentatively, and in small numbers, but starting nonetheless — to accept in government the man most of them would once have detested?
That is the most interesting question arising from today’s opinion poll.
Perhaps more than any other Northern Ireland politician, Martin McGuinness has arguably come to embody the peace process in terms of its past, present and potential.
No other individual has shifted from the leadership of the most efficient terrorist killing machine to the very top of Stormont’s power-sharing administration.
A man who was once so reviled and feared that his words — and those of his Sinn Fein colleagues — were spoken by actors is now recognised as the most impressive politician in the devolution era.
And as today’s Belfast Telegraph/Inform Communications survey underpins, no other Executive minister has performed with such aplomb or made such a cross-community impact. He is streets ahead of even his nearest rival (and she is a party colleague, Agriculture Minister Michelle Gildernew).
Whether it’s this poll or last week’s award from the political insiders involved in the Slugger O’Toole website which named him Politician of the Year, the accolades keep on coming for Mr McGuinness.
But it is a significant rating among Protestants to the question of which Stormont minister has “most impressed” — higher than for most unionist ministers, apart from Peter Robinson, Sir Reg Empey and Arlene Foster — which most surprises.
Professor Rick Wilford, acting head of the School of Politics at Queen’s University, Belfast, believes Mr McGuinness’ poll endorsement is recognition that he has made the transition from violent past to political present. And he predicts it may make it easier to accept Mr McGuinness in a more prominent role.
“While for many unionists such recognition and respect may be grudging, nevertheless it is a remarkable outcome which suggests that should Sinn Fein emerge as the largest single party at the next Assembly election, then his prospective role as First Minister may not be regarded as an unmitigated disaster by many, including some unionists,” he said.
The key moment may have been when Mr McGuinness referred to dissident republican groups who killed two soldiers and a PSNI officer in March as “traitors to the people of Ireland”.
Although Sinn Fein strategists will be slightly wary of the effect Mr McGuinness’ popularity with a Stormont government has on its own grassroots, it is unlikely that he will face the same backlash that met the Rev Ian Paisley from supporters angry at his close ties with a former enemy.
Though he doesn’t do the sackcloth and ashes his ‘Chuckle Brother’ Mr Paisley once asked for, Mr McGuinness has a quality of not taking other people’s enmity personally, and showing opponents respect.
And outside of the complicated area of forgiveness, there is a trait in human nature which can’t help but respond positively to that.
Post a comment
Limit: 500 characters
View all comments that have been posted about this article
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.
Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.



















You see, jonathan? Using the likes of "command respect" and "enemy" is why those non-unionists would appear to have the opinion that the poll showed in respect of unionist like Peter Robinson.
Nobody commanding respect will ever garner support. Commanding respect smacks of subservitude.
And as for enemy, it would appear that there is some form of outreach from some parties in Northern Ireland to understand the concerns of others while others remain stuck in there ways.
What you see is an evolution of a party, not stagnation that is apparent in others.
Posted by Ulysses32 | 02.12.09, 15:29 GMT
Mandela he was branded as a murdering terrorist who was responsible for the Pretoria bombings etc. which killed innocent people. He is now the Greatest man in the whole world now. Way to go for the price of "freedom" for who really? A new rich elite. Soon Bin Laden & Co. will be viewed as a freedom fighter hero.
Posted by Megan Slyper | 02.12.09, 10:56 GMT
they're all wild in Derry like!
Posted by Greg | 30.11.09, 22:23 GMT
People are beginning to open their eyes and pay closer attention to what is going on around them. I think that all parties will have to up their game if they want to keep their electorate on board. I foresee a major shift within Unionism especially. The UUP/Conservative coalition will become a major player again. While Jim and Peter try to out extreme each other the UUP/Tory coalition is going about its business in a much more professional way and appears to be concentrating on issues that affect everyone across the board.
There is also the PUP to consider and in Dawn Purvis they at least have a credible leader.
Using these forums as a yardstick I can see where ordinary voters are becoming disillusioned with intransigence and are wanting things to move forward for the common good. If dissidents have the temerity to put forward candidates in an election I believe they would lose their deposits. The country needs and deserves a true and lasting peace.
Posted by HC | 30.11.09, 21:16 GMT
Mr McGuinness will never command respect from any right thinking unionists. This man is our enemy and should be treated with contempt. He may laugh with Paisley but where is Paisley now? He will face the ultimate judgment for his actions eventually .
Posted by jonathan | 30.11.09, 18:12 GMT
An interesting and well balanced piece.
Posted by matt | 30.11.09, 11:33 GMT