Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Berkeley balcony collapse: Irish US ambassador writes to New York Times over 'despicable' coverage of tragedy

Published 17/06/2015

Two women embrace while watching sheriff's deputies move the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Two women embrace while watching sheriff's deputies move the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Police at the scene of a balcony collapse at an apartment building near UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
section of collapsed balcony remains on the front of an apartment building new UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley, California (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)

The New York Times has issued a statement following sharp criticism over its coverage of the tragedy in Berkeley in which six Irish students died, and another seven were injured.

The prestigious newspaper used the tragedy of a balcony collapsing to bring up negative stories about J1 students in the past.

Police at the scene of a balcony collapse at an apartment building near UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Police at the scene of a balcony collapse at an apartment building near UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
Two women embrace while watching sheriff's deputies move the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Police examine the scene of a balcony collapse in Berkeley, Calif. on Tuesday, June 16, 2015 (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Bottles line the inside of a fourth floor apartment where a balcony collapsed at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif. on Tuesday, June 16, 2015 (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Flowers and a cigarette box form a makeshift shrine near the area where a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
People gather at the scene of a balcony collapse in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Sheriff's deputy transport the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
section of collapsed balcony remains on the front of an apartment building new UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley, California (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)

"They come by the thousands — Irish students on work visas, many flocking to the West Coast to work in summer jobs by day and to enjoy the often raucous life in a college town at night," it begins.

"It was, for many, a rite of passage, one last summer to enjoy travel abroad before beginning a career."

The NYT - regarded as one of the world's most-prestigious papers - then displayed an incredible lack of compassion, adding that the work-visa programme used by Irish students has “become not just a source of aspiration, but also a source of embarrassment for Ireland, marked by a series of high-profile episodes involving drunken partying and the wrecking of apartments in places like San Francisco and Santa Barbara”.

The Republic's Equality Minister Aodhán Ó Ríordáin has branded the article a "disgrace" in a tweet sent to the paper, and the article has created a storm on social media with some users describing it as “crass” and “insensitive”.

In a letter to the editor Irish US ambassador, Anne Anderson, said: "It is quite simply wrong to say that the J1 visa programme is 'a source of embarrassment for Ireland'.  On the contrary, we are fully supportive of this programme and we know that it brings enormous mutual benefit. 

"Some of our best and brightest young people participate; they come for a summer in the US on the threshold of their adult lives, and take back experiences and memories that establish life-long bonds.  And they make a real contribution here; one of the messages of condolence we received yesterday put it simply:  'We welcome their energy and joy'."

"At this time of searing grief, the messages of condolence and offers of support which are flooding in to the Embassy and our Consulates are balm to the soul.  They reflect far more accurately the feelings of the American people than does your article. "

The letter can be read in full here.

The New York Times has responded to the criticism. Public editor Margaret Sullivan offered her "sincere sympathy" to all those affected by the tragedy in a blog post. She added: "I can say not only that I believe many of the complaints were valid, but also that I’m very sorry for the pain the story caused."

NYT Vice President Eileen Murphy said: "We understand and agree that some of the language in the piece could be interpreted as insensitive, particularly in such close proximity to this tragedy."

But Renua Leader Lucinda Creighton has said that the New York Times should withdraw their grotesque article on the Berkeley tragedy.

“It is truly ghoulish that at a time where sensitivity is required in dealing with the utterly sad plight of families which have to deal with the death of young children that the New York Times, a supposedly reputable media outlet would launch such a facile assault upon the character and activities of young Irish students," she said.

"The despicable New York Times piece by contrast appears to have used the deaths of these young people to engage in a diatribe about young Irish people that the racists in the 19th century Punch magazine would be embarrassed by," she added.

Politicians unite to remember dead

The normal business of the Dail was suspended in one of many marks of respect for the dead in the US balcony collapse.

Two women who knew victims of the collapse embrace at the scene in Berkeley, California on Tuesday, June 16, 2015. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Two women who knew victims of the collapse embrace at the scene in Berkeley, California on Tuesday, June 16, 2015. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
People gather at the scene of a balcony collapse in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A sheriff's deputy prepares to move the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Police at the scene of a balcony collapse at an apartment building near UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
section of collapsed balcony remains on the front of an apartment building new UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley, California (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)

Taoiseach Enda Kenny led messages of condolence to the parents, families and friends of those affected by the tragedy while a minister has been dispatched to San Francisco to lead the consular response on the ground.

"We've all been shocked by the loss of life and injured," Mr Kenny said.

"It is a terrible situation to have such a serious and sad incident to take place at the beginning of a summer's activity and opportunity for so many young people on J1 visas in the US."

A team of Government officials were on hand in Dublin Airport to support relatives travelling to the US west coast while consular staff from the Irish diplomatic corps in San Francisco met them on arrival.

Jimmy Deenihan, junior minister responsible for issues relating to the Irish diaspora, has been asked to lead the response in California and liaise with families alongside local consul general Philip Grant.

Mr Kenny said he would act as a Government presence in solidarity with the affected families and the young people who remain in San Francisco.

Flags flew at half mast at Government Buildings, at University College Dublin where three of the students studied and at the US embassy in Dublin.

Books of condolence were also opened by the university, with thousands of people signing online, while other books were being opened in the Mansion House in Dublin and in Cork and Galway.

Tanaiste and Labour Party leader Joan Burton, a former J1 student, said there are no words to describe the horror of the events at Berkeley.

Rubble and plastic cups line a sidewalk below the area where a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Rubble and plastic cups line a sidewalk below the area where a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
Two women embrace while watching sheriff's deputies move the body of a person who died when a fourth floor balcony collapsed in Berkeley (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A group stands in the lobby at Highland Hospital, where some victims from a balcony that collapsed were taken (AP Photo/Jeff Chiu)
Police at the scene of a balcony collapse at an apartment building near UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
section of collapsed balcony remains on the front of an apartment building new UC Berkeley on June 16, 2015 in Berkeley, California (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)
A fourth floor balcony rests on the balcony below after collapsing at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, Calif., early Tuesday, June 16, 2015. Berkeley police say several people are dead and others injured after the balcony fell shortly before 1 a.m., near the University of California, Berkeley. (AP Photo/Noah Berger)

"A J1 is meant to be a rite of passage, an opportunity to gain valuable life and cultural experience in a country, the US, that's so dear to all of our hearts.

"It is for a lot of people the summer of love, the summer of fun, and when you see those faces today in the snapshots on social media and the newspapers I think it brings back to everybody what those days are meant to be.

"Today though six families are heartbroken. Their children are wrenched away from them in the most dreadful of circumstances."

Micheal Martin, leader of the main opposition party Fianna Fail, said everybody in Ireland was thinking of the grieving families.

"The J1 programme is essentially a programme for young people and it brings to mind opportunity, a summer of fun, a summer of happiness, new eras beckoning, relationships and so forth," he said.

"That's why it has such a resonance."

Gerry Adams, Sinn Fein president, said: " It's easy to imagine the energy, the fun and excitement at that party before the disaster.

"It's a dreadful, stark reminder of the fragility of life, of the uncertainty of life, especially when the victims are so young, so vibrant and so full of potential."

Books of condolence were also opened at St Patrick's Cathedral in Dublin and University College Cork.

Foreign Affairs Minister Charlie Flanagan said concerns were also turning to the impact the trauma will have on those who survived the accident and those who witnessed it.

"We are also conscious that many Irish students were not physically injured, but were left deeply shocked and saddened by the loss of friends and classmates in this terrible accident," he said.

"The consulate has worked with local authorities in Berkeley to set up an incident centre in Berkeley, where grief counsellors will be on site and people will also have facilities to make phone calls home."

Extra diplomatic staff have been flown into San Francisco to support families while local authorities in Berkeley and Irish community organisations in the Bay area have been working together to provide transport and accommodation to those who need it.

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph