Belfast Telegraph

Wednesday 22 October 2014

Costa Concordia cruise tragedy: Officer was warned of danger just before impact

The cruise ship Costa Concordia leans on its side Monday, Jan.16, 2012, after running aground near the tiny Tuscan island of Giglio, Italy, last Friday. The rescue operation was called off mid-afternoon Monday after the Costa Concordia shifted a few inches (centimeters) in rough seas. The fear is that if the ship shifts significantly, some 500,000 gallons of fuel may begin to leak. (AP Photo/Gregorio Borgia)
In this underwater photo released by the Italian Coast Guard Monday, Jan. 16, 2012 the cruise ship Costa Concordia leans on its side, after it ran aground off the tiny Tuscan island of Isola del Giglio, Italy. The Costa Concordia ran aground on Friday after colliding with a rock. (AP Photo/Italian Coast Guard, ho)
GIGLIO PORTO, ITALY - JANUARY 14: Crowds gather on the island of Giglio, where passengers aboard the cruise ship Costa Concordia have been staying after the vessel ran aground, on January 14, 2012 in Giglio Porto, Italy. More than four thousand people were on board when the ship hit a sandbank. At least 3 people have been confirmed dead and another 50 are unaccounted for. (Photo by Laura Lezza/Getty Images)

The captain of the Costa Concordia cruise ship, Francesco Schettino - under arrest on suspicion of multiple manslaughter and abandoning his ship, is reported to have summoned the ship's head waiter to the bridge just before it struck a reef, resulting in the deaths of up to 22 people.

Witnesses said Antonello Tievoli told the captain to be careful and warned him that he was "extremely close to the shore" of his native Giglio where the vessel has previously performed a spectacular sail-past with its horn blasting and lights blazing.

The ship's owners, Costa Cruises, blamed "human error" for Friday night's disaster involving 4,200 passengers, which is set to become the biggest insurance loss in maritime history.

Clarence Mitchell, who is representing Costa Cruises, confirmed that the captain had been approaching the island to "make a salute".

He said: "The company says this (incident) was caused by an attempt by the captain to show the ship to the port. But there's a criminal investigation and we're not going to say anything that's going to compromise that or the captain's case."

Prosecutor Francesco Verusio said the captain's actions were "inexcusable", describing the final tack as "unscrupulous and reckless".

A judge will decide today whether to charge the captain over the shipwreck.

Meanwhile, a sixth body was discovered as the search for a further 16 missing passengers continued into the night.

Italy is preparing to declare a state of emergency amid fears of a major environmental disaster caused by up to half a million gallons of heavy fuel oil leaking into the pristine waters of the dolphin sanctuary where the luxury liner struck a rock.

Rescuers were forced to temporarily abandon their hunt for survivors when the 114,500-tonne ship began sliding in heavy seas with the weather expected to worsen in the coming days.

Hopes of finding anyone alive are diminishing after firefighters concluded their investigation of cabins and areas above the water level.

Divers will now begin probing the submerged part of the multi-storey vessel.

Italy's Environment Minister Corrado Clini said the risk of an ecological disaster was now "very, very high". The Concordia had just left port with 2,300-tonnes of oil on board contained in 17 double hulled tanks.

"The aim is to prevent the fuel leaking out of the ship. We are working to avoid this. It is urgent and time is running out," Mr Clini said.

The International Maritime Organisation said lessons must be learnt from the wreck and that regulations on the safety of large passenger ships could now be reviewed pending the results of the Italian investigations.

Images of the overturned cruiser and horror stories of terrified passengers struggling to find lifeboats in the dark could have a serious impact on the £34bn cruising industry.

Shares in Carnival, the London and Miami-based owners of Costa, slumped yesterday.

Lost revenues as the ship is salvaged and refitted are expected to top £62m this year alone, with one analyst suggesting the final cost to Carnival, which operates 101 vessels around the world, could be up to £652m -- much of which will be shouldered by insurers with knock-on effects for policyholders.

The tragedy occurred during the traditional post-Christmas boost to bookings.

But the industry was at pains to point out that the 10-fold growth in passenger numbers since the 1970s was unlikely to be stemmed in the long term with three even bigger new ships due to be launched this year including the 130,000-tonne Carnival Breeze.

(© Independent News Service)

Q&A: The cruise disaster

Q Why did the Costa Concordia approach within 200 metres of the shore?



A Statements from crew members and local officials suggest the unofficial approach by the vessel's captain, Francesco Schettino, pictured, was to please tourists, crew members and even Giglio locals.



Q Why did the Costa Concordia's officers take so long to sound the alarm?



A Reports have emerged of Italian passengers aboard the vessel calling Italian police with their mobile phones, while the ship's authorities sought to assure passengers the vessel was suffering only "electrical problems". Given the disastrous size of the ship's impact with the rocks and the rate at which it began listing, the ship's captain might find this question hard to answer.



Q How inept was the rescue effort and the evacuation procedure?



A The ship's crew and the owners of the vessel have been attacked for chaotic scenes and lack of advice and preparedness. But Pier Luigi Foschi, the head of the vessel's operator, Costa Crociere, noted yesterday that 20 or fewer deaths following the emergency evacuation of more than 4,000 people into cold seas, suggested procedures worked fairly well.



Q Are any more of the missing people likely to be found alive?



A With so much time – 72 hours – having passed, in such cold conditions, and with no sounds coming from inside the capsized vessel, this now appears unlikely.



Q Will emergency services be able to stop the Costa Concordia's 2,000-tonne fuel consignment from leaking into the sea?



A Last night, authorities were putting a brave face on their fight to stop an eco-disaster. Without going into details, they insisted diving crews had made progress in securing the fuel tanks before removing the diesel oil they contain. However, small amounts of oil began to appear near the vessel by yesterday afternoon.



Michael Day

Latest News

Latest Sport

Latest Showbiz