Belfast Telegraph

Friday 25 April 2014

Germany demands explanation from British ambassador Simon McDonald over GCHQ's 'secret listening post in the heart of Berlin'

Concerns have been raised that Britain operates a top-secret listening post from its Berlin embassy to eavesdrop on the seat of German power. Photograph shows GCHQ's main base in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire
Concerns have been raised that Britain operates a top-secret listening post from its Berlin embassy to eavesdrop on the seat of German power. Photograph shows GCHQ's main base in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire

Britain’s ambassador Simon McDonald was called in by the German Foreign Minister Guido Westerwelle after allegations emerged that a secret listening post is operating from its embassy in Berlin, just yards from the German parliament and Angela Merkel’s offices.

Mr McDonald met senior officials and was bluntly warned that any interception of data by intelligence services from a diplomatic facility would be in violation of international law.

It is believed to be the first time that Germany has called in a UK ambassador in this way since the end of the Second World War.

Documents leaked by Edward Snowden, the US National Security Agency whistleblower, suggest that the UK is operating an “intercept nest” from the roof of its embassy. After the claims received widespread attention in the German media, the Foreign Minister, Mr Westerwelle, requested a statement from the ambassador.

Mr McDonald, formerly David Cameron’s foreign policy adviser and head of foreign and defence policy in the Cabinet Office, relayed the conversation back to London.

Last month the US ambassador received an official complaint following revelations about a listening post on top of the American embassy that was intercepting calls from Chancellor Merkel’s mobile phone. The US and UK embassies are just yards apart, close to the Bundestag and the Chancellery, Mrs Merkel’s prime ministerial offices.

Downing Street sought to play down the scale of the rift, with David Cameron’s spokesman insisting Mr McDonald had been “invited”, to the ministry. The spokesman said Mr Cameron had an “excellent” relationship with both Ms Merkel and her government, and that it would continue.

But a senior British diplomat who recently worked at the Berlin embassy took a different view of events, calling the spying claims and their aftermath “acutely embarrassing”. He said: “The problem is that because one can’t discuss what is being done, it’s easy to draw the worst possible inference.

“All I can say is that we have excellent intelligence-sharing with Germany and we don’t want that to be damaged by this. However, if this leads to better dialogue on this issue, then at least something positive has happened.”

How Britain bugged the Soviets

Secret bugging operations similar to the British and American Berlin embassy operations have been making the news for more than 40 years. 

Germany's foreign affairs minister Guido Westerwelle has summoned Britain's ambassador in Berlin (AP)
Germany's foreign affairs minister Guido Westerwelle has summoned Britain's ambassador

In 1971, American news columnist Jack Anderson reported that  NSA and GCHQ were successfully monitoring Soviet leaders’ radio links from Russian-made Zil limousines, producing streams of information about foreign policy and military intentions – but also revealing that the Soviet leaders “banter and bicker … and gossip”. “The leaders … complain about their ailments like old maids,”  he wrote.

As with the Snowden leaks, at the time the NSA claimed that the Anderson leak caused the Russians to shut down their use of limo phones.

This was not true – the Soviets just went on chattering. On 26 May 1972, according to released US documents, the embassy suites produced information that was vital to securing the East-West agreement not to use anti-missile missiles.

The Russians’ real response to the revelation was to blast both embassies with high intensity radio signals, in a failed attempt  to jam the receiving equipment. The radio onslaught provoked concerns for the health and  safety of both diplomats and spies.

DUNCAN CAMPBELL

Britain’s GCHQ has ‘secret listening post in the heart of Berlin to eavesdrop on the seat of German power' 

GCHQ accused of hacking Google

GCHQ fears challenges over spying

NSA phone spying row: Angela Merkel and Francois Hollande demand talks with US

Civil liberties groups claim British spy agency GCHQ broke European laws by hacking millions of citizens’ internet data

UK has secret Middle-East web surveillance base collecting emails, phone calls and web traffic 

Latest News

Latest Sport

Latest Showbiz