Saudi judge says it's fine to beat wives
Published 12/05/2009 | 11:10
A Saudi judge told a conference on domestic violence that a man has the right to slap his wife if she spends lavishly on such things as clothing.
The remarks - which have drawn criticism from rights activists in the conservative kingdom - do not carry the weight of law, as they were made out of court. But such public pronouncements by Saudi judges, who are also Islamic clerics, are often widely respected.
Those campaigning for women's rights in Saudi Arabia said the comments were another setback in efforts to gain the right to vote, drive and freely participate in politics.
"If a person gives 1,200 Saudi riyals (£212) to his wife and she spends 900 riyals (£159) to purchase an abaya (head-to-toe robe) from a brand shop and if her husband slaps her on the face as a reaction to her action, she deserves that punishment," Judge Hamad Al-Razine was quoted as saying by the English-language Arab News newspaper on Sunday.
The comments at a recent conference were given as part of an explanation for an increase in domestic violence in the country. The judge said women were equally responsible for the increase, the newspaper quoted him as saying.
The paper did not say exactly when the conference was held. The judge could not be reached for comment today.
Women in the audience loudly protested the judge's remarks, the newspaper said.
Saudi Arabia bars women from voting, except for chamber of commerce elections in two cities in recent years, and no woman can sit in the kingdom's Cabinet. Women also cannot drive or travel without permission from a male guardian.
Sohaila Zenelabideen Hammad, spokeswoman of the Saudi National Centre for Human Rights, said today that the judge's remarks are reason for concern for being "too extreme".
"It is not acceptable, it is even forbidden in Islam to beat a woman on her face. No matter what the woman does, the man has no right whatsoever and under any circumstances to beat his wife on the face," said Hammad, who was not at the conference.
"Regrettably, there is a common understanding in the Arab and Islamic world that man is the master who looks down on the woman and has the right to do whatever he wants to her. This is wrong," Hammad said.