Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home News World

South Africa aiming to withdraw from International Criminal Court

Published 21/10/2016

Omar al-Bashir is wanted by the tribunal for alleged war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide (AP)
Omar al-Bashir is wanted by the tribunal for alleged war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide (AP)

South Africa has said it will submit a bill in parliament to withdraw from the International Criminal Court, raising concerns of a possible African exodus from a human rights tribunal accused by some leaders of unfairly targeting their continent.

The South African announcement follows a similar decision by Burundi this week and was criticised by human rights groups that see the ICC as the best means of pursuing perpetrators of the world's worst atrocities.

The departure of other African countries would severely undermine the court, whose treaty entered into force in 2002 after years of efforts by South Africa's post-apartheid government and others.

The debate over withdrawal from the ICC is expected to be a "hot issue" at an African Union summit in January in Ethiopia, said Oryem Okello, deputy foreign minister of Uganda.

"As a country, we are still undecided," Mr Okello said. "We think the matter is best decided as a bloc."

South Africa's announcement is "devastating" for the ICC and its efforts to hold those responsible for alleged crimes against humanity to account, said Mark Kersten, a Britain-based researcher.

"It is unclear if other states will follow South Africa's lead, but it is clear that states are more likely to follow South Africa's lead than Burundi, with whom many African states have tensions," he said.

Kenya, Namibia and Uganda are among the countries that have indicated interest in leaving the court, he added.

Many African countries were initially supportive of the court partly because of the 1994 Rwandan genocide, but have grown uneasy with it due to scrutiny of national leaders suspected of war crimes and other violations.

Under the Rome Statute that created the court, signatory countries have a legal obligation to arrest anyone sought by the tribunal.

The treaty that created the court is "in conflict and inconsistent with" South Africa's diplomatic immunity law, said justice minister Michael Masutha.

"A difficult choice had to be made," Mr Masutha said. The treaty hinders South Africa's goal of promoting peace talks, which can include hosting adversaries on its soil, he added.

South Africa's announcement follows a dispute last year over a visit by Sudanese president Omar al-Bashir, who is wanted by the ICC for alleged war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide in Darfur.

He was allowed to leave South Africa even though a local court ordered authorities to stop him because of the international order for his arrest.

South Africa submitted its intention to withdraw from the International Criminal Court in a letter delivered at the United Nations this week.

The country's main opposition party, the Democratic Alliance, said it would go to court to try to declare the government's decision unconstitutional. Richard Goldstone, a South African who was an international criminal prosecutor, said the move was demeaning to South Africans.

"From a moral standpoint, it detracts from the inspiring legacy of the administration of president Nelson Mandela that so strongly supported the ICC and all of the mechanisms of international justice," Mr Goldstone said.

Observers say a withdrawal from the ICC takes effect a year after the UN secretary-general is formally notified of a country's intention. Countries would have to co-operate with any ICC proceedings that begin before the withdrawal takes effect.

On Tuesday, president Pierre Nkurunziza of Burundi signed legislation to make his country the first to withdraw from the ICC, which had said it would investigate recent political violence there.

More than a year of deadly violence has followed Mr Nkurunziza's decision to pursue a third term, which some have called unconstitutional.

The ICC, based in The Hague, Netherlands, had 124 member states before Burundi's move.

The push among some African countries to withdraw began after it indicted Kenyan president Uhuru Kenyatta on charges of crimes against humanity for 2007 post-election violence in which more than 1,000 died.

The ICC prosecutor said threats to witnesses, bribery and lack of co-operation by Kenya's government led to the case's collapse.

Only Africans have been charged in the six cases that are ongoing or about to begin, though preliminary ICC investigations have been opened elsewhere in the world.

The African Union has said it will not compel member states to arrest a leader on behalf of the ICC.

AP

Press Association

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph