Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

US Election: record turnout could cause chaos

Sunday, 2 November 2008

The United States has an electoral system that is not organised, designed or funded to cope with "anywhere near a 100% turnout" as an estimated 130 million Americans head to the polls, according to the director of a leading independent electoral reform group.

Doug Chapin, director of The Pew Charitable Trust's Electionline.org, said voter turnout will "dwarf" all other problems in this year's presidential election as an estimated 70% of registered voters try to cast their ballots.

"The challenge is we will get closer to 100% turnout on election day this year than ever before," he said.

Mr Chapin said the US typically sees a turnout in the "high 50s to 70% range" but added: "You now see some states forecasting, 80%, 85%, even 90% turnout of their registered voters on election day.

"And this flood of new voters is going to challenge the system in a way that it really never has been before."

He said if there was a problem at the front of the line at a polling station, this was an inconvenience if there were 10 people in the queue.

But he went on: "If there are 100 people in line it is a problem; if there are a 1,000 people in line, it's a crisis.

"Given the number of folks that we have coming out to vote this year, any problem that occurs at the point of voting has the potential to be a real challenge on election day."

He said many states were "overwhelmed and in many ways overrun" by the number of voters during the primary season, but were "fully prepared, or what they think is fully prepared, for record turnout across the country" on Tuesday.

"It is an article of faith and job mission of every election official in the United States that every eligible American who wishes to do so should have the right to cast a ballot and have that ballot count," he said.

"The truth however, is that, given how decentralised our system is and the disputes over our system, we do not necessarily have a system that is organised, designed or funded to handle anywhere near a 100% turnout."

He said the voting system was "startlingly" decentralised.

"It is a myth that there is a United States' election system," he said.

"We have at least 50 separate state systems; in actuality, probably closer to thousands of state and local election systems.

"I would be very surprised if we don't hear more of, 'We need to centralise elections more' after this election."

He said the problems caused by voter turnout were already being seen in reports of early problems related to long queues, scattered reports of machine problems, and a "system characterised by overwhelming demand".

Asked if the US could see another problem such as the one in Florida which dogged the 2008 election, Mr Chapin said: "I can state unequivocally, maybe we will."

He said three states would be worth watching closely for any problems.

Florida, the home of the "hanging chads" and spoiled ballots of 2000, has been a "symbol of election reform" since and has seen "as much change, if not more, than any other state in the country".

Ohio, a "plumb political catch" is usually very closely fought and "no dispute in this country has taken place since 2000 without taking place in some meaningful way (here)," he added.

And Colorado, also a key battleground state this year, is "as unsettled in its election administration as any state in the country right now", he said.

It was one of the last in the country to complete a required upgrade to its state-wide voter rolls, its chief state election official is a candidate for the US Congress, and its state election director recently resigned.

Mr Chapin, who also wrote a report subtitled "What if we had an election and everyone came?", said: "Many people out there are predicting problems at the polls. We don't yet know that that is warranted.

"If we have a problem... it will be because of something completely unexpected, not because of a lack of preparation."

He said voters had shown increased interest this year, not just in the candidates but also in the mechanics of casting their votes.

"So while we won't know until polls close on election day whether or not we have avoided the problems of the past, there are signs for optimism."

In the UK, the 2005 general election saw a national turnout of 61.36%.

Last week, MPs were told that Britain should learn from the expected high turnout in the presidential election.

Commons leader Harriet Harman said a lack of voter registration and low turnout was something that had to be tackled in Britain, particularly among people living in inner cities.

"It looks set to be an election with very high turnout from people who previously have not necessarily voted, people who have registered to vote and then have gone out to vote," she said in the House of Commons.

"One of the things that all of us should be preoccupied to tackle is lack of registration, particularly in inner city areas and among poorer people and low voting turnout.

"If there is something we can learn from the American elections about more people voting and more young people voting then that is something we should look to."

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

In Oregon we have had exclusive vote-by-mail elections for a number of years and it is surprising that only Washington has followed our lead. The ballots come a couple of weeks before the election date and can be mailed back or dropped off at library or election office collection sites. Unlike Washington only ballots received by the elections office by the election date are counted so we have no problem with waiting for late mailed ballots and results are available just like any other state. It works well, gives you time to study the voters pamphlet while you vote and the paper ballots can be manually recounted if necessary. Hopefully other states with the long lines and problems will take a look at our system.

Posted by Kathy S. | 04.11.08, 00:07 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

It's all a concpiracy. like Jim Cullen said its not that difficult, In canada voting realy is very simple. Its easier to manipulate the ballot count if there is complications..maybe??

Posted by Fred Nat | 03.11.08, 23:26 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Our voting problems certainly are an embarrassment.

There are a lot of changes that need to be made. Three I can think of are: get rid of the Electoral College; make voting easier; and give other parties an easier route to visibility.

Posted by Heidi S. | 03.11.08, 19:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

An Ode To American Voting

We must fix voting.
Our elderly and sick can't wait in line.

We must fix voting.
Registration must be streamlined.

We must fix voting.
We owe it to our founding fathers.

We must fix voting.
No one should have to wait for hours.

We must fix voting.
The decisions are hard enough.

We must fix voting.
There's no excuse for making it this tough.

They run large crowds through Disneyland.
So I would say, Oh, Yes We Can!"

To make it work, and have our say,
We must fix voting, and start today!

Posted by ConcernedMilf | 02.11.08, 20:02 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Solution: Washington State has, save for two counties, embraced a mail-in system - basically formalized absentee ballots. Upon receiving your ballot you have a couple of weeks to fill it out. The method of marking the ballot is unambiguous - it consists of simply connecting a broken arrow pointing at the candidate of your choice with a line in blue or black ink. It is then sealed in special "secrecy" envelope and may be mailed or dropped off in a secure box at the County Auditor's office.

Downside: The final tally may not be available on Election Day, proper (as mail-ins are allowed to be postmarked no later than Election Day itself) - but that's just a "delayed gratification" issue.

The concept of physically going to the polls is antiquated in this day and age, and if election fraud is going to take place, the current decentralized system is "ripe for the taking."

Posted by Rod Brock | 02.11.08, 18:26 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

It really boggles the mind that we are already seeing voting problems again for 2008. It does not help that the ballot contains numerous questions that have to be answered instead of being just a straightforward presidential vote. It also has been noted in the past that for the most part the electronic voting machines are a farce at best. One has to wonder at the legitimacy of ANY voting system that appears to be substandard and can allow for possible tampering with the outcome. I have already seen some complaints where a voter selected Obama and their vote automatically switched to McCain ... sound familiar?

While all this is going on the Canadian government announced a federal election which lasted for 49 days which has come and gone with NO voting problems. On voting day , I produced my ID, was given a ballot, (paper ballot with six names on it with a circle beside each name) I marked my X in the circle of choice, popped in into the ballot box ... done. It took 5 min at most.

Posted by Jim Cullen | 02.11.08, 14:22 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

This article, if accurate, is a serious comdemnation of America. How it can call itself, "LEADER of the FREE WORLD", must rate as being beyond anyones comprehension. It is a sure sign that America will be rapidly replaced as the world's most powerful nation.

Posted by Alf Morley | 02.11.08, 11:31 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Most viewed

Beach boy Bush at the Olympics

  • U.S. President George Bush watches a practice as U.S player Kerri Walsh warms up at the Chaoyang Park Beach Volleyball Ground at the Beijing 2008 Olympics in Beijing, Saturday, Aug. 9, 2008.
  • U.S. President George Bush watches as U.S. team of Misty May Treanor, left, and Kerri Walsh warm up at the Chaoyang Park Beach Volleyball Ground at the Beijing 2008 Olympics in Beijing, Saturday, Aug. 9, 2008.
  • President Bush gestures toward the back of Misty May Treanor as he visits the practice of the U.S. beach volleyball team the 2008 Summer Olympic games in Beijing, China Saturday, Aug. 9, 2008. At right is Treanor's teammate Kerri Walsh.

US President finds time for some volleyball fun

In Pictures: The Troubles

In Pictures: Northern Ireland Nightlife

Had a big night out? Click here to send us your pics

TeleToons

TeleToons: Cartoons by Stevie Lee

Click here for audio version