Sunny Belfast Hi 24 °C | Lo 12°C

I got it wrong on Bloody Sunday but I don’t fear Saville’s findings

By Eamonn McCann
Thursday, 28 January 2010

A steady increase of acrimony over Bloody Sunday is underway as publication of the report of the Saville Tribunal approaches.

It was confirmed this week that Lord Saville is confident of hitting his target of the week beginning March 22.

Twelve years in the making at a cost of £200m, there has never been anything like it — and won't be again.

The enactment of the 2005 Inquiries Act apart, dismay at the length and cost of the proceedings has not been confined to recalcitrant unionists and scions of the British elite. Derry DUP chieftain Gregory Campbell has been to the fore in maintaining that the |tribunal has been an expensive sop to nationalism, pitching |his argument in terms which make plain that Protestants who take any other view are letting the side down.

Nationalist politicians argue that the real reason Gregory harps on about the inquiry is that he doesn't put much value on the lives of Catholics killed by the |security forces. As for themselves, they aver, not always plausibly, they have always held that |you cannot put a price on truth and justice.

In fact, the main reason the inquiry has cost so much and taken so long has to do with the nature of the Bloody Sunday event — not to forget the elegant and meticulous ponderousness of the judiciary. The tribunal was tasked to look for the truth not only about Bloody Sunday as a single episode but about each individual killing and wounding, of which there were 27.

The evidence might lead to a finding of unlawful killing in one instance, of self-defence in another. The only way of determining which fell into which category was to study the evidence given at the time, question surviving eyewitnesses and summon what forensic evidence remained.

That every killing and wounding was witnessed by at least a dozen — in some cases scores — of witnesses is the prime reason oral hearings occupied 404 days and that the report will be the equivalent of 15 average-length novels.

This, compounded by the astonishing fees commanded by lawyers of varying levels of competence, in criminal and civil proceedings as well as at tribunals, helps explain the staggering cost of the exercise.

But these are not the key considerations and should not be at the heart of debate.

By far the most important factor is that when the state kills its citizens it is in the interest of all that it be called to account.

When unionist politicians say that the Protestant community has nothing to gain from the Saville exercise they imply that Protestants should regard the state as having an untrammelled right to do with them, too, what it will.

Which is somewhat |pathetic and not a little insulting in light of the disdain which the British state has shown for the Protestant people for decades. To see Bloody Sunday as an atrocity perpetrated on |the other side is to see it in a false perspective.

Gregory's most persistent riff on Bloody Sunday is that everybody already has his or her mind |made up, making this elaborate pursuit of the truth redundant and futile.

But many of us who sat through the hearings found our prior views severely challenged.

For many years countless |people believed — I was among them — that the main motive for the assault on the Bogside had been to shore up the unionist government at Stormont. At the time, Brian Faulkner's administration was under intolerable pressure from forces around Ian Paisley and William Craig over the failure of the security forces to bring the Bogside/Creggan no-go area to an end.

Five days before the assault, two backbench MPs resigned the Ulster Unionist whip rather than support a motion of confidence in Faulkner and the security policy in which he had allegedly acquiesced. It seemed no more than common sense that the paratroopers were unleashed in Derry to save Faulkner's skin.

I wrote this down in books and pamphlets and dozens of newspaper articles. But I was wrong. No convincing evidence emerged at the hearings to sustain my view.

The evidence of Robert Ramsey, private secretary to Brian Faulkner at the time, was especially |persuasive on this point and was confirmed in Army memos |and other military documents produced in evidence.

On the other hand, there was plenty of evidence that the key factors were the rage of senior Army officers at the insult to their conception of military propriety, even their “honour”, which the no-go area represented.

That, plus the fact that London politicians and civil servants at the highest level, blithely careless of the implication for the safety of citizens, gave the go-ahead to the officers concerned.

Saving Stormont had little to do with it. The interests and aspirations of the Protestant people |figured not at all.

Whether this view of the reasons for the design and launch of the operation is upheld by Lord Saville, we must wait and see. If he finds differently, I'll argue he's gotten this one wrong.

What denouncing Saville in advance, on grounds of time and cost to the exchequer, reveals is unease about what he might find.

The biggest waste of 200 million pounds I have ever witnessed in my life. You all need counselling, and your heads examined.

Posted by jomarco | 26.02.10, 16:45 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

The IRAcall themselves the provisional government of Ireland. They have a proclamation to prove it. The republicans of Derry always supported the IRA, and never the police or British Army. So, the republicans leaders were the IRA in their eyes. Let the Northern Ireland government spend 200m on an enquiry into the IRA to prove they were not a legitimate army, but terrorists who tortured their community and country for over 30 yrs. They killed their people, and were parasites on their communities. What is the difference. The catholic community are just as bigoted as the protestant community. Does the lives of Police, Army, and civilians killed by the IRA not count????Looks like a one sided arguement to me as always in the history of N.I.

Posted by jomarco | 26.02.10, 16:44 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

How did raytheon 9 get acquitted were they not caught on film,and why does no one mention two police officers ambushed and murdered in derry three or four days previous to bloody sunday which at this time had an immense bearing on what happened but they appear to be airbrushed Why ?

Posted by norman braiden | 04.02.10, 20:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

"It’s done. Finished. Over. Put it to bed. Move on. We’re all bored with it."

Get a sense of perspective, 14 people died and half of them teenagers, causing unimaginable pain to their families. I'm sorry if you are 'bored' but the Saville Inquiry wasn't supposed to be a spectacle for your amusement. If the British Government had not have white-washed the first report then this would have been over long ago and we could all have moved on.

Posted by Liam | 04.02.10, 00:32 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Chris, you are easily bored! Irish History seems to mean nothing to you! I feel sorry for you.

Posted by Maura Clarke | 03.02.10, 14:31 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I was there that day. They could have asked me for the truth for a lot less than 200,000,000.

Posted by Nedran Broc | 31.01.10, 01:24 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Good article. Eamonn McCann is easily the best writer the Belfast Telegraph has. None of the others come close.

Posted by Mel | 30.01.10, 02:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

It was an illegal march-infiltrated by the IRA.

Posted by henry | 29.01.10, 21:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

"I find it sad that there has not been an enquiry into the Kingsmill massacre of 11 Protestant workmen by the IRA , are their lives any less important , is that massacre anything else but murder.
The Shankill Fish Shop atrocity , say 11 Protestants murdered by the IRA , is that any less important."

Steve, you seem unable to differentiate between terrorists and state sanctioned Murder. I don't pay my taxes to a government so that they can send their agents to kill me!

Posted by Bren | 29.01.10, 19:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

So Saville has changed Eamonn mind from believing 13 people were shot dead for Stormont to believing they were killed because of British Army rage. Well that's £200 million well spent!!

Roll on the enquiries for Bloody Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday! What? What do you meant they're aren't going to be any?!

Posted by Steve | 29.01.10, 18:37 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details


B’Sunday happened 40 years ago.

It’s done. Finished. Over. Put it to bed. Move on. We’re all bored with it.

Posted by Chris | 29.01.10, 17:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Of course Gregory doesn't want British state terror to be shown up for what it was.

After all only Protestant/Unionist lives matter, ain't that right Gregory?

Posted by Euskal Herria | 29.01.10, 12:38 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

"not a little insulting in light of the disdain which the British state has shown for the Protestant people for decades"

Stop putting us all into one box Eamon. "Protestants" in Northern Ireland are not homogenous and implying this in your article lends support to the DUP's assertion that it speaks to the "Protestant communnity." Most people who claim to be Protestant don't even go to church. Why don't we start treating people as individulas instead of clubbing them together unfairly?



Posted by Anna | 29.01.10, 11:56 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Eamonn McCann writes a must-read column.

He is the perfect embodiment of the enlightening philosophy 'when everyone is thinking the same; no one is thinking at all'.

The depth of his perception is thought-provoking and forces the reader to think for himself.

What else can a writer do?

Posted by Derek Dean | 29.01.10, 11:55 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I think it is sad and regrettable that any innocent person had to die during the Troubles whether Protestant or Catholic .
I find it sad that there has not been an enquiry into the Kingsmill massacre of 11 Protestant workmen by the IRA , are their lives any less important , is that massacre anything else but murder.
The Shankill Fish Shop atrocity , say 11 Protestants murdered by the IRA , is that any less important.
Yes we know it was the IRA , and they admitted it ,but that does not mean that it is over , it can be forgotten.
Its not all one sided you know .

Posted by Steve | 29.01.10, 11:18 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

See 5 paras from end. I did not travail in vain!

Posted by james ramsay | 29.01.10, 10:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

NiteLife: The Roost, Granny's, Bert's

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

Balmoral Show: Pictures and Results

Balmoral Show

In Pictures: North West 200

North West 200

Old School Pics: Alex Higgins

Old School

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

The Troubles: Northern Ireland's First Minister and Deputy First Minister

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

Out & About: The Garrick

Out & About: The Garrick

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Why my kids feel Olympics are not the real thing now

I did quite well in my school exams, but the only thing for which I can confidently say I stood out like a beacon among my fellow pupils was my record-breaking 100-metres dash.
readers_editor

Think your money is legal tender? Don’t bank on it

Readers have a habit of shining spotlights on unexpected issues that throw up interesting queries. Or, on occasion, a downright can of worms.

eamon_mccann

World must open its eyes and see Israel for what it is

Why pick on Israel when there's so much injustice in the rest of the world? The answer is to be found in the specific circumstances which gave rise to the launch of the BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) campaign in July 2005.
liam_clarke

PR machine is driving Sinn Fein power push

Sinn Fein's ard fheis opens in Killarney tomorrow. Like most conferences held by successful political parties, it is a well-managed set-piece. It is a PR event and it is aimed at the voters watching on TV.
robert_mcneill

Why bringing up our kids should be child's play... or maybe it's not

Nurse, the screens! Yup, top experts have issued new warnings about kiddies watching nothing but tellies and computers, while real life flits by unnoticed outside.
Belfast Telegraph Quizzes

TeleToons

Teletoons gallery by Stevie Lee

Latest Comments