Belfast Telegraph

Saturday 20 December 2014

A ghost returns to haunt us wrapped in Union flag

Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalist protestors and PSNI officers pictured at Belfast City Hall on 22 December 2012
Loyalists block the Sandy Row area of Belfast as part of a mass protest over flags
Ulster Unionist leader Mike Nesbitt and First Minister Peter Robinson were among those holding talks about the Union flag dispute in Belfast
Loyalists protesting around the village area in south Belfast December 17 2012
Loyalists protesting, blocking traffic in Derry
Loyalists protesting, blocking traffic in Derry
Loyalists protesting, blocking traffic in Derry
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalist hold protests around the village area in south Belfast
Loyalists taking part in a protest over the restrictions of flying the Union flag protesting outside Belfast City Hall
Up to 1,000 people took part in the cross community Peace Gathering in Belfast city centre
Loyalists in Belfast have been protesting against a decision to reduce the number of days the Union flag will fly from City Hall
Protest outside the Alliance Party office in East Belfast belonging to Naomi Long, following the decision by Belfast City Council to stop flying the union flag every day. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Tuesday December 4, 2012. See PA story ULSTER Flag. Photo credit should read: Paul Faith/PA Wire
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a flag protest
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Alliance party office which was set on fire in Carrickfergus after a protest rally over the Union flag
Police in Carrick come under attack from protestors following a fire at the Alliance party office
Police in Carrick come under attack from protestors following a fire at the Alliance party office
Aftermath of riots in Carrickfergus. Photograph by Mark Winter
Aftermath of riots in Carrickfergus. Photograph by Mark Winter
Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest
Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Northern Ireland- 4th December 2012 Mandatory Credit - Photo-Jonathan Porter/Presseye. Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest.
Loyalist hold protest at Naomi Long's east Belfast Alliance office following a council vote last night which will see the Union Flag only follow certain days. Loyalist protesters pictured on the Newtownards Road during the protest
Loyalist protestors carrying Union flags clash with police outside the City Hall in Belfast
Loyalist protestors carrying Union flags clash with police outside the City Hall in Belfast
Loyalist protestors carrying Union flags clash with police outside the City Hall in Belfast
Loyalist protestors carrying Union flags clash with police outside the City Hall in Belfast
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall
Loyalist protestors pictured at Belfast City Hall

Who would have believed that, having come so far, Northern Ireland could threaten to implode so swiftly? The ghost of Christmas present has stalked the streets, wrapped in a Union flag.

The seasonal greeting of peace and goodwill to all men has a hollow ring about it this year, not least for those who have suffered so much distress and disruption to their lives in the recent flag protests.

Where will it all end, we are left to wonder on this Christmas Eve. When the pine needles have fallen off the festive tree, when the last scraps of turkey are consigned to the bin, when a New Year beckons, will the flag-draped ghost return to haunt us all? Or can it be exorcised in 2013 to everyone's satisfaction?

The Union flag Christmas of 2012 has taught everyone a lesson: never take peace, stability and reconciliation for granted. The message has not been lost on the outside world, as European and American audiences take in images of violent protests on their televisions.

Of course, the ghosts of Christmas past were much worse than this one. For all the damage done, it is nothing in comparison to the 1970s and 80s, with security gates and searches in every city, town and village and seasonal hopes for peace constantly blown away by December bombing campaigns.

Clearly, the political leaders at Stormont are struggling to find any solutions and yet any repeat of the madness of the past month could undo what good they have done to date.

Can they find an answer? Or are we destined to spend the future forever wrangling over flags and emblems and parades?

The Union flag Christmas illustrates a fundamental flaw in the governance of Northern Ireland, which can be put right. Had the rules of democracy, as defined in the Good Friday Agreement and as operated at Stormont, been applied in Belfast City Council, all that has happened might have been avoided.

Had the council vote on the flag taken account of the need for cross-community consensus on sensitive issues, most likely it would not have been passed and Alliance would not have faced such an impossibly isolated position.

Flying the flag on designated days on public buildings in Britain was the protocol adhered to in the year 2000, when legislation was approved by then-Secretary of State Peter Mandelson for Northern Ireland. If it is good enough for Stormont, it should be acceptable across Northern Ireland.

But, not surprisingly, each district council has decided to do its own thing, resulting in Union flags flying every day of the year in some places and nowhere to be seen in others. Re-opening the flags and emblems debate across this divided province hardly bears thinking about. Yet somehow, in 2013, the issue will have to be addressed once and for all, along with a resolution of the handful of contentious parades which lead to so much community unrest every summer.

Locking the leaders of the five main parties in Stormont until they come up with an answer is hardly too extreme a suggestion, given the damage done to community relations, to the economy and to our international image by their collective failure to find a resolution to date. Northern Ireland operates under two very different systems of democracy. In one, applied at Stormont, cross-community support is essential on difficult issues. In the other, in district councils, majority rule rules the roost - a recipe for sectarian point-scoring and political discord, as we have seen so vividly in Belfast.

So where do unionist and nationalist parties stand on this issue? Strangely silent, it appears, which is perhaps no surprise, given that the 26 district councils are carved up between them.

These 26 councils are being reduced to 11, essentially breaking Northern Ireland into a network of even larger Protestant/unionist, or Catholic/nationalist, dominated fiefdoms.

How will they cope in respect of the display of flags and emblems, naming of parks and erecting of memorials? How will they decide what - if anything - is flown from their new headquarters?

Will majority rule mean one side or the other's feelings will be disregarded, as is the case now? Or will the Union flag Christmas of 2012 prove a spur to finding a better consensual system of decision-making on the thorny issues of flags and emblems? Unless the spirit of the Good Friday and St Andrews agreements is better reflected in the voting procedures of the new councils, Northern Ireland will face the turmoil of Belfast all over again. Do we really want that?

Happy Christmas.

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Latest News

Latest Sport

Latest Showbiz