Sunny Belfast Hi 21 °C | Lo 11°C

Lindy McDowell: Why Caitriona lost marks over school trip row

Saturday, 23 May 2009

In common with many parents I completely, utterly understand why Caitriona Ruane would choose to take her little girl with her during a recent official trip to Cyprus.

In the great scheme of things three days out of a school career is unlikely to be a serious educational drawback. What the child will have learned from a trip to a foreign country will more than compensate.

Ms Ruane says her daughter’s school was informed in advance. And that there were “personal” and “exceptional” circumstances.

When she points out: “I as a parent, as a mother, made the decision to take my daughter with me and I stand by that |decision,” I as a parent and a mother back her totally.

However ...

Where my sympathy comes off the rails is when Caitriona hits out at this week’s Press coverage of the story.

“This is a dreadful attack on my family. It is not right that my daughter is being discussed like this,” she says .

“I paid for my daughter. She missed three days of school but I am a mother as well as a |minister and I will decide the priorities in relation to my family.

“What I am saying is stop bringing my family into political battles, she is a minor.”

In fact this was not a dreadful attack on the Education Minister’s family and she is being disingenuous in claiming that it was.

In Northern Ireland the rules imposed by the education department which she heads up, clearly state that parents should not remove their children from schools during term time.

Except in “exceptional” circumstances which are spelt out as actually extremely rigid.

That the Minister removed her child from a school (in the Republic) during term time could be taken as sending a very confusing message to all those other parents who also decide the priorities in |relation to their children. Was this a case of a government minister saying, do as I say, not as I do?

The story fell into that category. And at a time when politicians are under scrutiny as never before it was both entirely fair and responsible that the paper which broke the story, and the wider media who |followed it up, should ask that question.

So no, it wasn’t about bringing the Minister’s family into political battles. It was about asking where as the Education Minister she stood on education policy.

Actually of all the comments in the story the one that gobsmacked me the most wasn’t anything Ms Ruane said.

It was a reported comment, from Frank Bunting leader of the INTO teaching union.

He is quoted as saying: “If people are in a high pressured job and do not see their children as much as others do then I think there should be a different rule for them and if they want to take their child away for a bonding trip for three days that is not going to have a catastrophic effect on their education.”

Can this really be a trade union leader suggesting that people in “high pressured jobs” should not be subject to the same rules as the ordinary rest of us?

Another thing — define high pressured?

After all if a politician’s role is deemed to be high pressured what does that make the likes of nursing or policing? Or working nightshifts in a factory?

High pressured, when you think about it, probably applies to the job of just about any working parent in these difficult times.

Sadly Frank, the rule is that rules is rules. And they should apply equally to everyone. Not just to a chosen few.

The onus is on an education minister |(indeed any minister) to be seen to support the rules of the department of which she is head.

And when she is occasionally asked to |explain her actions in this regard, this is not a “dreadful attack“ on her family.

It is legitimate public interest.

Throughout this article Lindy refers to "rules" which she says have been "imposed" by the Department. If she had done even the most rudimentary research for her article she would know that the Department has not "imposed" any "rules", nor is it in a position to do so. What it has done is to set out "guidelines" for schools. But is is entirely a matter for individual schools to decide how they will deal with the matter of children being taken out of school during term time.

Posted by Terry | 25.05.09, 16:27 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Personally I am fully in favour of Minister Ruane taking this trip abroad. In fact, the more time she spends abroad the better it is for the children of Northern Ireland. That way she isn't making a pig's ear of her job here.

P. S. - I hope she doesn't take this as an attack on her family - she does seem to be a rather sensitive soul.

Posted by Manphibian | 25.05.09, 11:49 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Well said. I agree completely with this article. There was no attack on Ms Ruane's family - this was an attack on her hypocrisy and her ' do as I say and not as I do attitude'.

If taking a child out of school during term time and availing of the education that grammars provide is good enough for her family - and I will do as she does and not as she says!!

Posted by Concerned and Dismayed P6 parent | 25.05.09, 09:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

'' I will decide the priorities in relation to my family. '' Those parents who believe in academic selection now have a principle which can be used in courts of law. Caitriona's inadvertent axiom is now a legal precept for parental choice in the validity of academic selection and the survival of grammar schools.

Posted by George | 23.05.09, 14:11 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I totally agree with the opinion voiced about Frank Bunting. Frank should worry less about cosing up to Ms Ruane and more about the INTO's inaction and failure over dealing with teacher's pensions and the fact that he has still to make progress over helping to gain the 10% PPA time teachers in England and Wales have. Concentrate Frank!

Posted by Broke Like A Plate | 23.05.09, 14:06 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

NiteLife: The Roost, Granny's, Bert's

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

Balmoral Show: Pictures and Results

Balmoral Show

In Pictures: North West 200

North West 200

Old School Pics: Alex Higgins

Old School

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

The Troubles: Northern Ireland's First Minister and Deputy First Minister

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

Out & About: The Garrick

Out & About: The Garrick

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Why my kids feel Olympics are not the real thing now

I did quite well in my school exams, but the only thing for which I can confidently say I stood out like a beacon among my fellow pupils was my record-breaking 100-metres dash.
readers_editor

Think your money is legal tender? Don’t bank on it

Readers have a habit of shining spotlights on unexpected issues that throw up interesting queries. Or, on occasion, a downright can of worms.

eamon_mccann

World must open its eyes and see Israel for what it is

Why pick on Israel when there's so much injustice in the rest of the world? The answer is to be found in the specific circumstances which gave rise to the launch of the BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) campaign in July 2005.
liam_clarke

PR machine is driving Sinn Fein power push

Sinn Fein's ard fheis opens in Killarney tomorrow. Like most conferences held by successful political parties, it is a well-managed set-piece. It is a PR event and it is aimed at the voters watching on TV.
robert_mcneill

Why bringing up our kids should be child's play... or maybe it's not

Nurse, the screens! Yup, top experts have issued new warnings about kiddies watching nothing but tellies and computers, while real life flits by unnoticed outside.
Belfast Telegraph Quizzes

TeleToons

Teletoons gallery by Stevie Lee

Latest Comments