GET THE BELFAST TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR EVERY DAY

Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

How wartime politics enforced a ‘border’ in the Irish regiments

By Kevin Myers
Friday, 6 November 2009

This Sunday is Remembrance Sunday, when we may choose to remember the Irish dead of the two world wars, or not.

Whereas once Ireland shied in horror at any commemoration of these wars, they are now accepted as part of the Irish history of the 20th century.

So it stands to reason that the National Museum in Dublin is part of the process of historical retrieval, for a museum's job is to revisit the past, independently of political context.

Tomorrow the Collins Barracks arm of the museum is hosting an open-day to enable people to discover their own connections with the Great War, and the hundreds of thousands of Irishmen and women who served in it.

There is an exception to the programme; to commemorate the 70th anniversary of the outbreak of World World II, I will be presenting a paper on the Irish involvement in that war — or rather, a talk about the Irish losses.

Because we now know that some 7,000 Irish servicemen and women died in that war, roughly equally divided north and south, and maybe another thousand Irish civilians were killed in Luftwaffe bombings.

This is more than were killed between 1916-1923 or 1966-96. Indeed, Irish losses in World War II, including civilian casualties, probably exceed the death toll for all the domestic political violence in the entire 20th century.

This time last year, writing on the first Irish (and British) fatal casualty of the war — Pilot Officer Willie Murphy, from Mitchelstown, Co Cork, in September 1939 — I reported that the sole survivor of the raid he led, Laurence Slattery of Tipperary, had after the war lived as a recluse above a shop in his hometown of Thurles.

I was told this in good faith. It is apparently not true.

He returned to Ireland, got married and settled down. I hope he lived the rest of his life in peace.

That story is an allegory for how we get things wrong. Which is what we do, the whole time.

The truth is a mist in a darkened room full of mirrors, in which the occasional flash of light might tell us a truth, or mislead us with a mirage. Thus my research into the Irish soldiers of the war. Systematic analysis of casualty figures, which is now possible on CD Rom, has revealed that the so-called ‘Irish’ regiments of World War II were in fact, no such thing.

For contrary to widespread belief, political unionism was a clear factor in the composition of ‘other ranks’ in the three northern infantry battalions before 1939: the Royal Ulster Rifles, the Royal Inniskilling Fusiliers and the Royal Irish Fusiliers.

A study of casualties in those regiments in 1940 suggests that NO soldiers resident in what was then legally Eire had been enlisted in them. Now this could be explained by an oversupply of recruits from within an impoverished and hungry Northern Ireland, except this is not the case. For 28% of the soldiers of those northern Irish regiments were English.

A few southern-born soldiers resident in the UK at the time of enlistment were serving in the Northern regiments. But the simple truth is that if you were from and lived in southern Ireland, you were clearly not welcome as a private soldier in the three northern infantry battalions.

Yet, 281 southern-born Irish soldiers were good enough to be killed in other regiments of the British army by the end of 1940.

Matters changed after 1940, but just how they did is something I will be talking about tomorrow. Yet what is clear is that southerners thereafter were far more dispersed through the British army than they had been in World War I.

The Munster family name Power gives us a snapshot into the disparate nature of Eire service in British colours. In all, 11 Powers from Eire died in 10 British army regiments.

Captain John Joseph Power (26), from Kilmallock, Co Limerick, was killed in action in Italy with the Wiltshire regiment in 1944. RAF Sergeant James Patrick Power, an air-gunner from Tramore died in a Japanese POW camp in China, in February 1945.

One Irish Patrick Power died in France in 1940 with the Bedfordshires and another, Patrick Power, died with the North Lancashires in the Far East in 1941.

And now a tale of three John Walshes. John Patrick Walsh from Belfast was a gunner with the Glamorgan yeomanry. He was 22 when he was killed in September 1944, the son of Mary and John Walsh from Belfast.

Company Sergeant-Major John Walsh of the Highland Light Infantry, aged 36, was from south of the border. He was husband of Eileen Walsh, formerly O'Donoghue, and he was killed in action in Holland in 1944.

Sergeant John Walsh was also from Eire. He was an air dispatcher serving with the Army Service Corps and was killed at the Arnhem fiasco in September 1944.

Most of these minor insights do not form part of my talk tomorrow, which is just part of a day-long Remembrance weekend commemoration, and which is far more about the Great War than the Second.

Log on to www.museum.ie for a full outline of the day, and I hope my fellow contributors and I will see you there.

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

The two comments below are breathtaking in their ignorance.

"Too bad their countrymen helped the luftwafe find Belfast by the lights of dublin."

Completely untrue, not to mention outrageous, given that Dublin was bombed heavily in 1940 and '41, with many lives lost.

Secondly, the Irish government actively helped the Allies by interning German soldiers captured on Irish soil while repatriating any Allied personnel found, providing advanced weather reports to the Allied side and information about German naval movements and letting Irish citizens serve the Allies.

The myth that has grown up in Unionist circles that Ireland somehow helped the Germans, as opposed a country like Sweden which actually did by providing iron ore etc., is mystifying but for the fact that it is motivated by simplistic sectarian politics.

Indeed, the British even tried to sell Northern Ireland back to the Republic in 1940, offering reunification if Ireland entered the war on the Allied side.

Posted by Serge | 09.11.09, 11:28 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Too bad their countrymen helped the luftwafe find Belfast by the lights of dublin.

Posted by william | 07.11.09, 01:10 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

It is to be grateful that at last a more enlightened generation of Irish citizens is now able to recognise the major contribution made by Southern Irish soldiers for King and country in WW1 particularly. Records show that approx 9300 died in the 10th Irish and 28400 in the 16th Irish alone. Far in excess of the 7300 who you say were killed in 1916-1923. That more Irish were not enrolled in Northern Regiments in WW2 can be understood by the well documented Nazi sympathies of some members of the Dublin gov at the time. Have a good presentation

Posted by Jacko | 06.11.09, 14:09 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

In Pictures: The Troubles

Columnist Comments

robert_mcneill

Brown gets right dunking over his cookie coyness

It is, I think, correct and fair to refer to Gordon Brown as a balloon, a numptie, a phoney, a nutter...

Columnist Comments

eamon_mccann

We do not need to be told the truth. We need truth to be told

Why Bloody Sunday? There have been bigger death tolls. Fifteen Catholics in McGurk’s Bar in the New Lodge in Belfast the previous month. Eighteen Paras at Warrenpoint in 1979.

Columnist Comments

lindy_mcdowell

Why Church must confess all for sake of my abused friend

For evil to succeed it is only necessary that good men either do nothing ? or that they get the victims of evil to sign vows of silence promising never to reveal details of the terrible abuse they suffered.

Columnist Comments

sharon_owens

Little pop tart Lady Gaga fills me full of dread for our daughters

If you go on Lady Gaga’s website you can buy a T-shirt that says ‘I’m A Free Bitch’.

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Why Christine really is the One

Isn't our own Christine Bleakley turning out to be a really class act? Her Sport Relief Waterski Challenge was a kind of David Walliams/Eddie Izzard moment when the Newtownards woman moved officially into the ranks of minor national treasure.

Columnist Comments

eric_waugh

A lesson in history for Cameron: unionists always do it their way

If I refer to the imbroglio of the UUP as ‘the Hermon mess', I hope Lady Hermon will not take it amiss.

Columnist Comments

laurence_white

Marching into another summer of discontent

The Orange Order has given a qualified welcome to the work done by the DUP/Sinn Fein-packed Stormont body on how to resolve the issue of contentious parades in Northern Ireland.

Columnist Comments

ed_curran

Swashbuckling Sir Reg finally delivers a shot across the bows

No matter how much positive spin is placed on the transfer of policing and justice powers to Stormont, concerns remain. Will what has not worked in the past be any better in the future?

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Loud, aggressive and mean, Carol’s number’s really up

For years she has been paraded as the ultimate poster girl for attractive, smart, self-sufficient forty-something women, but last week we saw the real face of Carol Vorderman and boy, it ain’t pretty.

Columnist Comments

robert_fisk

Robert Fisk: Democracy doesn't seem to work when countries are occupied by Western troops

In 2005 the Iraqis walked in their tens of thousands through the thunder of suicide bombers, and voted – the Shias on the instructions of their clerics, the Sunnis sulking in a boycott – to prove Iraq was a "democracy".

Columnist Comments

mark_steel

Mark Steel: The moment you think of voting Labour, up pops the unregretful Tony Blair

There are many questions a population asks itself before a General Election, and the one that many people are asking before the one this year is, "Which of these rancid heaps of sewage will be slightly less repulsive than the other?"

Columnist Comments

the_punter

The Trick is to avoid big two

Anyone fancy 5-2 about Kauto Star for the Gold Cup?

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Cost of pay freezes and high taxes was a culture of duplicity, envy and hypocrisy

The Chancellor was right yesterday to dismiss the idea of a High Pay Commission. His phraseology was characteristically mild: he was "not persuaded" of his merits.

TeleToons

TeleToons: Cartoons by Stevie Lee

 

Click here for audio version