Belfast Telegraph

Wednesday 22 October 2014

A united Ireland will make sense on all fronts

Abolishing the border would let everyone share in a vibrant and dynamic economy, says Mitchel McLaughlin

Ed Curran, your former editor and opinion writer, posed the question recently - could the Republic actually afford unity - now or ever?

I believe that it is generally accepted that a new start is needed in Ireland if we are to change our politics, our economy and our whole society for the better. We can't do that without examining a fundamental issue - the way we govern ourselves on the island of Ireland.

At present, Ireland has two states, north and south, and three governments in Dublin, Belfast and London. We have duplication in public services and two sets of currencies, tax systems, social services, laws and regulations.

There is now widespread support across the whole political and economic spectrum for integrated economic structures for the island. All the people who share this island would benefit from the creation of a vibrant, dynamic all-Ireland economy based upon:

• A single currency

• Democratic control over Irish monetary and fiscal policies

• An equitable and progressive tax regime, including a common VAT regime, a harmonised income tax and corporation tax

• A fully integrated energy, transport and ICT infrastructure to support the growth of island-wide prosperity, based on the principles of environmental sustainability, universal access and quality service

• All-Ireland regulation of public and private sector business to ensure protection of the economic interests of the people of Ireland

• All-Ireland enterprise agencies and economic planning to build a competitive and sustainable economy.

Ed Curran bases his analysis of the cost of Irish unity on a portrayal that the North is totally dependent on a hand-out of £10bn from the British Government. That analysis is flawed because it ignores the flow of billions in tax paid by citizens in the North through a myriad of taxes.

An analysis of the expenditure by 'regions' along with a series of estimates of the revenues from the regions by Oxford Economics shines some light on the actual subvention by the British Exchequer.

The main findings demonstrate that total 'identifiable expenditure' for the North was £14.1bn in 2004/05. This is relevant data, as 'non-identifiable spending' is mainly comprised of two components - debt interest payments and defence spending, neither of which would be accrued in a united Ireland.

The 'residence-based' revenues from the North in the same period were£10.7bn, indicating a deficit of £3.4bn.

There are significant sources of potential wealth creation as well as huge untapped resources that would be available for development in a single island economy. A proactive job creation strategy in alternative energy, ICT and green technology aimed at full employment - which British economic mismanagement could never achieve here - would see tax revenues climb rapidly and welfare payments plummet. Bringing people back into work and paying taxes on their incomes and through their spending would eliminate any deficit.

Another inhibitor to economic growth is the fact that the North is not free to negotiate on its own behalf with the major trading blocs.

The Good Friday Agreement provides a peaceful, democratic mechanism for bringing about reunification. Unity is not an issue of the past. It is a live issue of the present and the direction in which we are all heading. How best and how soon to reach that goal is the question we need to address. The fact is that Irish unity makes sense.

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Latest News

Latest Sport

Latest Showbiz