Learn from others and we will enjoy racial diversity

What can we in Northern Ireland gain from Great Britain's debate about multiculturalism, asks Owen Polley

Tuesday, 22 February 2011

Race and politics are always a potentially explosive mix. When Enoch Powell delivered his Rivers of Blood speech in the 1960s, he quickly became the most polarising public figure in Britain.

No one would compare David Cameron's recent remarks about multiculturalism to Powell's incendiary rhetoric, but they ranged across similar divisive terrain.

At a security conference in Munich, the Prime Minister argued that "state multiculturalism" in Britain has failed. The speech came under instant attack from critics who said that its timing was insensitive (his engagement coincided with a rally in Luton by the English Defence League - a rabble-rousing, anti-Islamist movement).

To add to the controversy, BNP leader Nick Griffin waded in to describe Cameron's comments as a "huge leap" forward. That's exactly the type of backing which the Prime Minister could do without.

It also serves as a reminder that a hardcore of extremists is ready to exploit and pervert any debate around race, culture and integration.

Recently, the BNP registered to contest elections in Northern Ireland. In this part of the UK, we're only beginning to experience genuine racial diversity, but the party hopes to exploit any tensions which immigration might create.

Unlike Griffin, when Cameron criticises multiculturalism, he's not attacking the existence of multiracial societies within the UK. The Prime Minister objects to a tendency of governments to treat people as members of groups, defined by race, religion or ethnicity.

He argues that this approach actually prevents some communities in Britain from integrating properly and contributes to home-grown Islamic terrorism. The previous government poured more than £90m into radical Islamist organisations via a Preventing Violent Extremism initiative.

It theorised that a group which shares a lot of radical ideology with a potential terrorist is best placed to dissuade him or her from committing violent acts.

It all sounds uncomfortably familiar from a Northern Ireland perspective. Our entire political system is, after all, based on the premise of two separate communities, competing for resources, services and jobs. Segregation and replication are already the norm and we're too familiar with arguments over funding dubious groups.

When OFMDFM released the Executive's so-called Cohesion, Sharing and Integration programme, it was quickly ripped apart by campaigners for a shared future, who say it will actually further entrench division. That's disappointing, at a time when the UK government is revisiting its approach to integration.

In Northern Ireland, we're late-starters on the politics of race. That could actually be an advantage. There's an opportunity to learn from experiences elsewhere.

If we get it right, we can enjoy the cultural richness diversity brings, while also making newer arrivals feel integrated and at home.

To date, we've had few high-profile racist incidents in Northern Ireland. Only the attacks on Roma during the summer of 2009 were serious enough to command attention outside the province.

There's no indication that casual racism, or occasional outbursts of violence, are set to harden into a mood for far-right politics any time soon.

If the BNP decides to field council candidates in Northern Ireland, it's likely to get short shrift.

For the time being, we're far more preoccupied with traditional prejudices. But as society becomes more diverse, there is a risk that it will become even more segregated.

The Executive's failure to combat existing home-grown divisions hardly inspires confidence that it will know how to respond.

NiteLife: Goats Toe Bangor

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Old School Pictures: Ian Paisley

Old School Pics: Girls Aloud Nadine Coyle

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

In Pictures: The Troubles

Titanic Gallery: First class bedroom

Titanic Gallery: exclusive collection

Out & About: Pizza Night

Out & About: Pizza Night

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Whitney funeral showed the true meaning of faith

Given the fact that the Christian faith played such a large role historically in the life of Britain and Ireland in the 20th century, it's not really a mystery that those who advocate what's known as a 'secular' worldview have become so aggressive in recent decades.

robert_fisk

Revolution brings Tunisia more fear than freedom

Want to remember what Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali was like? Just walk down the Avenue Habib-Bourguiba – until a few weeks ago still cordoned off by armoured vehicles and barbed wire – and drop by your local bookshop for Z's wonderful Révolution! Des années mauves à la fuite de Carthage.

ed_curran

Do unionist politicians still cherish the link with London?

The Prime Minister David Cameron has set out his stall in support of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. His vision is all for one, one for all - for the Scots, the Welsh, the English and for us across the Irish Sea.
nuala_mckeever

You could die waiting for government to take action

If you thought the cost of living was getting ridiculous and you'd be better off dead, think again. The cost of being buried means it's getting too dear to die. Belfast City Council is putting up the price of cremation at Roselawn Cemetery by a whopping 25%!

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery

TeleToons

Teletoons gallery by Stevie Lee

Latest Comments