CLICK HERE TO GET YOUR BELFAST TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR EVERY DAY

Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

North and South, we have to remember all their sacrifices

Friday, 14 November 2008

Remembrance Sunday commemorates the dead of the Great War: but it also remembers the dead of the Second World War, which began 70 years ago next August.

Most of what follows has never been published before. Why? Because I found it.

On September 4, 1939, the day after Britain declared war, five RAF bombers attacked the German naval base at Wilhelmshaven. Four were shot down, the first flown by Pilot Officer William Murphy (23), the son of William and Katherine Murphy, of Mitchelstown, Co Cork. The sole survivor from the four doomed aircraft was, rather strangely, Laurence Slattery of Thurles, Co Tipperary. Billie Murphy was thus both the first Irish and British victim of the Second World War.

We can, if only arbitrarily, identify the last Irish death of the war: Aircraftman 2nd class Timothy O'Sullivan, aged 20, at home in Limerick in September 1945. But uncountable others later perished of their injuries, or the madness of war. Poor Slattery, for example, spent six, bitter years in a POW camp, before returning to Ireland. A broken man, he lived alone in a room above a shop in Thurles, until his death in the 1960s.

About 5,000 Irishmen died serving with the British Army in the Second World War — rather more from the South than from the North. This means that roughly 53,000 volunteers served from southern Ireland, and 52,000 from the North. With air-force, merchant marine and naval losses, independent Ireland's wartime death-toll alone might be four thousand. For those who so keenly trumpet northern unionist devotion to the allied cause, the figures are sobering. Of the 478 Irish-born British army officers killed, 345 (72%) came from the South. Four Irish brigadiers were killed: all southerners. Thirty-three Irish lieutenant-colonels were killed: only three from the North. Eight southern Irish chaplains were killed, two northern. Fifty southerners (including my uncle, after whom I was later named) died in the Royal Army Medical Corps, and 28 from the North. In the Intelligence Corps, one northern death, seven southern. Thirty-eight female southern volunteers died, 15 from the North. One northerner — a Catholic — won the Victoria Cross: as did five, southern, Irish-born Catholics.

A Dubliner, Private James Scully, won the Pioneer Corps' only George Cross, for gallantry during the Liverpool Blitz in the winter of 1941. Another Irish Catholic won the GC that evil season, though posthumously: Captain Michael Blaney from Newry, an NUI engineering graduate, whose award reflected his extraordinary courage in defusing a series of unexploded bombs in London when his death — as he knew it would be — was inevitable. And as for the mystery of motivation, why, I merely draw your attention to a 19-year-old Cork-born sailor who died on HMS Glorious in 1940; Patrick Pearse Murphy. Tragedy came not often singly. In May 1940, the war's first RAF VC went posthumously to Flight Lieutenant Donald Garland, a Dun Laoghaire Catholic. By war's end, his three brothers — Patrick, John and Desmond — had also perished in RAF service. John McFall, from Monaghan, was killed with the Ulster Rifles in April 1941.

A year later, his parents' one surviving child, Sergeant Pilot Joseph McFall, was fatally injured in action. Dying a year apart, in different services, by extraordinary coincidence, these two boys are buried in the same cemetery in Hereford.

Flying Officer Charles Bomford of Ballycommon, Tipperary, was killed during the fall of France in 1940. Four years later, his only brother Richard, was killed in action in Italy.

On April 11, 1943, Bartholomew McKeon, from a southern Catholic family, was shot down and killed in North Africa. Just a week later, his only surviving brother, William, suffered a similar fate in the North Atlantic.

Not long afterwards, Flight Lieutenant Arthur Patrick Dowse, from Ard Brugha Villas, Dalkey, stayed at the controls of his doomed Lancaster to enable his crew to bail out over France. All six survived. He did not. Eighteen months later, his only surviving brother, Dick, was shot down and killed, aged 21.

From D-Day to VE Day, eight hundred and fifty Irishmen serving in the British Army were killed in the liberation of North Western Europe. Almost half of them — 421 — were from the South. Six hundred and forty four Irishmen died in the land-battles to free Italy, slightly over half — 326 — from the 26-counties. Nearly 300 southerners died fighting in Malaya and Burma.

As yet uncounted others died with the Indian army: 60% of the officers of one Gurkha battalion — in which my neighbour (and true gentleman) Patrick Foley, had the honour to serve — were Irish.

From May 1945, newspapers in the Republic began to carry a roll of honour of Irish military personnel whose deaths had been concealed by the censors. One death notice from ‘E.G.S, a friend’, for a Royal Artillery subaltern killed in 1944, stands out.

It read: ‘Williams, in memory of a dear friend, a noble character, a loyal companion, and former student. Lieutenant Sean Williams RA (TCD) who gave his life so that I and others might live to pursue our ideals in freedom.’

Quite.

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

What a tragedy that after so many brave soldiers from both sides of the divide died fighting for a better life for all of us ,we are still scourged by hate, discrimination and maniacal religious fervour.
Today's politicians and their intrangencies show nothing but contempt for the valor of those who sacrificed their lives.

Posted by Des Cormican | 18.11.08, 05:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Is it time to sit down and write an 'inclusive' history of Ireland ?
As a child educated in a system influenced by Unionist tradition I was 'denied' a whole chunk of my history. The same could be said to be true of children on the other side of the divide (religious or border) who were taught a version of Irish history which may have been influenced, more by the needs of a newly independent Ireland than by strict attention to detailed fact.
In the same way that one part of the population has been unable to embrace the contribution of Irish men and women made in the fight against facism etc, I as a Presbyterian have not been allowed to embrace the Irish part of my heritage, including the Irish language, the survival of which owes a not insignificant debt to Protestants who championed the language ('proper Irish', not 'Long kesh Irish') in previous centuries.
Our combined heritage is so much greater than the sum of the two versions we are stuck with at the moment.

Posted by Andy | 17.11.08, 15:00 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Well written and hopefully will be noted by all citizens of Ireland, ib the Republic and Northern Ireland

Posted by Ulsterman | 14.11.08, 17:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

In addition:

Both groups of men fought for Ireland. In Ireland we need a new symbol, not the poppy or Easter Lilly… but something new that represents the Irish killed in WW1 & WW2 in the British and US forces and wars since.

We must remember the Irish killed fighting for the freedom of Ireland from 1916 - 1921.
We must remember those killed in Vietnam, Iraq and Afghanistan and other conflicts.
We must remember those killed in the Congo, the Lebanon and Liberia with the Irish army.

The poppy does not represent all these men nor does the Easter Lilly. They are infact sadly divisive symbols on this island of ours.

So why don't we create a new symbol that remembers ALL Irishmen, of different creeds, ideals and loyalties who died fighting for what they believed was right.

Bound by one commonality, they were ALL sons and daughters of Ireland.

Posted by Sean | 14.11.08, 12:22 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I am so glad this has been written and published. And today when we learn another Irish solider killed serving in the British forces makes it all the more poignant.

Irishmen from the Republic join many foreign armies including the British, US and French to pressure a military career that is not always possible in the Irish Defence Forces, due to small size of the Irish forces, and possible foreign operational opportunities open to them abroad.

The Irish in the first and second world wars joined out of a sense of adventure and knowing that the defence of their freedom was at stake. As Ireland was neutral (and arguable rightly so considering its recent independence/civil war) its young men had to choose to fight in British uniforms. And admirably so.

Unionists politicians need to realise also that these men did not and do not join up out of loyalty to the British crown. To believe so is not a true reflection.

Posted by Sean | 14.11.08, 12:11 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

In Pictures: The Troubles

Columnist Comments

mark_steel

Brown can't even stick to his own nonsense on Afghanistan

Bit by bit, as happened with Iraq, the reasons for staying in Afghanistan slide into gibberish. So Gordon Brown's reasons for the war seem to change every week.

ed_curran

Why defining identities is more than Armalites and Ulster Scots

If you think you're a unionist or a nationalist can you define what you mean?

eamon_mccann

Cannabis: it’s time to stop the lies and start a rational debate

It doesn't require a Leap of faith to support the growing calls for a radical rethink of policy on drugs and in particular on the decriminalisation of cannabis.

eric_waugh

We're stuck with the Assembly . . . and it's no laughing matter

A few evenings ago the Minister of Health at Stormont, Michael McGimpsey, was to be seen on the television news offering his audience what he termed a 'joke'.

Columnist Comments

Columnist Comments

james_lawton

Thierry Henry's confession leaves revolting taste

The Republic of Ireland is entitled to believe it has never seen anything so cynical, so far removed from the spirit of sport, as the devilish hand played by Thierry Henry to deny Giovanni Trapattoni's team a place in the World Cup finals that would have been so thoroughly deserved.

david_healy

Wenger’s way a lesson to all of us

Arsenal are scoring goals galore at the moment. Not exactly what everyone was hoping for at Sunderland ahead of our Premier League game with them tomorrow.

Columnist Comments

frances_burscough

I Iearned a tough lesson from my first digs at uni

My nephew Joe left home this week to go to university. It’s a huge step for a teenager but if anyone can carry it off with aplomb he certainly can.

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

GAA scored an own goal over SF demonstration

Just because it's Nelson McCausland, it doesn't mean he's wrong. The events surrounding that Hunger Strike anniversary rally at Galbally GAA grounds pose very disturbing questions for the organisation.

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Cost of pay freezes and high taxes was a culture of duplicity, envy and hypocrisy

The Chancellor was right yesterday to dismiss the idea of a High Pay Commission. His phraseology was characteristically mild: he was "not persuaded" of his merits.

Columnist Comments

eric_waugh

Eric Waugh: Why Gareth’s a victim of our failure to tackle drink culture

The case of Gareth Anderson, the teenage victim who has ruined his liver with booze, is agony writ large.

Columnist Comments

lindy_mcdowell

Why we’re now in a panic about the pandemic panic ...

According to the Health Minister, Andy Burnham, the Swine Flu pandemic has led to a pandemic of public panic.

TeleToons

TeleToons by Stevie Lee

 

Click here for audio version