Part of the Independent News & Media Group

Peter Robinson set the trap but the DUP has been snared

By Alan Murray
Tuesday, 9 March 2010

In spite of devising a Baldrick-type 'cunning plan' that would ensnare the Ulster Unionist Party up to its armpits, Peter Robinson today faces the possible Assembly division that he had hoped to avoid.

Without the guarantee of significant adjustments to how the Stormont Executive is run, Sir Reg Empey is seemingly committed to force the division this afternoon that will leave the DUP leader fire-fighting unrest within his own camp as the General Election looms.

Defending the destructive role of Caitriona Ruane towards the cherished grammar schools within the unionist community, and a First Minister's Office that contains Martin McGuinness rather than a constitutional democrat like Seamus Mallon, is a role Peter Robinson will hardly relish.

He charmed his party in early February with the apparent pearl of political strategy that if the Ulster Unionists didn't support the Hillsborough Castle Deal, then there would be no gig and Reg Empey and Danny Kennedy would have the blame shovelled onto them.

No more than a week ago, DUP deputy leader Nigel Dodds confirmed - or seemed to confirm - that, without the UUP's shoulder to the wheel, there would be no heavy lifting by his own party. Last Thursday, though, came a volte-face from Robinson and the announcement that the 'cunning plan' would now not be deployed at all and that the DUP would sink or swim alone through the division lobby today.

It would be costly now in credibility terms for the UUP not to cause a division vote.

At the very least, the division might flush out one or two DUP MLAs who still harbour doubts about devolving policing and justice from Westminster. The consequences for the UUP are hardly prohibitive. In fact, it is almost a 'win-win' situation.

Policing and justice powers can go through without UUP support, and Reg Empey and his MLAs are unlikely to be gravely admonished by a unionist electorate concerned about the implications of the move and unconvinced about its value (or, for that matter, David Ford as the politician to spearhead it). The SDLP will nod, or walk, it through - even though efforts by new leader Margaret Ritchie with Reg Empey to achieve a modification of the paralysing two-party veto that governs the Executive were soundly rebuffed last week.

A proposal to change the veto mechanism from a two-party censure to a much broader three-party veto was rejected by Martin McGuinness - evidence, some say, of the carve-up he and Robinson plan to continue into the future.

The Ulster Political Research Group added its reservations about the Robinson-endorsed deal, saying loyalist communities where its supporters live have seen no consultation on the Hillsborough contract.

The Orange Order, too, has clear reservations, leaving only Dawn Purvis sure to raise her hand to the ceiling to clamour for policing and justice powers to be devolved.

With Dawn attached and the certain absence of Ulster Unionist the Rev Robert Coulter, who will be collecting his MBE from the Queen at Buckingham Palace, Peter Robinson should have a comfortable, if not comforting, 36-17 majority.

American pressure has now been added to the lobby from London and Dublin and it's no surprise that a 'loaded' NIO poll has drifted from Hillsborough onto Reg Empey's shoulders.

Crucially, though, no movement has come from either Robinson, and particularly Martin McGuinness, to reform an Executive that can become paralysed for months - and, indeed, has been.

The DUP argues that it can and will stymie the introduction of an Irish Language Act, especially if Caitriona Ruane continues to attack 'Protestant' grammar schools, and now preparatory schools, within the unionist community.

Problem is, Ms Ruane, like another lady, appears not for turning and her leader is ghosting behind her, promising more ammunition for her social engineering policies.

When Sinn Fein gets policing and justice powers in the bag, presumably this afternoon, how kindly disposed will Martin need to be to Peter in the future?

"There will be smiles in Dublin, London, Brussels and Washington at unionist division and political incompetence." Well George, it seems to me like everyone is out of step except 'our Billy'. Is it an intellectual paucity among some Unionist thinkers that they cannot see devolvement of power,any power as a positive step for all communities?

Posted by Tommo | 10.03.10, 11:49 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

A great piece by Alan Murray

Posted by John | 10.03.10, 10:36 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

An excellent analysis of DUP inability to outthink, outflank and outmanoeuvre Sinn Fein as another inevitable stage towards Irish unity has been achieved. There will be smiles in Dublin, London, Brussels and Washington at unionist division and political incompetence. Regrettably the DUP negotiators do not have any intellectual or pragmatic understanding of the ascendant phoenix.

Posted by George | 09.03.10, 20:33 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

In Pictures: The Troubles

Bloody Friday 1972

Columnist Comments

robert_mcneill

Celebrity culture is all Greek (and Roman) to me

We are turning into the Romans of old. So says Ferdinand Mount, former adviser to Margaret Thatcher, but not to be dismissed as a nutter just because of that.

Columnist Comments

lindy_mcdowell

Could NHS have done more to save Hurricane?

The Lord Mayor of Belfast, Pat Convery, paying tribute to the late Alex Higgins, told reporters: “He was a controversial and colourful character, but we have to remember the good things that Alex did for this city in the international sporting arena of snooker.”

Columnist Comments

sharon_owens

Fame is that most fickle friend who finally left Alex snookered

Snooker genius Alex Higgins was found dead in his Belfast flat a few days ago. He was 61. Alex had battled throat cancer for 10 years and recent photographs showed him to have become a skeletal ghost of a man.

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Why Alex was the last of the Belfast working class heroes

Sadly , we’re in the middle of yet another period of mourning for a homegrown sporting hero. Do we as a society endure more of these than other places? It would certainly seem so.

Columnist Comments

eamon_mccann

The truth is out: Labour didn't have one single, serious ideal

There are some who sneer at Nelson McCausland for believing that God made the world in six working days back in the summer of 4004 BC.

Columnist Comments

nuala_mckeever

How my life seems to be just a replay ...

Remember when VHS machines came out and there was the joke about the Irishman who used his to record programmes he didn’t like and then play them back when he was out?

Columnist Comments

ed_curran

Stop playing name games and we can all enjoy our City of Culture

Londonderry? Derry? The Maiden City? Stroke City? The UK’s new city of culture has a unique problem. Regrettably, our citizens do not agree on what to call the place.

Columnist Comments

robert_fisk

‘Desert airports’ succumb to shifting sands of time

I am inspired this week to praise the “caravanserai” because it is where we all met in the age before steamships and aircraft.

Columnist Comments

alf_mccreary

A moment for churches to reflect on a turbulent year

This is a time when local churches are fairly empty and when the faithful may be attending services far from home.

Columnist Comments

geoff_mcgimpsey

Challenging a spandex-wearing rocker to a duel? Make sure you select pistols...

There have been a lot of good gigs in Belfast over the past few weeks. I was at Metallica recently (or a ‘reunion of Family Metallica’ as the singer insisted on calling it), and I had a great night out.

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Lindsay’s pushy parents — how Lohan you go?

If there is a better argument for keeping children light-years away from showbusiness than Lindsay Lohan, please pass it on.

Columnist Comments

laurence_white

Why MLAs must get real and put holidays on hold

Our MLAs are about to go on holiday. They won’t be long back when we will be told the extent of the public spending cuts coming our way.

Columnist Comments

mark_steel

Mark Steel: The decline and fall of England's empire

How long does it take for a nation that once had an empire to come to terms with the fact it's no longer as important as it was? Do people from Rome still go around singing "Carthage, Galls and Southern Spain doo-da, doo-dah?". This is a vital question as we ponder our latest humiliation.

 

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery

TeleToons

TeleToons: Cartoons by Stevie Lee

 

Latest Comments