GET THE BELFAST TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR EVERY DAY

Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

Talking about past without major players would be futile

A Legacy Commission without the main parties to the conflict will achieve nothing, writes Brian Rowan

Monday, 19 October 2009

Something has come through loud and clear in recent days - that the Legacy Commission, as proposed in the Eames/Bradley report, is not going to work.

It is not going to work because it cannot guarantee the participation of some of the major players in the past.

Gerry Adams has made that clear. Several loyalists have made that clear.

There was another development when one of the authors of the report, Denis Bradley, suggested that, if a Conservative Government emerges from the next election, the document could be binned.

Adams' opposition is about the role the British Government has in shaping the commission. He sees the Britain not only as a player, but the major protagonist in the conflict.

Any commission that has their fingerprints on it would be doomed to failure - that is republican thinking. Adams said recently that he would not cooperate in those circumstances.

He set out an alternative: an Independent International Truth Commission shaped by the United Nations. There are those who are asking how likely that is.

But that is where republicans have set the bar and there is a view it has been set too high, with some arguing deliberately so.

What is clear is that, if Gerry Adams will not participate in the Eames/Bradley-recommended process, then neither will other republicans whose voices and presence would be needed. And without them it is a meaningless project.

That Legacy Commission proposed by the Consultative Group on the Past would have Investigation and Information Recovery Units. But the emerging loyalist argument is you cannot have both truth recovery and investigation/arrest processes. Their argument is the war is either over, or it is not.

A former Red Hand Commando prisoner, William 'Plum' Smith, who chaired the 1994 ceasefire news conference, warned recently against "Nuremberg-style trials". So we know what loyalists don't want - but what might they be prepared to do? That is the next question.

At her party's annual conference, Progressive Unionist Party leader Dawn Purvis tried to move the debate on - asking loyalists the question, 'How do you want to be remembered?'

"Our future is inextricably linked with our past," she said. "In order to build a peaceful and stable future we must now deal with the issue of our conflicted past and so loyalism must move to the next stage in the evolution of the peace process.

"Loyalism needs to engage on this issue and there is now an opportunity for them to get their story out there, to write the agenda, to listen to and answer those who ask questions in order to meet the needs of a society crying out to move on."

The Government is now considering responses to a consultation process on the Eames/Bradley document and will have heard the recent commentary coming out of the republican and loyalist communities.

But the process on the past is not just about republicans and loyalists - it is about what governments and security forces and many others are prepared, or not prepared, to put on the table.

Storytelling will be part of any process that emerges and recently Healing Through Remembering hosted Australian Paul Costello - an internationally recognised leader in the area of narrative practice.

"Stories should have the same warning on some of them that cigarette packets have - 'Dangerous'", he said.

He was not speaking against storytelling - but warning against "promising miracles".

"Some people who haven't had a voice need to be given the chance," he said. But - "there's got to be a strategy here. Why are we doing this? What is the outcome?"

After the consultation, we now wait for a strategy.

Recent comments have raised big questions: the biggest of them is, 'What will a process without the major players achieve?'

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

In Pictures: The Troubles

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Loud, aggressive and mean, Carol’s number’s really up

For years she has been paraded as the ultimate poster girl for attractive, smart, self-sufficient forty-something women, but last week we saw the real face of Carol Vorderman and boy, it ain’t pretty.

Columnist Comments

eamon_mccann

They've got a deal! Oh no they haven't! It's panto time again

Barack Obama was bouncing with excitement in the White House on Tuesday as word came in that Stormont had accepted the devolution of policing and justice.

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Hamish McRae: Recoveries do happen, but they take time

So there is a date at last for the first of the Budgets this year, 24 March.

lindy_mcdowell

Why Bulger killers should have been locked up longer

In his statement about how he was refraining from providing further information about the case of Jon Venables, Justice Secretary Jack Straw said he had given “active thought” to releasing more details but had concluded this “would not presently be in the interests of justice”.

Columnist Comments

sharon_owens

Oh, Kerry! What did you ever see in gold-digging Mark Croft?

We all knew it would happen and now it has. Professional girl-next-door Kerry Katona has split up with her pantomime-villain husband Mark Croft.

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Why the public counts less than the Bulger killers

The Prime Minister won't do it. The Justice Secretary won't do it. The Home Secretary thinks someone should do it, but not him. The Probation Services won't do it.

Columnist Comments

eric_waugh

Grading up or dumbing down? Why it’s all a matter of degree

A cloud of dust is being raised in the education world south of the border by what they are calling the ‘grade inflation crisis'.

Columnist Comments

laurence_white

Marching into another summer of discontent

The Orange Order has given a qualified welcome to the work done by the DUP/Sinn Fein-packed Stormont body on how to resolve the issue of contentious parades in Northern Ireland.

Columnist Comments

ed_curran

Why the lack of transparency at the BBC is tarnishing its crown

The BBC has announced it is changing direction - but will it make any difference? It is important to note that the BBC is not saving £600m. The money is merely going to other core areas of broadcasting.

Columnist Comments

robert_fisk

Robert Fisk: Democracy doesn't seem to work when countries are occupied by Western troops

In 2005 the Iraqis walked in their tens of thousands through the thunder of suicide bombers, and voted – the Shias on the instructions of their clerics, the Sunnis sulking in a boycott – to prove Iraq was a "democracy".

Columnist Comments

robert_mcneill

Lord Baden-Powell must have been a Nazi piece of work

I don't know how to tell you this, but I am the owner of several books by Lord Baden-Powell. “For shame!” I hear you cry. I agree. He was a man who ought to have been poked in the eye more often by those around him. But there you are.

Columnist Comments

mark_steel

Mark Steel: The moment you think of voting Labour, up pops the unregretful Tony Blair

There are many questions a population asks itself before a General Election, and the one that many people are asking before the one this year is, "Which of these rancid heaps of sewage will be slightly less repulsive than the other?"

Columnist Comments

the_punter

The Punter: Not a done deal just yet for Dunguib

What are the bankers for Cheltenham?

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Cost of pay freezes and high taxes was a culture of duplicity, envy and hypocrisy

The Chancellor was right yesterday to dismiss the idea of a High Pay Commission. His phraseology was characteristically mild: he was "not persuaded" of his merits.

TeleToons

TeleToons: Cartoons by Stevie Lee

 

Click here for audio version