CLICK HERE TO GET YOUR BELFAST TELEGRAPH NEWSPAPER DELIVERED TO YOUR DOOR EVERY DAY

Belfast Telegraph

  • nijobfinder
  • nicarfinder
  • propertynews.com
  • Classified

Victims: will four heads be any better than one?

Victims issues have always proven difficult for government and greater accessibility alone is no panacea, Political Correspondent Noel McAdam argues

Tuesday, 29 January 2008

And so the voice of victims from the Troubles will be listened to at the heart of government "for the very first time", First Minister Ian Paisley has pledged.

He and Deputy First Minister Martin McGuinness also explained their appointment of four Victims Commissioners rather than one as being based on providing the 'personal touch'.

One commissioner, it was argued, would have had to delegate much work and rack up consultants' fees.

"To put it simply," Mr Paisley said, the quartet of Commissioners, will "be much more personally available to victims and survivors than a single Commissioner."

While they have answered many questions, not least confirming that their decision will require yet more legislation, the First Ministers - who also described the entire raft of sensitive and complex issues surrounding victims and survivors as " pivotal" to them - remained silent about others.

Will a quartet carry the same weight as a single victims champion? Will the commissioners come to develop different areas of expertise or deal mainly with one section of the victims' constituency? Precisely how will they engage with other public bodies?

The fact is that victims constitute an issue which has long been dogged by doubt, dispute and suspicion. For years the standard Northern Ireland Office view was that there was no consensus among victims' groups on how they should be dealt with.

Which in practice turned out to be an argument for doing nothing.

Old ground was re-trodden many times. There has been little other than praise for Bertha McDougal, who shifts from being an 'interim' victims commissioner along with her colleagues Brendan McAllister, Patricia MacBride and Mike Nesbitt - to "designate" status.

But her appointment two years ago overlapped with a lot of the work of former Victims Commissioner Sir Kenneth Bloomfield, completed in under a year and delivered in 1998, on vexed matters such as criminal injuries compensation levels.

And some of her tasks, the long drawn-out controversy over the need for a victims and survivors forum, for example, will now be taken up by the latest Commission.

So it is not only recently - in the high profile High Court case brought against former Secretary of State Peter Hain - that victims have proven an area of considerable controversy.

For months it has been evident to many observers outside the Office of First and Deputy First Minister that Mr Paisley and Mr McGuinness were unable to agree on a single appointment. Thus for example, while the Office was publicly denying there would be a second trawl, the two top men had already discussed the option with civil servants.

Officials, nevertheless, have still been citing the shift to four from one as evidence that Mr Paisley and Mr McGuinness have not been at loggerheads, as the latter again insisted yesterday.

Should there be a further court case from someone who argues, for example, that they would have applied had they known they would form part of a Commission rather than a solo role (and OFMDFM says it sought all necessary legal advice) more of the multi-level background to all this may emerge.

In the meantime, there must be a broad welcome for at least the possibility that four Commissioners, together representing a broad cross-section of a still divided society, can begin to get to grips at last with the real nitty-gritty. It will be no easy task.

Post a comment

Limit: 500 characters

View all comments that have been posted about this article

Comment
Your details

* Required field

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.

Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.

In Pictures: The Troubles

Columnist Comments

mark_steel

Brown can't even stick to his own nonsense on Afghanistan

Bit by bit, as happened with Iraq, the reasons for staying in Afghanistan slide into gibberish. So Gordon Brown's reasons for the war seem to change every week.

ed_curran

Why defining identities is more than Armalites and Ulster Scots

If you think you're a unionist or a nationalist can you define what you mean?

eamon_mccann

Cannabis: it’s time to stop the lies and start a rational debate

It doesn't require a Leap of faith to support the growing calls for a radical rethink of policy on drugs and in particular on the decriminalisation of cannabis.

eric_waugh

We're stuck with the Assembly . . . and it's no laughing matter

A few evenings ago the Minister of Health at Stormont, Michael McGimpsey, was to be seen on the television news offering his audience what he termed a 'joke'.

Columnist Comments

Columnist Comments

james_lawton

Thierry Henry's confession leaves revolting taste

The Republic of Ireland is entitled to believe it has never seen anything so cynical, so far removed from the spirit of sport, as the devilish hand played by Thierry Henry to deny Giovanni Trapattoni's team a place in the World Cup finals that would have been so thoroughly deserved.

david_healy

Wenger’s way a lesson to all of us

Arsenal are scoring goals galore at the moment. Not exactly what everyone was hoping for at Sunderland ahead of our Premier League game with them tomorrow.

Columnist Comments

frances_burscough

I Iearned a tough lesson from my first digs at uni

My nephew Joe left home this week to go to university. It’s a huge step for a teenager but if anyone can carry it off with aplomb he certainly can.

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

GAA scored an own goal over SF demonstration

Just because it's Nelson McCausland, it doesn't mean he's wrong. The events surrounding that Hunger Strike anniversary rally at Galbally GAA grounds pose very disturbing questions for the organisation.

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Cost of pay freezes and high taxes was a culture of duplicity, envy and hypocrisy

The Chancellor was right yesterday to dismiss the idea of a High Pay Commission. His phraseology was characteristically mild: he was "not persuaded" of his merits.

Columnist Comments

eric_waugh

Eric Waugh: Why Gareth’s a victim of our failure to tackle drink culture

The case of Gareth Anderson, the teenage victim who has ruined his liver with booze, is agony writ large.

Columnist Comments

lindy_mcdowell

Why we’re now in a panic about the pandemic panic ...

According to the Health Minister, Andy Burnham, the Swine Flu pandemic has led to a pandemic of public panic.

TeleToons

TeleToons by Stevie Lee

 

Click here for audio version