Sunny Belfast Hi 24 °C | Lo 11°C

Editor's Viewpoint: Church sends out wrong message

Monday, 28 December 2009

The fall-out continues from the Murphy Report into clerical child-sex abuse in the Archdiocese of Dublin and two more Catholic bishops have offered their resignations.

Bishop Eamonn Walsh and Bishop Raymond Field dramatically announced their decisions on Christmas Eve, after the earlier resignations of Bishop Donal Murray, which has been accepted, and Bishop James Moriarty, whose resignation is expected to be accepted next month.

Four of the five bishops named in the Murphy Report have offered their resignations, but the fifth cleric — Bishop Martin Drennan of Galway — has not yet indicated his attention of doing so.

There are suggestions from a Galway spokesman that he believes he has done nothing wrong, and that his situation is different to that of the other bishops.

Bishop Drennan, who was an auxiliary bishop in Dublin from 1997 to 2005, may feel strongly that he has done nothing wrong, but many people will agree with Marie Collins, a victim of clerical sex abuse in Dublin, who claims that he is sending out the wrong message.

It is difficult to quarrel with her conclusion that Bishop Drennan is not doing the church or himself any favours by staying on. The whole point about the resignations is the fact that they signal the fresh start that is required by the Catholic Church in its long haul to regain public credibility.

This seems to have escaped the Bishop of Derry, Seamus Hegarty, who has said he was “not sure” if more resignations would contribute “in any great way towards healing”.

This is not the attitude which will inspire public confidence that the Church is serious about closure, about healing and about moving forward.

Pope Benedict XVI should have fired the lot if "the whole point about the resignations is the fact that they signal the fresh start that is required by the Catholic Church in its long haul to regain public credibility."

I wonder, are there still cardinals in Rome saying this is an "American problem?"

Sister Maureen Paul Turlish
Victims' Advocate
New Castle, Delaware, USA

Posted by SMPTURLISH | 29.12.09, 05:54 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Bishop Drennan's resignation at this point would do little or nothing to regain public credibility nor provide any healing.

In the past suffering has been increased by injustice against individual persons to protect the church institutions. The Murphy report clearly shows that for victims of clerical child abuse the injustice of ignorance and cover up made the suffering worse.

Rather than providing closure or healing, the injustice of delegating guilt and punishment to Bishop Drennan will be an indication that absolutely nothing has changed.

Posted by Robert Fuller | 28.12.09, 09:02 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

NiteLife: The Roost, Granny's, Bert's

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

Balmoral Show: Pictures and Results

Balmoral Show

In Pictures: North West 200

North West 200

Old School Pics: Alex Higgins

Old School

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

The Troubles: Northern Ireland's First Minister and Deputy First Minister

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Gallery: Awesome images of Titanic

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

Out & About: The Garrick

Out & About: The Garrick

Columnist Comments

jane_graham

Why my kids feel Olympics are not the real thing now

I did quite well in my school exams, but the only thing for which I can confidently say I stood out like a beacon among my fellow pupils was my record-breaking 100-metres dash.
readers_editor

Think your money is legal tender? Don’t bank on it

Readers have a habit of shining spotlights on unexpected issues that throw up interesting queries. Or, on occasion, a downright can of worms.

eamon_mccann

World must open its eyes and see Israel for what it is

Why pick on Israel when there's so much injustice in the rest of the world? The answer is to be found in the specific circumstances which gave rise to the launch of the BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) campaign in July 2005.
liam_clarke

PR machine is driving Sinn Fein power push

Sinn Fein's ard fheis opens in Killarney tomorrow. Like most conferences held by successful political parties, it is a well-managed set-piece. It is a PR event and it is aimed at the voters watching on TV.
robert_mcneill

Why bringing up our kids should be child's play... or maybe it's not

Nurse, the screens! Yup, top experts have issued new warnings about kiddies watching nothing but tellies and computers, while real life flits by unnoticed outside.
Belfast Telegraph Quizzes

TeleToons

Teletoons gallery by Stevie Lee

Latest Comments