Why we must not forget Iris's intolerance of others

Sympathy for Iris Robinson's depression shouldn't mask the more extreme aspects of her career, argues Owen Polley

Thursday, 31 December 2009

Now that Iris Robinson has announced her intention to quit public life there could be a tendency to reassess her contribution in a positive light. It is a temptation best resisted.

Even by the DUP's standards, Mrs Robinson's politics comprise an unpleasant concoction of bigotries, seasoned with a predictable dash of ethno-religious fanaticism.

This unpalatable dish is served up with a sizeable side-dollop of spite, epitomised by Iris's triumphant nine-finger salute which taunted Tory MPs after DUP votes had secured a Government victory on 42-day detention, or by her serial "unparliamentary" harassment of the Health Minister, Ulster Unionist Michael McGimpsey, for which she attracted official censure.

It is possible, of course, to elicit human sympathy for Robinson in light of the mental illness which has forced her to step back from her duties. Perhaps the condition might even permit a kinder interpretation of the extremity of some of her outbursts.

But the sum total of hatred and intolerance encompassed by Northern Ireland's politics will be diminished by Iris Robinson's retirement and that is not a result to lament.

She is one of a small number of DUP politicians, Sammy Wilson - the climate sceptic who served as Northern Ireland's environment minister - is another, whose reactionary opinions have been scrutinised with horror by the national media. In Robinson's case, her dehumanising attitude to homosexuality attracted widespread opprobrium and the gay rights association Stonewall named the MP its Bigot of the Year for 2008.

Informed by a fundamentalist interpretation of Christianity, the Strangford politician's arguments on the gay issue were a rather confused mishmash.

She claimed homosexuality to be an "abomination" and compared it to child abuse, stating that there "can be no viler act", yet on the BBC's Nolan Show she suggested that gay people are mentally ill, recommending a psychiatrist with a record of "turning" homosexuals.

Setting aside the unscientific nature of this proposition, surely experience of a mental illness would have cautioned Robinson against describing its sufferers as "vile" or claiming that they made her "sick"? Her language revealed a startling lack of empathy for fellow human beings.

Robinson's intemperance was not reserved for those who offended her religious sensibilities. As a health spokesperson at Stormont she clashed repeatedly with Michael McGimpsey and seemed unable to restrain her temper.

During 2007 the Speaker - and DUP MLA - Willie Hay banned Robinson from the Assembly for a day after she lambasted McGimpsey in an "unparliamentary" outburst.

Earlier this year, in another disproportionate attack, she called on the Health Minister to resign after he revealed that adequate funds were not available to send children suffering from epilepsy to the United States for treatment.

As an MLA, health spokesperson, councillor and MP, Iris Robinson certainly undertook an unforgiving workload.

However, in spite of a patchy attendance record at the House of Commons, Iris attracted disapproving headlines for Westminster expense claims, submitted alongside her First Minister husband. They managed to munch through £30,525 of food over a period of four years, which they subsequently claimed from the taxpayer.

Iris Robinson deserves support as she attempts to recover from a debilitating condition. Most people in Northern Ireland will be all too aware of the damage which depression, and other mental illnesses, can inflict upon friends and family.

We can, however, extend the Strangford MP sympathy and good wishes without applauding an erratic and unconstructive political career, occasionally characterised by a vicious and vindictive use of language.

The Lord works in mysterious ways....there is a certain irony in that which has befallen Ms Robinson considering the unchristian and inhuman attitude she has shown for some of her fellow humans...

Posted by Noble | 31.12.09, 18:48 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Alan Day: By suggesting those homosexuals who wanted to go straight needed the help of a psychiatrist, implies that homosexuality is indeed a mental illness.

Posted by Jim | 31.12.09, 16:47 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I think your writer is slightly misinformed as seems to be the case in most media stories on Iris`s comments on homosexuality. She tempered her comments quite clearly with comments such as she `hated the sin and loved the sinner` and in reference to seeking a psychiatrist he comments were quite specific and were NOT in regards to all homosexuals. she actually stated that she could recommend a psychiatrist with experience in the matter for those who WANTED to turn straight...not quite the same as treating all homosexuals as mentally ill and in need of psychiatric help.
Nor do I believe she promoted hatred towards anyone - she simply believes that the place for sexual relations is between a man and woman within marriage - not outside of marriage.

Posted by Alan Day | 31.12.09, 12:24 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

NiteLife: Goats Toe Bangor

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

In Pictures: Lingerie Super Bowl 2012

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Women: Can you flaunt too much?

Old School Pictures: Ian Paisley

Old School Pics: Girls Aloud Nadine Coyle

To launch gallery click image or select school below

Methodist College, Campbell College, Grosvenor,
Bangor Grammar, Dunlambert, St Augustine's,
St Dominic's, Royal Academy, Ballymena Academy

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Teletoons by Stevie Lee

Follow us on Twitter

In Pictures: The Troubles

Titanic Gallery: First class bedroom

Titanic Gallery: exclusive collection

Out & About: Pizza Night

Out & About: Pizza Night

Columnist Comments

gail_walker

Whitney funeral showed the true meaning of faith

Given the fact that the Christian faith played such a large role historically in the life of Britain and Ireland in the 20th century, it's not really a mystery that those who advocate what's known as a 'secular' worldview have become so aggressive in recent decades.

robert_fisk

Revolution brings Tunisia more fear than freedom

Want to remember what Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali was like? Just walk down the Avenue Habib-Bourguiba – until a few weeks ago still cordoned off by armoured vehicles and barbed wire – and drop by your local bookshop for Z's wonderful Révolution! Des années mauves à la fuite de Carthage.

ed_curran

Do unionist politicians still cherish the link with London?

The Prime Minister David Cameron has set out his stall in support of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. His vision is all for one, one for all - for the Scots, the Welsh, the English and for us across the Irish Sea.
nuala_mckeever

You could die waiting for government to take action

If you thought the cost of living was getting ridiculous and you'd be better off dead, think again. The cost of being buried means it's getting too dear to die. Belfast City Council is putting up the price of cremation at Roselawn Cemetery by a whopping 25%!

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery

TeleToons

Teletoons gallery by Stevie Lee

Latest Comments