Belfast Telegraph

Friday 19 December 2014

Six Nations: Time to rewrite rules after ‘try’ farce

CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Ireland captain Brian O'Driscoll appeals to Referee Jonathan Kaplan of South Africa after Mike Phillips of Wales scores a try in the corner during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. Ireland believe that the wrong ball was used at a lineout directly leading to a try being scored by Mike Phillips of Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
Ireland captain Brian O'Driscoll makes his way off the field at the final whistle during the RBS 6 Nations Match at the Millennium Stadium, Cardiff. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Saturday March 12, 2011. See PA Story RUGBYU Wales. Photo credit should read: David Davies/PA Wire. RESTRICTIONS: Use subject to restrictions. Editorial use only. No commercial use. No book use without prior permission. Call +44 (0)1158 447447 for further information.
Wales's Jonathan Davies is tackled by Ireland's Brian O'Driscoll during the RBS 6 Nations Match at the Millennium Stadium, Cardiff. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Saturday March 12, 2011. See PA Story RUGBYU Wales. Photo credit should read: David Jones/PA Wire. RESTRICTIONS: Use subject to restrictions. Editorial use only. No commercial use. No book use without prior permission. Call +44 (0)1158 447447 for further information.
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Brian O'Driscoll of Ireland dives over to score the opening try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
Mike Phillips
Ireland's Keith Earls is held by Wales' Bradley Davies and James Hook during the RBS 6 Nations Match at the Millennium Stadium, Cardiff. PRESS ASSOCIATION Photo. Picture date: Saturday March 12, 2011. See PA Story RUGBYU Wales. Photo credit should read: David Jones/PA Wire. RESTRICTIONS: Use subject to restrictions. Editorial use only. No commercial use. No book use without prior permission. Call +44 (0)1158 447447 for further information.
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Wales players celebrate their team's victory as Referee Jonathan Kaplan of South Africa blows the final whistle during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Wales players Paul James (R) and Jamie Roberts celebrates on the final whistle after the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12th, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Try scorer Mike Phillips of Wales celebrates on the final whistle after the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12th, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Brian O'Driscoll of Ireland dives over to score the opening try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: James Hook of Wales lines up a conversion kick during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: James Hook of Wales kicks a conversion during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Try scorer Mike Phillips of Wales celebrates on the final whistle after the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12th, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales hands off Tommy Bowe of Ireland to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales hands off Tommy Bowe of Ireland to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales dives over the line to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales is wrapped up by Donncha O'Callaghan and Jamie Heaslip of Ireland uring the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales hands off Tommy Bowe of Ireland to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales dives past the challenge from Tommy Bowe of Ireland to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Mike Phillips of Wales dives past the challenge from Tommy Bowe of Ireland to score a try during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
CARDIFF, WALES - MARCH 12: Gordon D'Arcy of Ireland is stopped by James Hook (L) and Jamie Roberts (R) of Wales during the RBS Six Nations Championship match between Wales and Ireland at the Millennium Stadium on March 12, 2011 in Cardiff, Wales. (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)

Two men made serious blunders at Cardiff on Saturday that directly influenced the outcome of this match. But neither of them was the referee.

One was Irish fly half Jonathan Sexton, an undistinguished second-half substitute, and the other was Scottish assistant referee Peter Allen. Between them, they brought chaos to an international match.

Sexton erred by kicking the ball out on the full after 49 minutes. Then Allen made the crass error of losing concentration, failing to follow the flight of the ball so that he would have seen the same ball was clearly not used for the quick throw-in for Mike Phillips’ try that proved the crucial difference in the match.

Allen later personally apologised to Irish coach Declan Kidney for his error, but by then it was far too late.

But the real culprits of an incident that made international rugby union a laughing stock were those who wrote the rules. For one official must have seen the whole incident unfold, must have known instantly a gross miscarriage of justice was being enacted and yet could say absolutely nothing about it.

That person was the Television Match Official (TMO) and furthermore, he was wired up to communicate with South African referee Jonathan Kaplan. So why on earth didn’t he say something and stop such a nonsensical situation ensuing?

The answer is, that sacred cow ‘rugby protocol.’ The TMO is not allowed to interfere in such a situation, not allowed to say clearly to the referee ‘NO TRY, because it was not the same ball used.’

Had he been doing his job properly, as I am sure he was, he would have seen the lunacy unfolding. Yet officials in Cardiff on Saturday night told me that had the TMO interfered, he would have been lambasted by his bosses and caused a diplomatic storm.

So he said nothing and a try that never was, was allowed to stand. Bewildered? Welcome to the strange world of international rugby.

In the eyes of those who make the rules, it is far more important that an official follows to the letter the detail of his job description and does not step beyond those parameters. The fact that he could have saved the game from farce was, in the eyes of the authorities, far less important than the dreaded scenario in which he would have disregarded protocol.

You see, nothing is more important in rugby than that every official does exactly as they are told, they follow their brief to the letter and never overstep the boundaries of their pre-assigned task.

How daft is that? Well, the desire to arrive at the correct decision was sacrificed on the altar of their own petty rules of engagement.

It HAS to be simple common sense that if a TMO sees an alarming, totally wrong decision such as this one being made (and by the way, don’t blame Jonathan Kaplan...he carefully asked his assistant if it was the same ball that had been kicked out, and the guy erroneously said ‘Yes’) he should be allowed to draw the referee’s attention to it.

In life, you can’t be half pregnant and rugby, like Fifa in professional soccer, has to learn that you can’t half embrace technology, yet ignore it when it is most needed.

What happened in Cardiff was a gross miscarriage of justice. But it is the lawmakers who should carry the can. Most importantly, their rules should be re-written in the light of this nonsense.

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Nightlife galleries

More

Latest Sport News

Stats Centre