Dunphy: Roy Keane is an a***hole for blaming players after Ireland's World Cup exit
Broadcaster lays into former captain
Tuesday, 24 November 2009
Eamon Dunphy has branded Roy Keane an "a***hole" for blaming Shay Given and Paul McShane for Ireland's World Cup exit in Paris.
And Dunphy, who penned Keane's controversial autobiography in 2003, claimed the former Irish captain and Manchester United hero was still "dining out" on the infamous Saipan row, which saw Keane quitting the 2002 World Cup in South Korea and Japan before the tournament kicked off.
Dunphy was attending a party in Residence members club on Saturday night -- and was trying to put the French defeat and Thierry Henry's 'Hand of Gaul' antics behind them.
The broadcaster was buying rounds of drinks for bemused revellers, and also performed a string of songs on the third floor of the swish venue.
But he didn't hold back when asked for his views on Roy Keane's comments on the whole fiasco where he claimed players Shay Given and Paul McShane were really to blame.
"Roy Keane is an a***hole. He doesn't know what he's talking about. It's easy for him to say that when he's not part of the Irish team any more," he said.
He went on to say how the Ipswich Town manager is "still dining out" on the whole Saipan episode and needs to move on.
Dunphy made his comments less than two days after Roy Keane berated the FAI, saying that while Irish manager Giovanni Trapattoni and the Irish fans deserved more, the organisation didn't.
He singled out FAI boss John Delaney for criticism and declared he would never take "notice of that man".
And instead of criticising Thierry Henry for his handball, Keane attempted to shift the focus onto McShane and Given for letting the ball bounce in the area.
"I'd be more annoyed with my defenders and my goalkeeper than Thierry Henry," he said. "How can you leave a ball to bounce in the six-yard box? How can you let Thierry Henry get goalside of you? If the ball bounces into the six-yard box, I'd be saying, 'Where the hell is my goalkeeper?'
"If that was my team I'd go into the dressing room and I wouldn't even mention the handball. I'd just say, 'Why didn't someone put their head on it? Where's my goalkeeper?' That's what I'd be asking."
While critical of Keane's comments, Dunphy appeared prepared to put the World Cup heartbreak behind him.
Clearly on a lads' night out, Dunphy had been to dinner in Dublin earlier in the night before popping into the Stokes Brothers' upmarket club.
After having a drink in the courtyard area, he decided it was time to take centre stage on the third floor where a pianist was performing for members.
He sang a string of songs in the packed room, including The Rose and My Way before deciding to call it a night.
Other familiar faces in the venue and enjoying his performance included top beauty Roz Lipsett, who was there with her good pal Robbie Wootton.
Source: Herald
Post a comment
Limit: 500 characters
View all comments that have been posted about this article
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.
Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.











Alright Colin change the record now there's a nice wee las as for Eamon Dunphy I couldn't agree more with you say it how it is.
Posted by sean from co down Ireland | 24.11.09, 19:19 GMT
offside/onside....who cares....Henry still handled the ball and that under fifa rules is a foul..who wants to argue with that?
Posted by dickieboy | 24.11.09, 16:08 GMT
Actually GMT go watch the video again. The player offside was not Henry, and that player was not part of the play. Henry made his run around McShane and another player after the ball was kicked.
Ulyesses - your sarcasm was duly noted (even without you stating it). However, that doesn't change the fact that the defence failed in their duties. It doesn't excuse Henry from his actions either.
Posted by colin | 24.11.09, 13:16 GMT
Lets face it Ireland needed 2 goals going into the game to get to the world cup they missed there chance blame Henry all you want it was their own poor finishing that was to blame!.
Posted by Philip | 24.11.09, 13:03 GMT
Yeah, Colin. McShane could have saved Henry all that embarrassment.
Poor Henry. People might think he handled the ball deliberately or something.
If you don't notice the sarcasm then that is something else you have neglected to observe.
As for Roy Keane, who cares what he has to say about the Ireland team. He made his position on the national team clear when he walked in 2002.
I'm not a big fan of Eamon Dunphy. In fact, I think he is one of the worst football pundits around. He's right on the money here, though.
Posted by Ulysses32 | 24.11.09, 12:41 GMT
Takes one to know one.
Posted by M McCarthy | 24.11.09, 12:38 GMT
It's not often that I agree with Dunphy but he's right on this occasion. Keane's comments were dripping with personal bitterness. His words were petty and uncalled for. And how someone who walked out on his country can criticise a great servant like Shay Given is staggering.
Posted by SW | 24.11.09, 12:07 GMT
Colin - wasn't Henry offside? Wasn't it also handled before it got to Henry? Watch the slow motion reply again. Don't think you can blame the Irish players.
Posted by Henry Five Hands | 24.11.09, 11:41 GMT
You call Keane whatever you want, fact is that his question is not only valid but bang on the money. McShane does his job properly and doesn't let Henry goalside then there is no handball.
Posted by colin | 24.11.09, 10:31 GMT