League needed Cork’s demise
Tuesday, 28 July 2009
The darkest day for the League of Ireland?
Perhaps, but it's possible that out of the shadows, a chink of light may emerge from the sorry demise of Cork City.
Certainly, the impending loss of a flagship club is a devastating blow for those bidding to promote the league. On the week that the FAI bring Giovanni Trapattoni to Munster in a visit trumpeted as evidence of the game spreading outside Dublin, the reality is that a situation is imminent where the province will be without a senior top-flight football club. How depressing is that.
Yet, amid the doom and gloom, the feeling persists that if the league was to learn anything from its perpetual monetary crises, a big gun needed to fall.
Not be relegated, or deducted points, but properly punished for indiscretions.
When Kilkenny City dropped out of the league due to a reported ?50,000 debt, the shock value was minimal. Similarly, the withdrawal of Cobh Ramblers was greeted with a degree of indifference. And Dublin City? For all bar the committed few, the memory of that experiment has long since faded.
In the case of those casualties, the upper echelons of the game were able to privately dismiss the significance in terms of the bigger picture, citing the minimal stature of the clubs in question.
But the winding up of Cork City? That's a whole new ball game. We're talking about one of, if not the best, supported team in the league. This is the club who have delivered some of the finest League of Ireland moments of recent times.
Think of the league decider against Derry in 2005 in front of 10,000 people at Turner's Cross, the crucial role in the development of Kevin Doyle, Shane Long, Roy O'Donovan and Dave Mooney, the European eliminations of Apollon Limassol, Nijmegen and Malmo. On the face of it, they should have been the template. Until the emergence of Tallaght this year, Turner's Cross arguably provided the best match-day experience; when the crowds turned up, and the newly improved Shed End was packed, it was a terrific venue to visit by the league's modest standards. There was a fair sprinkling of local talent, guys like Colin Healy and Joe Gamble who were happy to return home and enjoy their football there.
City will somehow fight to survive but the draw for the 2009 Setanta Sports Cup will take place today with the future of the holders now hanging in the balance.
Post a comment
Limit: 500 characters
View all comments that have been posted about this article
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP address logged and may be used to prevent further submissions. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by BelfastTelegraph.co.uk's Terms of Use.
Posts submitted in UPPERCASE letters will be rejected.
Also in this section
- Oval must be a fortress again, warns Glentoran boss
- Cliftonville won’t blow title race this time, insists Scannell
- Thompson and Allen hit it off for Linfield








.
Yes but Tony, Eircom League clubs tried to improve the standard by living beyond their means, taking cash from boys riding the Celtic Tiger and when that hit the skids look what's happened, almost every club is perilously close to going under. The players are paid far too much to play in a league that isn't a great deal better than up here and I will say that before long they will go back to being a part time set up like ours and then those 'poxy Irish league clubs' will go back to having the superior league like they used to.
Posted by Con Brook | 30.07.09, 19:16 GMT
It is inconceivable that Cork will be without a soccer club for any length of time. I am old enough to remember both Cork Celtic and Cork Hibernians (I can't recall which of them George Best played for), both disappeared but the new Cork City appeared.
This great citadel of Irish sport, Gaelic Football, Hurling, RugbyUnion and soccer will not go under.
As for those fans of poxy Irish league clubs who mock, just remember that Cork and other Eircom League clubs tried to improve the standard with full time professional football and didn't need to be constantly bailed out by the IFA (as in Linfield's case). Remember also Omagh Town
Posted by Tony | 30.07.09, 12:50 GMT
Will you give us a break Roo. National issues are regularly reported on this site. Especially considering Its a cross border competition. Should be a cross border league, only way both leagues can hope to be semi professional. Works perfectly for the AIL in Rugby...
Its a shame this club are gonna fold, Corkonians are a very proud breed. They will be replaced no doubt by some soulless team.
Posted by Éamonn | 28.07.09, 16:47 GMT
Good, no long trip to Cork for a Setanta Cup Final then !
Posted by markgfc | 28.07.09, 14:00 GMT
Read the last paragraph Roo, Setanta Cup draw. That's a cross-border competition. Anyone interested in local football here would be interested in this story. Belfast Telegraph local AND national...
Posted by Ryan | 28.07.09, 13:52 GMT
Things just go from bad to worse for bigoted Tony
Whats your comment on this situation ?
Posted by Devastated | 28.07.09, 12:43 GMT
they do not play in the Irish Premier or Championship leagues.
Why does this matter to Northern Ireland?
Posted by Roo | 28.07.09, 11:33 GMT