Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

City return to top of Premier League standings after Manchester derby draw

Published 25/10/2015

The Manchester derby ended in a goalless draw at Old Trafford
The Manchester derby ended in a goalless draw at Old Trafford

Manchester City moved to the top of the Barclays Premier League despite a dull goalless draw in the Manchester derby at Old Trafford.

United and City had the chance to make a real statement about their title chances by registering a big win, but neither was up to the challenge and the two teams played out just the third goalless draw between them in Premier League history.

Wilfried Bony was unable to fill the considerable void left by Sergio Aguero's absence while Yaya Toure had a day to forget playing in the number 10 role where the injured David Silva usually causes so much damage.

United fared no better. It was only in the last 10 minutes that they started to turn the screw on their rivals.

Wayne Rooney failed to mark his first match as a thirtysomething with a goal. The United captain, who needed his head stapling together after a clash of heads with Vincent Kompany, was anonymous throughout.

Jesse Lingard rattled the bar and Joe Hart saved from Chris Smalling at the death, but otherwise the hosts did not trouble the City goalkeeper.

A wall of noise hit the players as they emerged from the tunnel and both sets of fans traded insults from opposite ends of the packed stadium.

The atmosphere soon dampened down, however, as a dull first half ensued.

Rooney did his best to ignite proceedings, hurtling at the away defence. Toure was lucky to escape a booking after taking down the United skipper near the halfway line.

Juan Mata appealed for a penalty after the ball brushed Fernandinho's arm, but Mark Clattenburg waved play on.

The Brazilian entered the book for a clumsy challenge on Anthony Martial, who was United's only threat in the opening half.

The Frenchman won a free-kick after bamboozling Bacary Sagna, but United wasted it.

While Antonio Valencia was down having treatment for a knock, Rooney sprinted to the touchline with blood gushing from the top of his head following a clash with Kompany. United's medical staff stapled the wound together so he could carry on.

Toure wasted two half-decent chances before the break, but otherwise City offered little.

Marcos Rojo was doing an excellent job keeping Kevin De Bruyne quiet and Raheem Sterling was not in the game.

Sterling paid the price for his poor showing. Jesus Navas came on for the winger just after the break.

Lingard and Marouane Fellaini came on for United while City substituted a disappointed Toure for Martin Demichelis.

Nothing changed on the pitch, however. Neither team looked like breaking the deadlock.

There was a moment of panic in the away defence when Mata broke through, but Hart rushed off his line to deny the Spaniard.

Lingard thought he had won the game with his first United goal five minutes from time. Martial took the ball off Navas and chipped a delightful ball into the box. The Warrington winger lifted the ball over Hart, but the ball struck the bar and bounced out to safety.

The England goalkeeper then denied Smalling with a fine save down to his left with two minutes to go.


"We wanted this victory so bad! Unfortunately, we couldn't reward ourselves after a great second half. #mufc" - Manchester United midfielder Bastian Schweinsteiger ( Basti Schweinsteiger ‏@BSchweinsteiger) expresses his frustration after the 0-0 draw with derby rivals Manchester City.



David de Gea: 6

Antonio Valencia: 6

Phil Jones: 6

Chris Smalling: 7

Marcos Rojo: 8

Bastian Schweinsteiger: 6

Morgan Schneiderlin: 7

Juan Mata: 6

Ander Herrera: 6

Anthony Martial: 8

Wayne Rooney: 4


Jesse Lingard: 6

Marouane Fellaini: 6

Matteo Darmian: 6


Joe Hart: 7

Bacary Sagna: 6

Nicolas Otamendi: 7

Vincent Kompany: 7

Aleksandar Kolarov: 6

Fernando: 6

Fernandinho: 7

Kevin De Bruyne: 5

Yaya Toure: 5

Raheem Sterling: 5

Wilfried Bony: 6


Jesus Navas: 5

Martin Demichelis: 6

Kelechi Iheanacho: 5


Anthony Martial. Much quieter in the second half than the first but looked the greatest attacking threat on either side. Questions will still be asked of whether he might be more effective playing centrally but he did a good job on the left and almost set up a winner for Lingard.


Joe Hart's superb late save from Chris Smalling ensured City claimed an important point. The City goalkeeper had a quiet afternoon but stayed alert throughout and produced the magic when he needed to.


Louis van Gaal and Manuel Pellegrini saw their two sides largely cancel each other out. City seemed to have more quality but United dealt with them well and finished the stronger. At the end of the day, both managers may be satisfied with a point.


After all the hype and excitement, this was a game that simply did not live up to its billing. As a result, the atmosphere was so flat at times that all that could be heard was the drone of a plane circling overhead.


Manchester City v Crystal Palace (Capital One Cup fourth round, Wednesday October 28).

Manchester United v Middlesbrough (Capital One Cup fourth round, Wednesday October 28).

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph