Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport GAA

GAA: Down v Armagh - How the players rated

Ratings by John Campbell

After Down ended their 25 year hoodoo with a two point win over Armagh, John Campbell gives his rating on each and every player. Do you agree?


Michael Cunningham: Landed a point from a free, was rather erratic with kick-outs in the first half and had no chance with the two shots that beat him. 6

Anthony Doherty: On his championship debut it was a big ask to police Andrew Murnin but he gained in confidence as the match progressed. 6

Gerard McGovern: Covered soundly for the most part, made a few timely interceptions and used the ball well out of defence. 7

Darren O’Hagan: Lead the team well in his role as skipper by setting a fine example even though Jamie Clarke in particular presented him with problems on occasions in the early stages. 7

Daragh O’Hanlon: Always looked hungry for the ball, broke up several attacks through his positional sense and scored four points in an accomplished display. 7

Conaill McGovern: Kept Oisin O’Neill in check, tackled strongly and helped to minimise Armagh’s threat through the middle in the second half. 7

Caolan Mooney (above): One searing first half run underpinned his counter-attacking ability while his game intelligence and experience saw him make a huge contribution to his team’s performance. 8

Kevin McKernan: Played as sweeper in the first half but was seen in a more attacking role on occasions after the break as he produced his usual whole-hearted performance. 7

Niall Donnelly: Put in a strong shift, won a lot of ball and did good work in defence when it was most required. 7

Peter Turley: A solid effort from the Downpatrick man who played despite a hamstring injury and never shirked a tackle throughout. 7

Conor Maginn: Busy as always, he found it difficult to fend off the attentions of Paul Hughes at times but scored a point and kept going right until the end. 6

Shay Millar: Did his reputation no harm on his championship debut by tracking back when necessary, scoring a point and undertaking useful work in the middle third of the pitch. 7

Jerome Johnston: Tended to flit in and out of the game, scored an early point from a free but did not really threaten a great deal afterwards. 6

Ryan Johnston: Looked busy in the first-half, landed a point and was unselfish in his use of the ball. 7

Connaire Harrison: Turned in an impressive performance after a spell on the sidelines, landed two points and always looked dangerous when in possession. 7


Barry O’Hagan for Harrison (52mins): Proved a thorn in the side of the Armagh defence and scored a point. 6

David McKibben for Donnelly (52): Like O’Hagan, looked lively and helped himself to a point when the heat was on. 6

Niall McParland for Doherty (BC 50): Put himself about as he helped his side see out the game. 6

Joe Murphy for Jerome Johnston (58): Looked energetic and forceful but did not see enough of the ball in the closing stages. 6

Aidan Carr for Turley (71): Used his experience to help keep Armagh at bay in the frenetic finish. 6

Mark Poland for Maginn (71): Dropped deep to bolster Down’s bid to seal the game. 6


Blaine Hughes: Made a magnificent save from Harrison in the 18th minute, might have varied his kick-outs a little more but was sound otherwise. 7

James Morgan: Kept a tight rein on Jerome Johnston for the most part and still found time to support his attack when possible. Battled throughout. 7

Charlie Vernon: Started well in defence, then moved out to midfield but was called ashore as early as the 43rd minute. 6

Paul Hughes: Had quite a battle with Conor Maginn but nonetheless managed to push up when he could especially in the second quarter when Armagh were chasing the game. 6

Aaron McKay: Struggled on Shay Millar in the opening phase but looked much more confident and composed after the break. 7

Brendan Donaghy: Played as sweeper in the first half when he deployed his experience well, fielded the ball capably and initiated some counter-attacks. 6

Mark Shields (above): In his first game in almost four months, he put in a lot of hard work and highlighted his admirable overall effort with a superb early goal. 8

Stephen Sheridan: A wholehearted player whose commitment and work-rate throughout the match were admirable as was the point that he took so well. 7

Joe McElroy: A surprise selection, the Harps clubman put in some big challenges, picked up a yellow card in the feisty finish and battled until the end. 7

Aidan Forker: Tried hard to link defence and attack, got himself into some good positions and scored a fine point. 6

Oisin O’Neill: Showed early promise but then began to look out of his depth and was replaced by Anthony Duffy in the 47th minute. 5

Rory Grugan: A disappointing outing for the captain who never really got going despite an encouraging start and his substitution in the 57th minute was no big surprise. 5

Jamie Clarke: Tried hard to make things happen in the first half, was rather unusually held scoreless from play and was unable to prove an inspirational force. 6 

Stefan Campbell: Forced to play in a very deep role, his undoubted finishing skills never really came into play and his team suffered in consequence. 6

Andrew Murnin: Enthusiastic and inventive, he scored one goal, might have had another and did not always enjoy the rub of the green but kept going until the end. 7


Niall Grimley for Vernon (43): Made an immediate impact, won three kick-outs and looked more than useful. 7

Anthony Duffy for O’Neill (65): Made a big effort to impose himself on the game but found Down’s tigerish tackling too much. 5

Gavin McParland for Grugan (57): Might have made a bigger impact had he been introduced earlier. 5

Niall Rowland for Forker (65): Unable to make any headway as Down shut up shop. 5

Ciaran McKeever for Campbell (76): Not on long enough to be rated.

Ciaron O’Hanlon for Murnin 76: Not on long enough to be rated.


ratings by john campbell

Belfast Telegraph Digital

How to Complain

If you have a complaint about the editorial content of the Belfast Telegraph or Sunday Life then contact the Editor here. If you are not satisfied with the response provided then you can contact the Independent Press Standards Organisation here


From Belfast Telegraph