Intermittent Clouds Belfast Hi 21 °C | Lo 13°C

David Tremayne: Formula One risks running off the track after FIA takes easy way out

Wednesday, 24 September 2008

Lewis Hamilton lost  his case against the penalty that cost him victory in the Belgian Grand Prix

Lewis Hamilton lost his case against the penalty that cost him victory in the Belgian Grand Prix

The decision by the FIA International Court of Appeal to take the easy way out and rule that McLaren's appeal against Lewis Hamilton's time penalty in the Belgian Grand Prix was simply inadmissible has done nothing to stem the perception, both inside and outside Formula One, that the dice are loaded in Ferrari's favour and against McLaren.

Nor will many of the discrepancies which, thanks to that simple ruling, did not become the issues in court that they should have been.

First, there was race director Charlie Whiting's confirmation – twice – to McLaren sporting director Davy Ryan, during the 43rd lap of the race, that Hamilton had done enough in handing the lead back to Raikkonen. It is alleged that race stewards were minded not to apply a penalty, but they did so after an incident report was submitted by Whiting.

Then there is the question of if it was right at the Japanese Grand Prix at Fuji last year to allow Toro Rosso to appeal against a 25-second time penalty imposed on their driver Tonio Liuzzi. They were permitted to do so even though the appeal subsequently failed.

That judgement had been made by the former permanent FIA steward Tony Scott-Andrews who was generally regarded in the paddock as a man of impeccable honesty but who was fired by FIA president Max Mosley last December as he reorganised international stewarding. The FIA told McLaren it had been flawed, and Whiting claimed Scott-Andrews admitted a mistake had been made.

McLaren showed the court a statement in which Scott-Andrews emphatically denied such claims and said: "I have seen the email and I'm extremely surprised by its content. In short, it is grossly inaccurate and misleading."

As Whiting stuck by his version, McLaren's lawyer Mark Phillips QC highlighted this remarkable "discrepancy" and asked the judges "to reflect, when you come to consider your judgement, the way in which certain members of the FIA conducted themselves."

Falling back on an appeal simply being inadmissible is just too convenient. It is fundamentally damaging to a sport when spectators leave the event believing they have seen one thing, only to discover that their eyes deceived them. And when senior figures tell you that it is better that the fans are arguing over "controversial rulings by the referees" rather than the majesty of the on-track action, you know that the sport is in dire danger not just of losing its soul, but its very raison d'etre.

Not being a fan of F1 I do however pay passing àttention to the results . I have read and listened to the machinations of the governing body over the past couple of years, I think the ruling body are a disgrace and are totally biased toward the Red Machine. It would be interesting to see what hold Ferrari actually have over the rulers .

Posted by Dave Crooks | 24.09.08, 09:49 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details
In Pictures: Joey & Robert Dunlop

Joey & Robert: kings of the road.

Player of the Month

Columnist Comments

james_lawton

Gary Neville could be key to Wayne Rooney's form at Euros

You might have thought that ruling yourself out of the first two games of football's second most important international tournament with a shocking flash of irresponsibility was quite enough to focus the mind of the nation's most gifted player.

The World's 10 Sexiest Women

The World's 10 Sexiest Women

Columnist Comments

In Pictures: Funny Football Chants

In Pictures: Funny Football Chants

When fans display lyrical genius on the terraces

NiteLife: The Roost, Granny's, Bert's

Had a big night out? Click here to send your pics

In Pictures: Rugby through the years

In Pictures: Rugby through the years

A look back at the local archives

Belfast Telegraph Quizzes

Exams

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Baby Pictures

To send Us Your Baby snaps just Click here

Just Wed: Readers' Wedding Pictures

Just Born: Readers' Wedding Pictures

To send Us Your Wedding snaps just Click here

 

Latest Comments

Belfast Telegraph Home Delivery