Belfast Telegraph

Saturday 29 November 2014

Second fatality prompts emotive debate

Go for it: Ruby Walsh will go for World Hurdle glory on board Annie Power today
Go for it: Ruby Walsh will go for World Hurdle glory on board Annie Power today

Another day another fatality. The divisive issue of mortality and the horse made a swift return to Cheltenham with the loss in the penultimate race of Akdam to a broken leg two hurdles from home.

The horse that provoked the melee, Clarcam, survived but his jockey Bryan Cooper, flicked about like a football beneath flying hooves, sustained a suspected fracture to his leg. Cooper will heal. For Akdam there was simply no hope.

Then in the day's last race Stack The Deck pulled up lame with a fractured left foreknee and was later put down.

Today marks the first anniversary of the fall at this festival that left amateur jockey John Thomas McNamara paralysed, injecting heat into an already emotional debate provoked by Ruby Walsh on the opening day.

Walsh's forthright distinction between animal and jockey after the loss of Our Conor in Tuesday's feature race drew widespread criticism from an anti-racing lobby despairing at what they saw as the callous dismissal of animal welfare.

"Our Conor has no family, he's a horse. It's sad, but it has to be kept a little bit, in my eyes, in reality. Horses are horses. You can replace a horse. It's sad, but horses are animals, outside your back door. Humans are humans. They are inside your back door. You can replace a horse. You can't replace a human being. That's my feeling on it," Walsh had said.

He wasn't to know that the dangers inherent in the sport would be rammed home so graphically in the Fred Winter Juvenile Handicap, which also saw Tony McCoy and Wayne Hutchinson unseated on the first circuit. McCoy lay inert on the deck for long enough to prompt the erection of screens. He eventually resumed his feet.

Walsh was back in the saddle in the first race of the day and, by definition almost, in the winner's enclosure.

Faugheen had just given him his 41st Festival winner, extending an already towering record. Walsh was allowed an answer or two to questions about his stellar mount and his performance in the Neptune and then it was back to the value placed on a horse's life.

"We live in a liberal, democratic world," he said.

"I'm as entitled to my opinion as anyone else. If someone doesn't agree with it they're entitled to theirs. We look after horses like they're pets.

"There's a huge difference between your pet and your family. That's the point I was making.

"There's a big difference between you going home tonight and something's happened to your dog, and you go home tonight and something's happened to one of your kids. There's a huge difference.

"We look after horses like they are pets, and that's the feeling you get when something goes wrong.

"At the end of the day, it's still your pet. It ain't your son, your daughter, your brother, your sister.

"I love horses like the next man. There is no-one more sympathetic to horses than me. Trust me on that."

The lot of McNamara, presently struggling to establish a tolerable future at a rehab clinic in the north west of England, is today's searing example that makes Walsh's point.

Eleven years ago it was Kieran Kelly and Sean Cleary, close friends of Walsh both of whom failed to recover from injuries sustained in falls and died within three months of each other.

The spectre of their deaths is never far from the surface, and explains the hierarchy of emotions that register when a fatality strikes.

On a happier note Walsh was followed home in the Neptune by a horse that carried with it sharply contrasting emotions.

Cheltenham is not all about the winners, not all about the wealthy owners, the big stables, the superstar jockeys.

To get a horse to the starting line at this festival is victory enough for the more modest connections, persuaded by love or madness or both into ownership of a horse, or, more likely, a part of it.

John and Trish Westwood are luckier than most.

They were made a Christmas present of Ballyalton by their son Lee who, being the record money-winner on golf's European Tour – £20 million-plus and counting – was well able to meet the £33,000 asking-price 15 months ago at Brightwell's December sale here at Cheltenham.

Ballyalton came home behind Faugheen, gaining for his owners entry into racing's sacred circle, the winner's enclosure, which was repayment in full no matter what happens next.

Their son, an owner himself, was unable to make the annual pilgrimage from Florida, electing instead to attend a school production of Harry Potter starring his son, Sam.

Young Sam must have sent a spell across the Atlantic.

There was magic in the faces of his grandparents as they shared personal space with winning owner Rich Ricci and Irish racing royalty, trainer Willie Mullins and Walsh.

"It was a really lovely Christmas present," Trish said .

"We know he is going to be good. He's just learning. We spoke to Lee before the race and he was really excited. The phone will be ringing again soon."

You sensed that only watching his son lift the Claret Jug or slip a Green Jacket over his shoulders at the Masters next month could top a day like this.

"It's the Holy Grail, isn't it?" John said. "We are thrilled to bits. That's some horse that Faugheen.

"To come home second to him is no disgrace at all."

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Nightlife galleries

More

Latest Sport News

Stats Centre