Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport Rugby

France v Ireland Ratings

Published 13/02/2016

Alexandre Flanquart had an impact for France
Alexandre Flanquart had an impact for France


MAXIME MEDARD: Cut a smart line for the vital try 7/10

TEDDY THOMAS: Ineffective and duly withdrawn 6

MAXIME MERMOZ: Unable to put any stamp on proceedings 6

JONATHAN DANTY: Powerful but not damaging enough 6

VIRIMI VAKATAWA: Scant chance to run riot 5

JULES PLISSON: Kept his head at the vital moment 6

SEBASTIEN BEZY: Pushed the pace where possible 6

JEFFERSON POIROT: Unable to impose himself 5

GUILHEM GUIRADO (CAPT): A bruising effort 6

UINI ATONIO: Not a top-level scrummager 5


YOANN MAESTRI: Subdued showing 6

WENCESLAS LAURET: Unable to stamp his authority early on 6

YACOUBA CAMARA: High energy but needs more savvy 6

DAMIEN CHOULY: Gritty effort 7


CAMILLE CHAT (blood, for Guirado, 47-56, 62-73): Put himself about 6

RABAH SLIMANI (for Atonio, 44): Turned France's scrummaging on its head 8

EDDY BEN AROUS (for Poirot, 44): Helped France wreak scrum havoc 8

PAUL JEDRASIAK (for Maestri, 58): Physicality but little else 6

LOANN GOUJON (for Camara, 67): Quiet outing 6

MAXIME MACHENAUD (for Bezy, 56): Hardly affected the action 6

JEAN-MARC DOUSSAIN (for Danty, 76): Little chance to make an impact 6

HUGO BONNEVAL (for Thomas, 44): Kept his positioning well enough 6


ROB KEARNEY: Solid effort on return from injury 6

ANDREW TRIMBLE: Unable to get onto the ball enough 6

JARED PAYNE: Solid but botched a couple of chances 6

ROBBIE HENSHAW: Physical but never able to break free 6

DAVE KEARNEY: Injury cut his day short 6

JOHNNY SEXTON: Kicked well, did what he could 7

CONOR MURRAY: Tactically as astute as ever 7

JACK McGRATH: Unable to cope at the scrum after France's changes 5

RORY BEST (CAPT): Overpowered in the tight 5

NATHAN WHITE: Struggled with Slimani's power 5

MIKE McCARTHY: Solid showing 6

DEVIN TONER: Unable to control the lineout 5

CJ STANDER: Faded again in his second cap 6

SEAN O'BRIEN: Injury cut his day short 6

JAMIE HEASLIP: Unable to gain any traction 6


RICHARDT STRAUSS (for Best, 71): Could not stop the scrum rot 5

JAMES CRONIN (for McGrath, 70): Another owerawed by France's scrum power 5

TADHG FURLONG (for White, 62): Struggled at the set-piece too 5

DONNACHA RYAN (for McCarthy, blood, 34-40, 62): Put himself about 6

TOMMY O'DONNELL (for O'Brien, 20): Worked hard 6

IAN MADIGAN (for Sexton, 69): Quiet effort 6

FERGUS McFADDEN (for D Kearney, 28): Precious little chance to shine 6

How to Complain

If you have a complaint about the editorial content of the Belfast Telegraph or Sunday Life then contact the Editor here. If you are not satisfied with the response provided then you can contact the Independent Press Standards Organisation here

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph