Belfast Telegraph

Thursday 25 December 2014

Red card costs Ulster £400,000 - but Ferris doesn't blame Heineken Cup ref

Off night: ref Garces red cards Jared Payne (15) to the dismay of captain  Johann Muller (centre)
Off night: ref Garces red cards Jared Payne (15) to the dismay of captain Johann Muller (centre)
Ulster's Ruan Pienaar during the Heineken Cup quarter-final against Saracens at Ravenhill
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Barry McGuigan enjoys the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Saracens' Chris Ashton scores a try against Ulster during Saturday's Heineken Cup quarter-final match at Ravenhill
Heineken Cup quarter-final Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Ulster's Johann Muller during the Heineken Cup quarter-final against Saracens at Ravenhill
John Afoa charges down Owen Farrell during theHeineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Jared Payne clashes with Alex Goode during the Heineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Jared Payne clashes with Alex Goode and sees red for this challenge during the Heineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
John Afoa charges down Owen Farrell during the Heineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Ulster's Nick Williams sets up an attack against Saracens during Saturday's Heineken Cup Quarter Final match at Ravenhill
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Tommy Bowe charges at the Saracens defence during the Heineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Jared Payne clashes with Alex Goode during the Heineken Cup quarter final game between Ulster and Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast. Photo: Pacemaker
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Ulster Rugby fans at Ravenhill for the Heineken Cup quarter-final between Ulster and Saracens, Saturday 5 April 2014.
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast
Heineken Cup quarter-final: Ulster v Saracens at Ravenhill, Belfast

French rugby ref Jerome Garces' controversial red-carding of Ulster star Jared Payne after just four minutes of Saturday's Heineken Cup quarter-final may have spelt up to a £400,000 loss for the Ravenhill coffers.

A battling 14-man performance by a side further hit by injuries to key players over the remaining 76 minutes just came up short as rivals Saracens scraped home 17-15 at the new Ravenhill.

The disappointment of the Ulster team and 18,000 home fans was heightened by the belief they could and should have won had New Zealander Payne stayed on the field, as TV replays seemed to suggest his penalised challenge on Sarries' Alex Goode was not a sending-off offence.

It also means Ulster missing out on a financial bonanza from a semi-final and possible final appearance.

With a minimum of 125,000 euro (£103,000) banked from Saturday's quarter-final, an Aviva semi-final against Clermont would have brought in at least double that with the final generating at least the same again, distributed through the governing IRFU.

Backing for Payne remains resolute against the backdrop of what might have been. Rugby's rule book deems a tackle on an airborne player as dangerous play, the offence for which Payne was dismissed. But TV replays show more of an accidental collision with Payne's eyes always following the flight of the ball.

Stephen Ferris summed up the magnanimous mood in a dejected Ulster camp by refusing to condemn ref Garces. "Red was very harsh," Ferris said, but added: "It's not the referee's fault, it's not Jared's fault, it's just a decision that swung the game in their favour."

 

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Nightlife galleries

More

Latest Sport News

Stats Centre