Belfast Telegraph

Home Sport Rugby

New Zealand v France ratings


Ben Smith: Faultless display at the back, but largely untroubled 7/10

Nehe Milner-Skudder: The perfect foil for Savea's power with trickery to spare 8/10

Conrad Smith: Class personified, at the centre of everything 8/10

Ma'a Nonu: At his punishing best as France wilted 8/10

Julian Savea: A phenomenon. Unstoppable 9/10

Dan Carter: Unusually untidy but that hardly mattered 7/10

Aaron Smith: So perceptive in exploiting space 9/10

Wyatt Crockett: Night cut short by injury 7/10

Dane Coles: Untroubled at the set-piece 8/10

Owen Franks: Solid shift 7/10

Brodie Retallick: Superlative effort 9/10

Sam Whitelock: Another potent showing 8/10

Jerome Kaino: Slugged it out all night 8/10

Richie McCaw (capt): Led from the front as always 8/10

Kieran Read: Tied it all together at the back of the scrum 8/10


Joe Moody (for Crockett, 17): Did not put a foot wrong 7/10

Charlie Faumuina (for Franks, 51): Sustained the intensity 7/10

Victor Vito (for Kaino, 65): Put himself about 6/10

Sam Cane (for McCaw, 74): Short but sweet cameo 6/10

Tawera Kerr-Barlow (for Aaron Smith, 65): Bagged his brace well 8/10

Beauden Barrett (for Milner-Skudder, 41): Swept up well at the back 6/10

Sonny Bill Williams (for Conrad Smith, 51): Hardly into the action 6/10

UNUSED: Keven Mealamu


Scott Spedding: Overwhelmed at the back 4/10

Noa Nakaitaci: Outmuscled by Savea 2/10

Alexandre Dumoulin: Battled manfully to create amid the chaos 5/10

Wesley Fofana: Another to show up despite the shambles around him 5/10

Brice Dulin: Unable to contain the All Blacks 3/10

Frederic Michalak: Error-strewn even before the injury 4/10

Morgan Parra: Could not marshal any kind of resistance 4/10

Eddy Ben Arous: Bested in every area 3/10

Guilhem Guirado: Not good enough 3/10

Rabah Slimani: Ditto his front-row colleagues 3/10

Pascal Pape: Wayward focus cost France dear 3/10

Yoann Maestri: Went missing when it mattered 3/10

Thierry Dusautoir: His pack crumbled around him 5/10

Bernard Le Roux: Nowhere near the required level 4/10

Louis Picamoles: One of few to put himself about 5/10


Dimitri Szarzewski (for Guirado, 56): No real lift 3/10

Vincent Debaty (for Ben Arous, 61): Scrum still creaked 3/10

Nicolas Mas (for Slimani, 60): Another way below par 3/10

Damien Chouly (for Picamoles, 72): Short but quiet cameo 3/10

Yannick Nyanga (for Pape, 47): Failed to impose himself 3/10

Remi Tales (for Michalak, 10mins): Could not stop the house of cards tumbling down 4/10

23 Mathieu Bastareaud (for Dumoulin, 61): Trucked it up to no avail 4/10

UNUSED: Rory Kockott.

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?


From Belfast Telegraph