Belfast Telegraph

Home Sport Rugby

Scotland Ratings


GREIG TONKS: Looked secure at the back as he dealt with a succession of high balls. 6

SEAN LAMONT: The veteran wing gave another dependable display. Nothing spectacular but always there to clean things up. 5

RICHIE VERNON: Should have put Tonks clear early on but overcooked his pass. Did not get too many chances to drive forward though. 5

MATT SCOTT: Showed he is nearly back to his best as he punched holes in the Italian defence. Set up Henry Pyrgos try with perfectly-timed pass. 7

RORY HUGHES: The Castlemilk-born wing could have marked his debut with a touchdown but fumbled a high Tonks kick. 6

DUNCAN WEIR: Making just his second start of the year and it showed with a series of erratic passes. Made amends with 11 points with his boot. 6

SAM HIDALGO-CLYNE: The Guinness Pro12 young player of the year was lucky to get away with a charged down kick just after the interval. 5

ADAM ASHE: Carried well but the Glasgow seldom seems to make much ground. 5

JOHN HARDIE: The latest Kilted Kiwi put in a tireless display as he tackled everything in sight. Impressive display before limping off with cramp. 7

ALASDAIR STROKOSCH: Took over the captaincy from sick skipper Grant Gilchrist and stepped up to the plate with a determined display. 7

JIM HAMILTON: Handed his chance to start in Gilchrist's absence and for once kept his nose clean. 6

RICHIE GRAY: The giant lock looked rusty against a poweful Azzurri pack. Might need another run out before the World Cup. 5

MIKE CUSACK: The English-born prop was handed his first start but found himself under pressure at the scrum. 5

STUART McINALLY: The hooker finally made his Test debut after a stomach bug ruled him out last week but looked over excited at times. 6

GORDON REID: Could not stop the Italians dominating the scrum. His World Cup hopes appear to be hanging by a thread. 5


ALASDAIR DICKINSON (for REID, 46): Steadied the scrum. 6

WILLIAM NEL (for CUSACK, 49): Looked assured on his debut. 6

ROSS FORD (for ROSS FORD, 53): Needs to improve in the loose. 5

HAMISH WATSON (for HARDIE, 55): Made a positive impact. 5

HENRY PYRGOS (for HIDALGO-CLYNE, 61): Popped up in the right place to finally get Scotland back to winning ways. 7

DAMIEN HOYLAND (for HUGHES, 62): Never saw enough of the ball. 4

PETER HORNE (for VERNE, 68): Made an impressive drive before playing a part in winning try. 7

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?


From Belfast Telegraph