Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport Rugby Six Nations

Best is the choice if Schmidt doesn't take risk on Irish captaincy

By Tony Ward

Published 09/01/2016

In the running: Rory Best and Sean O'Brien are two candidates to take over as captain of Ireland
In the running: Rory Best and Sean O'Brien are two candidates to take over as captain of Ireland
Joe Schmidt

Just how important is the role of captain in modern-day rugby? Still very, I would suggest. Nowhere near what it once was but still vital in inspirational terms.

Naturally, captains differ according to personality traits but the best leaders are those with whom players feel comfortable when approaching. No more than great players make great coaches do great players make great captains.

I always cite Ciaran Fitzgerald as the best captain I played under, for a number of reasons. What Fitzy had was special in that he was a naturally aggressive front-row forward who followed the ball like a magnet. By dint of positional demand, he led from the front. Where he went the rest followed.

But because that came naturally, when he spoke EVERYONE listened. You could hear a pin drop.

You knew he would never ask anything of you he didn't demand of himself. In addition he was a great listener. He made it his business to talk to all of the players in the build-up to a big game. You knew when you were in conversation with him that he was listening and was hearing what you were saying.

So when it came to match day and those final motivational moments, what Fitzgerald possessed over and above the ordinary was an innate ability to strike at individual chords through a collective button.

That takes some doing without trampling on madcap egos or precious sensitivities. Communicator, mediator, motivator, facilitator, psychoanalyst... all of those things were a necessity in the best captains of old.

Today it is a different game entirely, with the load nowhere near the same. Now between head coaches, assistant coaches, attacking coaches, defensive coaches, kicking coaches, scrum coaches, psychologists and whatever else, there is little time for the captain to take overall control.

There are exceptions and, as everyone who played with him will tell you, Paul O'Connell was one.

So for Joe Schmidt having to replace him is a huge ask. For me there are six, possibly seven candidates.

In no particular order other than position they are Rory Best, Peter O'Mahony, Sean O'Brien, Jamie Heaslip, Conor Murray, Jonathan Sexton and possibly Rob Kearney. With Munster captain O'Mahony recovering from injury and Murray still not back to full fitness, that reduces the list to five.

Add to that Kearney the elder and Sexton still taking small steps back to effective Test impact and in leaving the first-choice half-backs and full-back to get their own houses in order, it reduces further still.

I know Schmidt has a special working relationship with his out-half but for the most logical of reasons - form and confidence - I believe his playmaker in chief should be given time and space to look after himself.

Heaslip has already had a shot at the role. As a player he is under-appreciated and as one who advocated him for the role I feel that as a communicator he sells himself short. But he is still an on-field leader, irrespective of who wears the armband.

That leaves two, with one appearing a little out of left-field.

If it is to be a short-term appointment - as in the upcoming Six Nations - then at 33 and with 89 caps, Best is the man, and I for one have no problem with that.

Obviously I haven't been privy to experiencing him up close in that role but in almost every other way he mirrors Fitzgerald, apart the same position.

Should Schmidt choose that route I doubt there will be a dissenting voice.

But if I do have a bias it is in relation to the ideal position for captaincy on a rugby field.

All things being equal - and with respect to Fitzgerald, O'Connell, Keith Wood, Brian O'Driscoll, Karl Mullen and all the great leaders who have gone before - it would be for one with leadership qualities positioned at six, seven, eight or nine. That is the fulcrum of the side and if you can pull a leader from there you're in bonus territory.

On the assumption he is over the worst of his injury issues then the 41-times capped O'Brien at 28 is the most logical way to a new beginning.

Whether he has what it takes to become a Fitzgerald or an O'Connell only time will tell but there is only one way to find out. Schmidt is not afraid to take a punt and in O'Brien he would at least be taking a calculated one.

The safe call would be to go with the Ulster captain; the bold would be to back the Tullow Tank.

As regards Andy Farrell's appointment as new defensive coach to replace Les Kiss, like most I was surprised but equally as an avid follower of rugby League fully appreciate what he brings to the cross-code move.

That union is a more complex game is a given. Defensively, however, league has tightened up union. I hate what it's brought but the expertise and organisation in implementing systems is beyond dispute.

So when O'Driscoll, O'Connell and Keith Earls comment in such a positive way about Farrell's appointment, that's good enough for me.

If I have one wish for the Six Nations defence (even if it means losing that title) it is that we move beyond a great kick and chase.

There was a time when we were content to win ugly, but we are now a much more formidable opponent and stronger rugby playing nation.

We are not looking for a reinvention of the wheel but just a little more risk-taking. Off-loading in the tackle is not a dirty word but when executed at pace a la Leinster under Schmidt, it is a thing of beauty.

Belfast Telegraph

How to Complain

If you have a complaint about the editorial content of the Belfast Telegraph or Sunday Life then contact the Editor here. If you are not satisfied with the response provided then you can contact the Independent Press Standards Organisation here

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting? customercare@belfasttelegraph.co.uk

Read More

From Belfast Telegraph