Belfast Telegraph

UK Website Of The Year

Home Sport Rugby Ulster

Ulster Rugby player ratings - how did Neil Doak's men hold up against Munster?

By Jonathan Bradley

Published 11/05/2015

Ulster's Tommy Bowe scores a try against Munster during Saturdays Guinness PRO12 game at the Kingspan stadium.
Ulster's Tommy Bowe scores a try against Munster during Saturdays Guinness PRO12 game at the Kingspan stadium.

It was an exciting evening at Kingspan Stadium on Saturday, with Ulster clinching a last gasp 23-23 draw with Munster in their PRO12 clash. But, how did the players do?

Louis Ludik 6

The fullback was able to join the attack well and ran with purpose but, after picking up a knock to the hand, misjudged a few in the air.


Tommy Bowe 7

Grabbed Ulster’s first of the day, and nearly created another, but didn’t display usual authority in air.


Jared Payne 8

The number 13 ran some excellent lines and it was only a great tackle that stopped him sealing the draw before ball went to Marshall.


Darren Cave 7

In just under an hour of work, Cave produced a strong all round showing, including some solid tackling, clever running, and a turnover.


Peter Nelson 6

The young winger didn’t see as much ball as Bowe but he did manage to show some ability with the boot before injury.


Paddy Jackson 9

Aside from the nerveless conversion that earned a draw, Jackson produced another composed showing at out-half.


Ruan Pienaar 8

Struggling with a hamstring strain before kick-off yet distributed well and executed play with a calmness that is rarely matched.


Callum Black 6

Wasn’t able to make any headway against Stephen Archer in the scrum and departed with Munster firmly in the ascendancy.


Rory Best 8

The hooker won’t have been impressed to see three of his own lineout throws picked off by Munster but his work around the park was vital.


Wiehahn Herbst 7

The burly prop was throwing himself into contact before his untimely exit and Ulster’s scrum never seemed to cope in his absence.


Dan Tuohy 7

Decision to attempt a grubber was certainly curious but the lock’s physical presence was welcome throughout.


Franco van der Merwe 7

Will have been irked by Munster’s clear superiority in the lineout but the lock’s play in the loose was more than solid.


Iain Henderson 8

Was exerting a huge influence on the game, and was arguably Ulster’s best player, before late moment of rashness brought red card.


Chris Henry 7

Injury to Tommy O’Donnell deprived him of a direct battle with an Irish rival but Henry again put in an impressive showing full of industry.


Roger Wilson 6

The number 8 had been a prominent carrier, albeit with a couple of handling errors, before having to depart with an injury.



Robbie Diack (for Wilson,29) Contributed well in what was a lengthy stint off the bench. 7

Bronson Ross (for Herbst, 51) Unable to get a foothold come scrum time. 5

Stuart McCloskey (for Cave, 55) Ran powerfully and was involved in the late drama. 6

Andrew Warwick (for Black, 61) Brought into a struggling scrum, added just a touch more solidity. 6

Paul Marshall (for Nelson, 63) Forced out of position but still popped up with the crucial try. 6

Your Comments

COMMENT RULES: Comments that are judged to be defamatory, abusive or in bad taste are not acceptable and contributors who consistently fall below certain criteria will be permanently blacklisted. The moderator will not enter into debate with individual contributors and the moderator’s decision is final. It is Belfast Telegraph policy to close comments on court cases, tribunals and active legal investigations. We may also close comments on articles which are being targeted for abuse. Problems with commenting?

Read More

Widget page
Widget page

From Belfast Telegraph